juice wrote:However, Catherine Tate did a surprisingly good job, though I'm not too keen on the way she alternates between "self-sufficient go-getter" and "screaming banshee begging Dr Who to save her and/or blaming him for the problem" - less of the latter, please!
Actually, I always suspected that Tate would do a good job, if she could be allowed to do some acting and not just be wheeled in as the "comedy character".
Because she started out in serious acting. But she moved into comedy acting (because, fair play, she has that "comedy acting" knack of knowing how to deliver a line and if you've got that acting skill, then, you know, use it) and, fortunately / unfortunately (delete as applicable), hit on that "Lauren" character, which many people find hilariously funny.
Sorry, I'm not a great fan of "Lauren" myself - she was alright as a Comic Relief one-off (or, okay, two-off, as getting Blair to deliver her lines was comedy history - and it's lucky for him that he was leaving office soon after, because he totally exposed that he's far, far too good an actor) - but I'm of a similar opinion to Ricky Gervais about the overuse of "catchphrase comedy". And "Lauren" is the absolute epitome of that on "overkill", because the joke involves repeating "bovvered" over and over again. I'm not saying it's bad, but it's something I personally think should just have been used far more sparingly. It's all just passed its "sell by" date for me (your mileage may vary).
And then when she was in the Christmas special, they basically wrote a character that was "Lauren lite". She wasn't, at the time, expected to come back into the series, so it was a throw-away "comedy character". It was, if you like, inviting "Lauren" as being the guest star, not Tate herself.
In other words, it's pretty much similar to Billie Piper. She'd actually started out her career as an actress and acting is actually Piper's "true profession" (in her "heart of hearts"), if you know what I mean. But, yeah, she did some pop songs, got really famous doing that and then everyone mistakenly was thinking "oh, she's just a pop singer and won't be any good at acting". Well, as she went on to prove as Rose, that wasn't actually true.
In fact, thinking about it, RTD's got an obsession with casting people like that. Because, of course, even Kylie is the same thing. Kylie was an actress to begin with and then moved into a pop career. Although, in her case - as long as we ignore her youthful ignorance of going with Stock, Aitken and Waterman at the start and pretend that never happened - I'd say she's much better as a pop singer than an actress. No offence, Kylie.
Anyway, the point is that I knew that Tate could do a decent acting job, as long as the writers will let her do it.
The problem of her being a "self-sufficient go-getter" one instant and then a moany cow the other, is unfortunately a consequence that when they dragged Tate into that Christmas special, RTD wrote her part as "Lauren lite" (because, at the time, he thought she was only "guest starring" and didn't think her character would be coming back). But you really, really can't have a character like that for a whole series.
So, basically, they've created themselves the problem of somehow transforming her from "Lauren lite" to an actual useful character. RTD's tried to explain the transformation a little, as if being exposed to all that alien shit and flying around in the TARDIS has kind of made her open her eyes to what's really going on, made her take stock of her life and "mature" as a person.
Mind you, doing that all in one episode - even with a "this all happened in the intervening time that we didn't see" excuse - is pushing it a little on the credibility side.
But, basically, RTD wrote himself into the corner on that one. He shouldn't really have originally written Donna as solely a "comedy character" with basically zero depth. And he has to transform her because you can't have a whole series of her being like that - not just would she be annoying if she stayed like that, but her attitude in the Christmas special is such that she'd actually fuck up and get in the way of the plot lines. Having her moan and go into a strop every single episode just couldn't really be made to work, without dragging the whole series down with it.
So, RTD wrote himself between a rock and a hard place. He'd already written Donna as a moany cow. And it fucks up "continuity", if there is some of that moany cow still inside her somewhere. But she can't stay that way, so he's got to somehow "transform" her into a useful "Doctor's assistant" (and, in the modern era, we don't do "damsels in distress" anymore - so she's got to have that "self-sufficient go-getter" in her to be useful in the plot lines). And he can't take too long about it, episode-wise.
All that considered, I think RTD's doing alright at turning around what was, in hindsight, a mistake. He shouldn't have originally written Donna solely as a "comedy character" with zero depth and basically almost no redeeming features whatsoever.
Indeed, I even suspect Tate herself is a bit tired with Lauren too (or, at least, being forever typecast in those kinds of characters and not understood as being a capable actress) - because, in order to be in Doctor Who, she actually turned another series of her own "Catherine Tate show". And folks don't turn down a series of their own show, in order to be a secondary character in another show - even a big show like Dr.Who - at all lightly. So she's clearly taking the part of playing Donna very seriously and I think wants to make a good acting job of it, because, otherwise, it'd be a stupid career move to do that (but it'd be a wise career move, if she pulls it off and demonstrates to folks that she's not a "one trick pony" because that would kill off the "typecasting" - well, much as it did for Billie, where her "pop career" is now basically long forgotten).
Of course, it's not like I actually know these people personally or anything. I could be totally wrong. But it's just how I interpret what I see and what I think - what I suspect - might be what's really going on, based on that. Your mileage on the situation may, indeed, vary.

"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes