Different bins.Zoot wrote:I thought so too, at first, but watched it again last night and it appeared that it could be the same bin, but viewed from a different angle.Jedburgh wrote:Different bin, wasn't it?
Possibly
Pen bin:

Keys bin:


Different bins.Zoot wrote:I thought so too, at first, but watched it again last night and it appeared that it could be the same bin, but viewed from a different angle.Jedburgh wrote:Different bin, wasn't it?
Possibly


Harlequin has already pointed that out at least twice nowKlaxonCow wrote:(Decided to put my previously unspoilered comment into a spoiler tag, just in case it turns out I'm actually right. But it's an exceedingly mild and fairly obvious piece of speculation to reach that you've probably thought of it yourself anyway.)
Spoiler: show
ah..yes, well, thats ok then.PVB wrote:He seems to know a bit of future Earth history (if you see what I mean), so maybe he 'had' to throw it in the bin?Darkflame wrote:Yes, somethings up with that.Zoot wrote:Yes, different bin. Why on earth did he throw the pen away though? Obvious plot device..
I can understand perhaps the doctor has a slight contempt for sonic devices other then his trusty screwdriver, but casually chucking away such advanced tech seems socially irresponsible for a time traveler.

I don't know where you got that idea from. If you mean in the Who universe maybe, in ours I don't believe it's so at all.Darkflame wrote:
ah..yes, well, thats ok then.
Paradoxs can happly work that way around without the universe minding.
A set of events causeing themselfs is fine as long as the events could, in theory, have happened some other way anyway. (before the loop "started").
Well, I think it could apply to the real world too.zip accident wrote:I don't know where you got that idea from. If you mean in the Who universe maybe, in ours I don't believe it's so at all.Darkflame wrote:
ah..yes, well, thats ok then.
Paradoxes can happily work that way around without the universe minding.
A set of events causing themselves is fine as long as the events could, in theory, have happened some other way anyway. (before the loop "started").
In these paradoxes, there is always information transferred into past times, and that information, that data, has to have come from somewhere.
I too believe that paradoxs cant physicaly happen. It certainly wont destroy the universe. (probably just limited to this galaxy...)I believe there are rules in place that will stop the paradox even beginning to happen.

I understand what you mean, but the loop almost has to be infinitely long (unless we come up with a convincing explanation of both why it's not infinitely long, and why it isn't infinitely short, i.e. non-existent), and that means there is no beginning.Darkflame wrote:
Well, I think it could apply to the real world too.
Your absolutely right the information has to come from somewhere.
It comes from the hypothetic, unwitnessed, "start" of the loop.
Lets say I invent, though my own hard work, a time machine.
I then go back and give myself the plans.
If your looking from a liner perspective thats impossible...I was given the plans, and made the time machine, and handed them back to myself. The plans, as you say, come from no-where.
If, however, you saw the initial hard work that ensured the time machine would have been invented anyway the paradox really doesn't become such a big deal.
You kinda need a 2D time axis to draw this on a diagram however.



"Don't blink!"Dio wrote:Just wait until they throw Statues at us again.

Doesn't that sting just a bit? I have this vision of Dio being pelted with copies of the Venus de Milo for no readily apparent reason now.Dio wrote:Just wait until they throw Statues at us again.

That one did creep me out a bit. Even more than the gas mask mommy one.Dio wrote:Just wait until they throw Statues at us again.
Hush - it had Sally Sparrow in it. 'nuff said.Phineasfool wrote:That one did creep me out a bit. Even more than the gas mask mommy one.Dio wrote:Just wait until they throw Statues at us again.