Jamie wrote:Before I say anything i'll point out, for anyone who doesn't know, that i'm a Liverpool fan so anything I say will obviously have a certain amount of unintentional bias attached to it.
If I was an Arsenal fan I would genuinely be embarrassed at Wenger's comments after the game. If our penalty shouldn't have been given then neither should theirs last week meaning we would have gone through anyway. If ours was a penalty and theirs too then we still would have gone through too so how can there be any debate about being robbed? In fact, if you look at both penalty incidents one after the other, Hleb's body goes limp as soon as there's any contact but Babel genuinely tries to stay on his feet so if anyone can say Arsenal were robbed of a clear penalty last week then ours was without any doubt a penalty too. Both teams get a penalty or neither team does, Liverpool would still have won the tie.
Wenger trying to claim that they deserved to win but were robbed is as embarrassing and as misguided as Mourinho's comments 3 years ago about the goal that wasn't a goal. It clearly was a goal but if it wasn't and play had been stopped because of the foul then we'd have had a penalty and they'd have been down to 10 men too, that's worse than conceding just a goal. I admire the amazing passing football that Arsenal play but Wenger needs to accept that he's been tactically outwitted by a superior european manager.
Did you watch all of his comments properly? its still on bbc site, he blamed the one not given more than the one that was given. BUT he also totally blamed the lack of defensive guile and total embarrassing defending by his own players later on in the piece. Arsenal were the better team over the the two legs (no question at all) but being better does not mean a thing in the modern game (again Arsene hinted at this by saying that is football) , Two of the four semi finalists are all about tactics ,power ,percentage football and a more than little bit of luck. If Bednter had scored instead of doing the hilarious goose step the penalty decisions would all have bee moot point.
But then its all about ifs and buts.
It was a fucking penalty! If it had been anywhere else on the pitch nobody would have argued. As soon as the attacker had got the wrong side of him he was in shit street.
Jamie wrote:If our penalty shouldn't have been given then neither should theirs last week meaning we would have gone through anyway.
How did you work that one out?
Because we'd have won the game 3-2. The 4th goal might not have happened in the same way but you can't say a team wouldn't have scored in the last 5 minutes because of the way the tie has panned out over the preceding 175 minutes. Arsene can't say we were gifted a penalty when he's claiming to have been robbed of one last week, both incidents are almost identical. It's one rule for us and another for them. Yes they were robbed of a penalty last week but it's the difference between losing 5-3 or 5-4.
Of course you can. One of the commentators said the same thing as that, and it's crazy - it's far less likely there would have been a goal had Arsenal not been chasing the game.
Dio wrote:Of course you can. One of the commentators said the same thing as that, and it's crazy - it's far less likely there would have been a goal had Arsenal not been chasing the game.
Yes, a 4th goal is less likely had arsenal not been pressing but it's not a foregone conclusion that liverpool wouldn't have scored, in front of the kop, on a european night. Yes if we hadn't have been given a penalty the result would have been different or if they'd been given one last week or if Bendtner hadn't cleared it off our goal line the result may have been different but thats a lot of ifs to reverse the result.
Jamie wrote:Yes, a 4th goal is less likely had arsenal not been pressing but it's not a foregone conclusion that liverpool wouldn't have scored, in front of the kop, on a european night. Yes if we hadn't have been given a penalty the result would have been different or if they'd been given one last week or if Bendtner hadn't cleared it off our goal line the result may have been different but thats a lot of ifs to reverse the result.
You said that if your penalty wasn't given, theirs shouldn't have been either.
Theirs wasn't. So that's a pretty fundamental error.
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
Dio wrote:Of course you can. One of the commentators said the same thing as that, and it's crazy - it's far less likely there would have been a goal had Arsenal not been chasing the game.
Yes, a 4th goal is less likely had arsenal not been pressing but it's not a foregone conclusion that liverpool wouldn't have scored, in front of the kop, on a european night. Yes if we hadn't have been given a penalty the result would have been different or if they'd been given one last week or if Bendtner hadn't cleared it off our goal line the result may have been different but thats a lot of ifs to reverse the result.
Good. You finally agree with everyone else then.
Oh and "in front of the kop, on a European night" is right up there with "Theatre of Dreams" as the most cringe-worthy overused cliches in football
Jamie wrote:Yes, a 4th goal is less likely had arsenal not been pressing but it's not a foregone conclusion that liverpool wouldn't have scored, in front of the kop, on a european night. Yes if we hadn't have been given a penalty the result would have been different or if they'd been given one last week or if Bendtner hadn't cleared it off our goal line the result may have been different but thats a lot of ifs to reverse the result.
You said that if your penalty wasn't given, theirs shouldn't have been either.
Theirs wasn't. So that's a pretty fundamental error.
Simon
Agree , strange perception of ifs and buts there. Arsenal rode all over them in the first game and didnt have the killer touch , and the lack of a killer touch in the second with keystone defending cost them in the second.
Pool won end of story, however much I cry in my sleep , At least this result guarantees them having Benitez around for another year of tactically wonderful league matches.