Oh, come on... it's perfectly valid criticism of United - they were English football at the time, and they snubbed the FA Cup. It hasn't been the same since. Mainly because they were allowed back into it, which should not have happened. Leave them out for a few years to learn them good, was my proposal. Of course, the pussies who run the FA were too shit to do so.Zoot wrote:Yeah, Man Utd are responsible for all things bad in football - probably including Leeds Utd being in Division 1Mat T wrote:Is it me or is the FA Cup going a bit downhill?
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.![]()
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.
FOOTBALL: Season 2007/08 Discussion Thread.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
What a complete load of utter bollocks, that is. Yes they snubbed the FA Cup, but the tournament hasn't been ruined because of it - just ask Huddersfield. Oldham et al.Goatboy wrote:Oh, come on... it's perfectly valid criticism of United - they were English football at the time, and they snubbed the FA Cup. It hasn't been the same since. Mainly because they were allowed back into it, which should not have happened. Leave them out for a few years to learn them good, was my proposal. Of course, the pussies who run the FA were too shit to do so.Zoot wrote:Yeah, Man Utd are responsible for all things bad in football - probably including Leeds Utd being in Division 1Mat T wrote:Is it me or is the FA Cup going a bit downhill?
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.![]()
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.
You might as well say that the European Chamionship will be crap from now on because England didn't try hard enough to qualify. And, after all, we invented the game, so those foreigners have no right to be better at it than us, do they?
Zoot wrote:Yeah, Man Utd are responsible for all things bad in football - probably including Leeds Utd being in Division 1Mat T wrote:Is it me or is the FA Cup going a bit downhill?
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.![]()
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.
What part of my post was wrong? They did pull out of the FA Cup, there was massive uproar (rightfully so) and I think the cup has changed since then.
Nowt to do with Leeds fella.
I just don't think that you can blame any apparent apathy today on Man Utd not playing for one year. And do you not honestly believe that United playing in that World Cup thing was not only sanctioned by the FA but also encouraged by them? Of course the FA wanted to show everyone else in teh world just how good English club football was as represented by th best team in England.Mat T wrote:Zoot wrote:Yeah, Man Utd are responsible for all things bad in football - probably including Leeds Utd being in Division 1Mat T wrote:Is it me or is the FA Cup going a bit downhill?
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.![]()
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.![]()
What part of my post was wrong? They did pull out of the FA Cup, there was massive uproar (rightfully so) and I think the cup has changed since then.
Nowt to do with Leeds fella.
If you want to blame someone for the FA Cup not being glamarous, blame Sky for killing football on the terraces. Blame ITV for pinching TV Highlights from the BBC.
Personally, I think that the people who are dissatisfied with the Cup are those whose teams are not in it anymore. It's still a great competition, and will be even better if Utd extend even further their winning record.
Lord, it could be only a couple of years until Utd have the record for most League Titles AND FA Cups. Ah, 'twould be bliss indeed.....
I was more impressed with top whoring fella Martin Edwards literally spunking away a chunk of the club's profits by slinging his manky Manc mess up a high-class, dead-eyed, Rio lady flesh-tube.Zoot wrote:I just don't think that you can blame any apparent apathy today on Man Utd not playing for one year. And do you not honestly believe that United playing in that World Cup thing was not only sanctioned by the FA but also encouraged by them? Of course the FA wanted to show everyone else in teh world just how good English club football was as represented by th best team in England.
Still, that Edmundo goal...
Man, we'll always have that.
Be as revisionist as you like, Zoot, but Utd snubbing their home nation's most respected cup competition for a pointless, big-bollocks swagger-about in Brazil /was/ embarrassing and wrong. Ferguson could easily have told the FA to shit off.
It was definitely the beginning of the end of the FA Cup's unassailable charisma.
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
Can't believe I'm going to say this but....I don't blame ManU at all. They were forced to enter the World Club Championship by the FA under instruction from FIFA and to help ease ManU's fixture congestion, the FA gave them the option of not entering the FA Cup. IMO blame the FA or FIFA but not ManU.
All of which is academic anyway as I don't think that particular incident is in any way a major part of the Cups demise. Look at the media emphasis on the Premier League and the Champions League, the fact that it's become hugely predictable and one of the big-4 has won the last 12 finals, the fact that just surviving in the Premiere League is far more valuable than winning the cup.
And while I can understand the big-4 and maybe those fighting relegation putting out weakened teams, can anyone explain, as pointed out by someone on TV, why Blackburn who had nothing else to play for this season didn't field their strongest team?
All of which is academic anyway as I don't think that particular incident is in any way a major part of the Cups demise. Look at the media emphasis on the Premier League and the Champions League, the fact that it's become hugely predictable and one of the big-4 has won the last 12 finals, the fact that just surviving in the Premiere League is far more valuable than winning the cup.
And while I can understand the big-4 and maybe those fighting relegation putting out weakened teams, can anyone explain, as pointed out by someone on TV, why Blackburn who had nothing else to play for this season didn't field their strongest team?
fog wrote:Can't believe I'm going to say this but....I don't blame ManU at all. They were forced to enter the World Club Championship by the FA under instruction from FIFA and to help ease ManU's fixture congestion, the FA gave them the option of not entering the FA Cup. IMO blame the FA or FIFA but not ManU.
All of which is academic anyway as I don't think that particular incident is in any way a major part of the Cups demise. Look at the media emphasis on the Premier League and the Champions League, the fact that it's become hugely predictable and one of the big-4 has won the last 12 finals, the fact that just surviving in the Premiere League is far more valuable than winning the cup.
And while I can understand the big-4 and maybe those fighting relegation putting out weakened teams, can anyone explain, as pointed out by someone on TV, why Blackburn who had nothing else to play for this season didn't field their strongest team?
Re Blackburn - think "Not getting players who we need to sell inJanuary cup-tied" as being high on the agenda
Yeah - see you in round 3 again next season.Zoot wrote:Munky wrote:Well they've fucking ruined it for me this year.I love being drawn against Villa.
Re Re Blackburn - They're still in with a good shout of Europe, so maybe they don't want the distraction of a cup run?
But then again, it's not the first premiership team that Coventry have embarrasingly dumped out of a cup this season.
Because they do have something to play forfog wrote: can anyone explain, as pointed out by someone on TV, why Blackburn who had nothing else to play for this season didn't field their strongest team?
They can easily get a European spot. Much more valuable and much easier to achieve than winning the FA Cup.
-------------------------
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
That would be a terrible idea. To honestly claim that a team who performs over 6 matches deserves a Champions League place over a team who outperformed them over 38 games is ridiculous. Right now the 4th Champions League place is hotly contested, first 3 clearly wrapped up for Arsenal, Utd and Chelski.goldfish wrote:Best way to sort the FA cup out would be to swap the 4th place Premiership entry into the Champions' League so that the cup winners go through instead.
Simon
-------------------------
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
- illlogickill
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2206
- Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 1:27 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: Wreckhead Ad
- Location: Sunny Stoke-on-Trent
Did they ever come to a conclusion if the FA Cup 3rd Round draw was a farce or not after some numpty called out the wrong number? It tainted the whole competition for me.Zoot wrote:Munky wrote:Well they've fucking ruined it for me this year.I love being drawn against Villa.
"I'm not drunk! I'm always loud, friendly and clumsy!"
Xbox Live :- Wreckhead Ad
Twitter/PS3 :- Mindlessdrivel
Xbox Live :- Wreckhead Ad
Twitter/PS3 :- Mindlessdrivel



