The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
No.
Sci-fi is about using a sci-fi idea to form a story that could not be told another way.
Without that, your just left with soap-opera/drama in space (or the future). Not nesscerly bad, but neither does it need to be a sci-fi.
The sci-fi concept has to be the heart of the story.
And these concepts Dr Who has. Cilivisation living in a traffic jam? Quantom-evolved Gargoles? A hospital being ripped from a planet and plunked on the moon and yes, even infants being formed from excess body fat of a host.
These are ideas that only sci-fi can do, and ones that only Dr Who does.
Heads up to Farscape and Lexx for doing their own outlandish things (in farscapes case with much better charecter work), but Startrek, Stargate, Sliderz ect. No where near as diverse as who's ideas.
Im fed up with this current bullshit ideology that sci-fi is only good when its kept to a minimum.
Imho, I want to see what I havnt seen before, and thats exactly what sci-fi should be for.
Thats not to excuse bad charecterisations.
Good charecter interation/motivation is important whatever the genra.
Sci-fi is about using a sci-fi idea to form a story that could not be told another way.
Without that, your just left with soap-opera/drama in space (or the future). Not nesscerly bad, but neither does it need to be a sci-fi.
The sci-fi concept has to be the heart of the story.
And these concepts Dr Who has. Cilivisation living in a traffic jam? Quantom-evolved Gargoles? A hospital being ripped from a planet and plunked on the moon and yes, even infants being formed from excess body fat of a host.
These are ideas that only sci-fi can do, and ones that only Dr Who does.
Heads up to Farscape and Lexx for doing their own outlandish things (in farscapes case with much better charecter work), but Startrek, Stargate, Sliderz ect. No where near as diverse as who's ideas.
Im fed up with this current bullshit ideology that sci-fi is only good when its kept to a minimum.
Imho, I want to see what I havnt seen before, and thats exactly what sci-fi should be for.
Thats not to excuse bad charecterisations.
Good charecter interation/motivation is important whatever the genra.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Okay, if you insist, not so much "a corner". Yes, a corner is something that's hard to write your way out of, while this was perfectly easy to write his way out of - so I guess you're right to pick me up on that, as it's the wrong word.HGFB wrote:Did you see the same Runaway Bride as the rest of us Klaxon Cow? Go and watch the last 10 minutes again and then come back and tell me RTD wrote himself into a corner.
It's more of an..."obtuse angle", shall we say, than "a corner".
My point wasn't that RTD hadn't written his way out of it - I think he has and done so convincingly. And my point wasn't that Tate wasn't any good - my central, opening point (the reason I started writing that post) was exactly to say that not only did I think Tate did a good job, but that I also had confidence that she would do a good job before this episode (and, if I recall correctly, I think I did post something to this thread ages back, when it was first announced that she'd take the part for the Xmas special, already kind of expressing that (so I'm not saying this after-the-fact, I was predicting it back then too) - that she is more than capable of doing a good, serious acting job, no problem. It's just a question of the writers realising that to write her that way).
Juice commented that Donna is a touch, well, "bipolar" sometimes (e.g. flipping around in her personality) and I was explaining it - not criticising it, but explaining it - as a consequence of having written her as a "one-off" and establishing her as one kind of character then bringing her back and having, for practical reasons, to make her into a different kind of character. And the required continuity / fluidity in-between to make it credible.
And, really, I am NOT being unreasonable or out-of-order or anything in saying that, because Catherine Tate herself has said as much in a Radio Times interview:
Straight from the horse's mouth (not that I'm implying Tate is a horse, of course).Radio Times wrote:Interviewer wrote:Is Donna as mouthy as before?[...]Catherine Tate wrote:Everyone assumed she was a one-off - myself included - but now she has a whole season to have a story arc.Interviewer wrote:Does Donna change through the series?Catherine Tate wrote:Donna feels she hasn't done anything with her life and suddenly she's having incredible adventures - and she's not unmoved by them. She was, at the beginning, but you couldn't have had a series of someone going, "Get away from me! Shut up!" [...] They really rounded Donna out from being a shouting fishwife to someone who's quite vulnerable and emotional.
(And, if I recall correctly, RTD expressed pretty much similar sentiments in the "Confidential" episode about how she was a one-off and how that can't work for a whole season, et cetera, et cetera.)
Now, by all means, maybe you interpret that differently to me. And that's just fine. As I say, I don't know these folks personally or anything. I'm just going by what they've been saying in interviews and on "Confidential" about it. Maybe your interpretation is more correct than mine is. And maybe you know something I don't. I just don't know about that. But I'm perfectly happy to accept that very possibly being the case.
But that's just what I think. What I've made of it all. My personal opinion. As I said, I could be totally wrong about it. But shit happens. Everyone's wrong some time in their life. So it's not a big deal.
I mean, can't we all just get along?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
I think you wrote yourself out of a corner nicely. 
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Anyone reckon that Donna throwing her car keys into the same bin that the doctor had thrown the discarded pen have anything to do with the appearance of Rose?
- Jedburgh
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5904
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:50 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: dariusjedburgh23
- Location: Uncanny Valley
Re: The Dr Who thread
Different bin, wasn't it?
Jedburgh
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Yes, different bin. Why on earth did he throw the pen away though? Obvious plot device..
(just show, no stabby stabby)
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Hehe...
Just something that occurred to me at the time.
Actually, "Ooooh...," followed closely by, "Aaaah...," was my reaction after Donna told that blonde lady where the keys were.
Just something that occurred to me at the time.
Actually, "Ooooh...," followed closely by, "Aaaah...," was my reaction after Donna told that blonde lady where the keys were.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Yes, somethings up with that.Zoot wrote:Yes, different bin. Why on earth did he throw the pen away though? Obvious plot device..
I can understand perhaps the doctor has a slight contempt for sonic devices other then his trusty screwdriver, but casually chucking away such advanced tech seems socially irresponsible for a time traveler.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I thought so too, at first, but watched it again last night and it appeared that it could be the same bin, but viewed from a different angle.Jedburgh wrote:Different bin, wasn't it?
Possibly
- PVB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 32542
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
- PSN: PVBuk
- Location: Medway, U.K.
Re: The Dr Who thread
He seems to know a bit of future Earth history (if you see what I mean), so maybe he 'had' to throw it in the bin?Darkflame wrote:Yes, somethings up with that.Zoot wrote:Yes, different bin. Why on earth did he throw the pen away though? Obvious plot device..
I can understand perhaps the doctor has a slight contempt for sonic devices other then his trusty screwdriver, but casually chucking away such advanced tech seems socially irresponsible for a time traveler.
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
Re: The Dr Who thread
I can't recall - Was it in the same bin as the car keys?PVB wrote:He seems to know a bit of future Earth history (if you see what I mean), so maybe he 'had' to throw it in the bin?Darkflame wrote:Yes, somethings up with that.Zoot wrote:Yes, different bin. Why on earth did he throw the pen away though? Obvious plot device..
I can understand perhaps the doctor has a slight contempt for sonic devices other then his trusty screwdriver, but casually chucking away such advanced tech seems socially irresponsible for a time traveler.
[Sir_LANs-a-lot]
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
Re: The Dr Who thread
The outdoor scenes from Episode 11 that people have seen being filmed featured Rose in the same outfit that she wore in Episode 1.
I smell predestination paradox. It smells real purty.
I smell predestination paradox. It smells real purty.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I just checked. It wasn't.Sir_LANs-a-lot wrote:I can't recall - Was it in the same bin as the car keys?
My bag is called Mr Shitface
