Harlequin wrote:This reminds me of the very successful method which Valve employ in their games. Their developer commentaries also provide much insight as to how to make games easily accessible for a modern audience.
That's the best method for a FPS or RPG-type game, IMO. No tutorials, just help messages every time something new happens or the first time someone is expected to do something. Ideally you'd pace it - make the player do something, repeat until they've mastered it and can do it by themselves, then on to the next skill.
In something like SG that would be really distracting though - if you read the text, you die. Maybe something like a postmortem instead: "You died, a bullet hit you." And then a random selection of tips each time: "Listen for the sound a bullet makes when fired." "Hoof shots are very useful for deflecting bullets, use <R> to aim them while the power zone is extended." "You can shoot bullets back down the web, but eventually they'll return even faster." "These enemies shoot bullets: ..." "Watch out, these bullets can be fired diagonally across the web."
Patronising, maybe, but advanced users could make it disappear by squeezing the trustly LT.
Like the "death cam" in Team Fortress 2 -- or DOOM. Or other difficult-to-understand-at-first games, like "I, Robot." Could be done with style.
Here's a recent entry on Play This Thing - Greg Costikyan's blog-type site that usually highlights interesting games. This one though mentions the recent Gamasutra article. The main point is that he suggests that what comes next from Jeff should be a "gateway drug" - something that leads Geometry Wars players towards Space Giraffe - which I wholeheartedly agree with. I think just making a much more accessible game would be a good start (I'll always look for back-catalogue when I find something I like), but adding a few more sophisticated mechanics like SG employs would hopefully prepare gamers for a little more complexity than the simple pleasures of something like GW.
That's quite cool. Definitely a sentiment we all feel.
Mayhem wrote:Without beating about the bush, Jeff's blog comments regarding the performance of SG compared to Frogger have gone down extremely badly in a number of places I inhabit, prompting some very negative comments in response from many users.
Frogger is, and always has been, completely worthless and shit. I think some folks are so fixated on vintage or retro gaming that they don't see that most of it is utter garbage. I personally think Jeff has every right to feel more than mildly f*cked off that Frogger out-sold SG. One is a mindless and unrewarding game of moving between gaps in crappy sprites, the other is a sophisticated, innovative and immersive arcade shooter with killer audio-visual production values. It's just not even remotely fair.
GeeZa wrote:Frogger is, and always has been, completely worthless and shit. I think some folks are so fixated on vintage or retro gaming that they don't see that most of it is utter garbage. I personally think Jeff has every right to feel more than mildly f*cked off that Frogger out-sold SG. One is a mindless and unrewarding game of moving between gaps in crappy sprites, the other is a sophisticated, innovative and immersive arcade shooter with killer audio-visual production values. It's just not even remotely fair.
I do quite like Frogger myself. Indeed, it was the first game that I found myself unconsciously playing in real life. I think that you are being rather unkind to SG, however, as I do not think it either mindless or unrewarding and I do not believe that any sprites appear in it.
Last edited by Harlequin on Sat Dec 01, 2007 7:43 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
frogger was good in 1983 or whatever. I'd much rather have something new nowadays though.
also not bothered about nes/snes games on WiiVC. nes games especially are just shit nowadays, with very few exceptions.
it's crap that SG sold so badly though... still, it's out there, and lots of people like it. it's not like it's going to 'disappear from the shelves' anytime soon either.
To be honest I never "got" Minter's games, even back in the 80's. So my guess is that SG is not my cup of tea. However, the reason why I joined this forum in the first place was because I always found him to be a facinating personality and respected that he wanted to do something different, even though it never appealed to me personally.
Minter, along with names like Hubbard, Galway, Braben, Fasoulas, Yates and Rignall will always be a part of some of my fondest childhood memories.
And if I had a HD I'd most likely buy SG, if only to support Yak and Giles.
Harlequin wrote:I do quite like Frogger myself. Indeed, it was the first game that I found myself unconsciously playing in real life.
That's fine of course, I've played enough Frogger too. I remember it vividly on the old Atari 400. I never thought, and still don't think, that it's a particularly good or interesting game. I'd rather play Space Duel, which you most certainly can't unconsciously play in real life.
I think that you are being rather unkind to SG, however, as I do not think it either mindless or unrewarding and I do not believe that any sprites appear in it.
PurpleChair wrote:Come to think of it, a mute social MMO where you play as a deer and canter around a magical forest world would probably be pretty popular round here.
Giles and Yak seem to like it.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
PurpleChair wrote:Come to think of it, a mute social MMO where you play as a deer and canter around a magical forest world would probably be pretty popular round here.