Don't you be hedging your bets now, Andy.............Sickboy wrote:Luton playing for their lives. Talbot is Premiership quality. We're gonna get mugged here, if we don't wake up in the second half...
FOOTBALL: Season 2007/08 Discussion Thread.
Played, Luton. Deffo the better side. Well deserved - and a spot of poetic justice after the depressing story about Liverpool not being prepared to donate the revenue.
Shows what little we have in reserve, too. Too many average players. Hyypia all done, for sure. Riise's own goal was poor, but his miss was even more embarrassing (free shot, loads of space, on his left foot...)
I've got a feeling Rafa may well be out before the end of the season.
Shows what little we have in reserve, too. Too many average players. Hyypia all done, for sure. Riise's own goal was poor, but his miss was even more embarrassing (free shot, loads of space, on his left foot...)
I've got a feeling Rafa may well be out before the end of the season.
I really wish that you hadn't said that - I wanted to make a joke about Liverpool playing for the replay on compassionate grounds!Sickboy wrote:Played, Luton. Deffo the better side. Well deserved - and a spot of poetic justice after the depressing story about Liverpool not being prepared to donate the revenue.
And that would be a bad thing, why?Sickboy wrote: I've got a feeling Rafa may well be out before the end of the season.
He never claimed it was a bad thing.Zoot wrote:And that would be a bad thing, why?Sickboy wrote: I've got a feeling Rafa may well be out before the end of the season.
I think we're all in agreement Rafa will never win the Premiership.
-------------------------
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Blimey, Rib, that's twice in 24 hours that you have defended Sickers' position - you going soft or sommat?Rib wrote:He never claimed it was a bad thing.Zoot wrote:And that would be a bad thing, why?Sickboy wrote: I've got a feeling Rafa may well be out before the end of the season.![]()
I think we're all in agreement Rafa will never win the Premiership.
I think it'll be a euphemistic old "mutual consent" type-thing. Rafa pissed on his chips with the owners after the outburst last year and his mind has been elsewhere ever since.
And, yes, I think it is a bad thing. But I can't see him being given the back-up to bring in the two or three quality players we still need - even after a clearout.
Whatever happens, we'll always have that five-man midfield against Wigan at home...
And, yes, I think it is a bad thing. But I can't see him being given the back-up to bring in the two or three quality players we still need - even after a clearout.
Whatever happens, we'll always have that five-man midfield against Wigan at home...
Aye: strong rumours he'll be off in the summer, possibly under his own steam. If you like yer rumours then there's also the one about the Americans allegedly jacking their hand in sooner rather than later too (loads of sub-rumours about 'why' there, too ... )Sickboy wrote:I think it'll be a euphemistic old "mutual consent" type-thing. Rafa pissed on his chips with the owners after the outburst last year and his mind has been elsewhere ever since.
And, yes, I think it is a bad thing. But I can't see him being given the back-up to bring in the two or three quality players we still need - even after a clearout.
Whatever happens, we'll always have that five-man midfield against Wigan at home...
I'm for Rafa staying, strange selections notwithstanding. I can't think of anyone I;d rather have there at the moment. And on that basis I can only see us going futher backwards if they get shut.
But, yeah. I think they should have given the gate to Luton as well.
I'm not going to agree with that - no this year, like. But still.Rib wrote:stuff about we all agree Rafa wont win the premiership
So there.
- mac monkey
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1114
- Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 8:09 pm 0
- Location: Just about here.
Kev out of the 100 million + pounds RB has spent since he's been at LFC can you tell me the class players he's added to the squad, not including Torres Agger or Babel ( who for my liking gets nowhere near the amount of games he should)?
Not having a pop, just a question.
Not having a pop, just a question.
Bill Shankly:
"I was the best manager in Britain because I was never devious or cheated anyone. I'd break my wife's legs if I played against her, but I'd never cheat her."
"I was the best manager in Britain because I was never devious or cheated anyone. I'd break my wife's legs if I played against her, but I'd never cheat her."
Well, I won't agree with Rib's assertion out of blind priciniple reallymac monkey wrote:Kev out of the 100 million + pounds RB has spent since he's been at LFC can you tell me the class players he's added to the squad, not including Torres Agger or Babel ( who for my liking gets nowhere near the amount of games he should)?
But as to class players. That's difficult really. First off it seems to me that most people's definition of 'class' boils down to reputation followed by immediate impact in Premiership, mostly the latter. Torres ticks both those boxes, Agger just the latter. Van Nistelrooy and Ronaldo had immediate positive effect at United, whereas Poborsky and Veron didn't, for example. Likewise, Ballack and Schevchenko at Chelsea.
You missed Renia by the way
So, I'm not sure it's useful to judge Rafa on 'class' signings. They either gell or they don't.
I've said several times here before, by far the most insightful of managers when it comes to a) spotting real class and b) spending relatively nothing on them is Wenger by a mile.
Nope - fair question, mate.Not having a pop, just a question.
- PaulEMoz
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11795
- Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2003 12:00 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: paulemoz
- Location: The Devil's Temple, 5th Floor.
- Contact:
Pheeew.
That was a mite uncomfortable. It could have gone either way, but Stoke probably should have won, given that five-minute spell where they had some incredible chances.
That said, we had a couple of good moments too. We just suffered from too many bad final balls or bad touches at just the wrong moment. So, I'm happy with a replay... as long as it doesn't go the same way as last year's replay...
That was a mite uncomfortable. It could have gone either way, but Stoke probably should have won, given that five-minute spell where they had some incredible chances.
That said, we had a couple of good moments too. We just suffered from too many bad final balls or bad touches at just the wrong moment. So, I'm happy with a replay... as long as it doesn't go the same way as last year's replay...
It all went wrong for Liverpool when your lot forgot that youhad bloody good youngsters who actually grew up up on Merseyside and decided to buy them in instead. Fowler, Owen, Gerrard - heart and soul LFC. Why is Kuyt not as good in the UK as in Holland? Because the dutch don't play the same football as we do, and they don't have the derbies and pet hates that we do.KevG wrote:Well, I won't agree with Rib's assertion out of blind priciniple reallymac monkey wrote:Kev out of the 100 million + pounds RB has spent since he's been at LFC can you tell me the class players he's added to the squad, not including Torres Agger or Babel ( who for my liking gets nowhere near the amount of games he should)?Borne on the witnessing the highest highs and pretty much the lowest lows. So, yeah, it's blind optimism, really
.
But as to class players. That's difficult really. First off it seems to me that most people's definition of 'class' boils down to reputation followed by immediate impact in Premiership, mostly the latter. Torres ticks both those boxes, Agger just the latter. Van Nistelrooy and Ronaldo had immediate positive effect at United, whereas Poborsky and Veron didn't, for example. Likewise, Ballack and Schevchenko at Chelsea.
You missed Renia by the wayBest LFC keeper since Clemence IMHO. And Morientes - another that just didn't work. I could go on (Kuyt: top scorer in Dutch league, struggling like hell in the UK)
So, I'm not sure it's useful to judge Rafa on 'class' signings. They either gell or they don't.
I've said several times here before, by far the most insightful of managers when it comes to a) spotting real class and b) spending relatively nothing on them is Wenger by a mile.
Nope - fair question, mate.Not having a pop, just a question.
Oh, and the Gabriel Heinze fiasco before I forget. Rafa is going to be delighted when he "steals him away from Manchester United in a great coup". Haha, Fergie will be pissing himself laughing, mates. Heinze is a decent, if ageing attacking full back, but he couldn't even get in the first team at Old Trafford. Why do you think that Fergie went and bought Evra?
I predict that LFC will not win the Premiership until Rafa has gone, and his successor bleeds the current squad of the also-rans. By my reckoning, you will be left with Gerrard, Carragher and Torres. Then, do what Fergie did and get some local kids who have the old LFC heart and fire in their bellies.
- mac monkey
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1114
- Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 8:09 pm 0
- Location: Just about here.
KevG wrote:missed Renia by the wayBest LFC keeper since Clemence IMHO.
...you know when I posted it, I then thought, doh!! Renia.
I just feel that you look at some of the players he's let go compared to what we have now leave me scratching my head.
Owen, Pongolle, Baros to name a few are far better than the likes of Kuyt and Voronin.
Morientes is a class player but as you said didn't really adapt to the Premiership. You could argue the other 3 were part of GH reign but so are SG, JC, Riise, and big sami.
Bill Shankly:
"I was the best manager in Britain because I was never devious or cheated anyone. I'd break my wife's legs if I played against her, but I'd never cheat her."
"I was the best manager in Britain because I was never devious or cheated anyone. I'd break my wife's legs if I played against her, but I'd never cheat her."
Hmm. Not sure about that. Though it does concern me that the local youth set up appears to be ignored. Steve Heighway beat the Mancsthen promptly left. But the trouble had started under Houllier I think.Zoot wrote: It all went wrong for Liverpool when your lot forgot that youhad bloody good youngsters who actually grew up up on Merseyside and decided to buy them in instead.
The reason I'm not convinced is because Mourinho and Wenger's successes were built largely on talent outside the capital. YEah, yeah I realise there's Terry and Lampard, but Cech and Drogba are more important to them IMHO.
Also, winning a load of "tin" over the last few years (including Houlier) doesnt constitute it all going wrong'. Today's generation of LFC supporter are taught not to be happy with anything less than the premiership because of what went on before they were born, frankly. I was lucky enough to witness all of that but LFC have no divine right to any of it.
Not sure were that quote comes from. I'd be troubled if Fergie thought he was stiching LFC up if he flogged Heinze to. I mean, he shelled out for him in the first place. Plus, I seem to remember MUFC getting a cob on with LFC over the whole business in the first place.Oh, and the Gabriel Heinze fiasco before I forget. Rafa is going to be delighted when he "steals him away from Manchester United in a great coup". Haha, Fergie will be pissing himself laughing, mates.
Very few clubs have hit a seam of talent like those lads, so it's not a resonable benchmark IMHO. See comments onChelsea and Aresenal above. Liverpool's record was built on players who largely not local, e.g.Then, do what Fergie did and get some local kids who have the old LFC heart and fire in their bellies.
Hansen, Dalglish, Rush, Souness, Keegan, Clemence, both Kennedy's, Heighway, Whelan etc etc.



