The commentaries are indeed available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/s4/audio/ after each episode, as they have been for previous seasons.swooshy wrote:Not sure I've seen this mentioned, but if so, oh well![]()
I just spotted there's a free podcast of the commentary for last Saturdays Who on the iTunes site - guessing it's on the beeb somewhere too, but I never looked. Got some nice little bits in it if you like that kind of thing.
The Dr Who thread
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Downloaded the MP3 of the commentary, then fired up iPlayer with the episode running and hit "play" on the MP3 when the credits showed.Harlequin wrote:The commentaries are indeed available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/s4/audio/ after each episode, as they have been for previous seasons.swooshy wrote:Not sure I've seen this mentioned, but if so, oh well![]()
I just spotted there's a free podcast of the commentary for last Saturdays Who on the iTunes site - guessing it's on the beeb somewhere too, but I never looked. Got some nice little bits in it if you like that kind of thing.
Usefully, at the start, David goes "oh, look, there's my name" when it appears in the opening credits and Tate says "and there's mine" when hers shows up - and, brilliant, perfectly in synch. Then they mentioned something else on-screen and, again, spot on synchronisation.
It was perfect until Bernhard Cribbins showed up then they were talking about the TARDIS set before I could see it. Never mind, stopped the MP3 and then started it at the right bit, to put it back into synch. It then fitted perfectly again.
This worked - for five minutes - before they started mentioning things way, way ahead in the episode. Huh?
Interestingly, I could work out what they were talking about and went to that part then put it back in synch - and it fitted perfectly. Including all the "William Shatner as an extra" references - near frame perfect synchronisation with Tate's "Look, there he is!". Until they suddenly started talking about the final scene while I was still watching the crowd of Adipose getting run over by a taxi.
I was able to re-synch it sufficiently to work out what they were talking about when they were talking about it (just hit pause on the MP3 player whenever they mentioned something and unpause it once I could actually see it on the screen - and once I'd got it in synch again, it fitted perfectly time-wise) - but it just kept jumping ahead every once in a while.
The MP3 download's only 30 minutes but the show's longer than that.
I guess the actual commentary had gaps in it, where they stopped talking and these have just been cut out of the download?
That's a bit annoying. Even a bit stupid, as they constantly refer to things on-screen as the commentary runs and some of the comments only make sense when you can see what they're seeing.
Or is the idea that it's purposefully not particularly convenient, as an incentive to buy the DVD boxset later on?
Never mind, that was entertaining to try it out anyway (and not really quite as awkward to follow, as the above might make it sound), running the commentary alongside the episode in iPlayer - even if I did have to sometimes hit pause and unpause to synch it back up now and again.
I think I might do that with all the episodes from now on - so thanks for the link!
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
The boxsets have different commentaries instead of the free downloadable ones. 
You can watch the repeat(s) with the commentary track on BBC3.

You can watch the repeat(s) with the commentary track on BBC3.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Ah, right, that's how it works. Thanks.Alarm wrote:The boxsets have different commentaries instead of the free downloadable ones.
You can watch the repeat(s) with the commentary track on BBC3.![]()
It's just odd to have a commentary of the on-screen action, but then cut out the gaps where no-one's talking, so that the timing doesn't actually fit with the on-screen action anymore. It just has a ring of "for those watching in black-and-white, the pink is next to the red" to it, if you know what I mean.
Couldn't they, for the download, have the episode's soundtrack just fade in when they're not talking - thus, maintaining the correct timing with the on-screen action-- and then, you know, it's just a "replacement soundtrack" (as it undoubtedly is when it's played on that BBC3 repeat)? Then you could just play the episode with the volume off and play the commentary alongside it instead.
That makes more sense to me, anyway.
Never mind, it's not the end of the world or anything. It's not hard to pause it / unpause it or anything. But it's just, well, a bit fucking annoying, you know?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
Its a brainfart by someone at somepoint basicaly.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- WiteWulf
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10125
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
- PSN: WiteWulf
- Location: Loughborough(ish)
Re: The Dr Who thread
You'd be surprised how quickly you notice the lag when playing back material on two different devices that have slightly imperfect timing oscillators in them. Try playing back two copies of the same CD on two different players at the same time and you'll soon see what I mean 
:::G:::
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
Re: The Dr Who thread
The free downloadable commentaries I've listened to recently (at least those with RTD in them) have been a complete waste of time, basically lots of back-patting, in-jokes, and irrelevant waffle. Are the DVD ones better?Alarm wrote:The boxsets have different commentaries instead of the free downloadable ones.
You can watch the repeat(s) with the commentary track on BBC3.![]()
Why are you breaking my kayak?
Re: The Dr Who thread
WiteWulf wrote:You'd be surprised how quickly you notice the lag when playing back material on two different devices that have slightly imperfect timing oscillators in them. Try playing back two copies of the same CD on two different players at the same time and you'll soon see what I mean
True, but you wouldnt get 10 minutes worth vanishing.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Exactly.Darkflame wrote:True, but you wouldnt get 10 minutes worth vanishing.WiteWulf wrote:You'd be surprised how quickly you notice the lag when playing back material on two different devices that have slightly imperfect timing oscillators in them. Try playing back two copies of the same CD on two different players at the same time and you'll soon see what I mean
And we're talking about an "all digital" set up here, running on the same machine, running under the same scheduler, running off the same exact timer chip, fixed bit rates, frame skipping, etc.
In fact, that's what I was trying to emphasise in my little description of what happened. When I got the pictures and sound into synch, it was an uncannily dead-on accurate even after five minutes - spookily so, as I do know exactly the problem WiteWulf's talking about (indeed, I exploit it deliberately in some of my MIDI compositions to have two identical voices playing the same thing on the left and right channels at the same time - but because the timing is never 100% perfect, it creates a fuller and slightly "phased" sound), so when it wasn't going out-of-synch, it actually kind of threw me. It was surprisingly accurate - more than I'd originally expected it would be.
No, as Darkflame's captured, you can't attribute around ten minutes of missing commentary to a synch problem.
When I matched the two up, the synch was pretty much perfect (give or take). But it just kept jumping and we're talking large jumps near the end because they're talking about when the Adipose are triggered en masse (the "full pathogenesis" bit) and Tate's joking that Bill Shatner is an extra in the background of the scene - then, all of a sudden, only about a minute or two later, they're talking about the final scene and how preview copies of the episode were specially edited, so that the thing what happens in the final scene that I'm not going to mention didn't, as Tennant jokes, "end up in the Radio Times".
There's no way it's just a synch problem because the jump there is far too massive. I think they just shut up to watch the climax of the episode and they've just trimmed out all the silence (which kind of makes sense from one perspective - that of not having stupidly long silences throughout the download - but also doesn't make sense from the fact that it's a commentary of the on-screen action, so not having it match the on-screen action partially defeats the object of the exercise).
I do know what WiteWulf's talking about - and, generally speaking, he's absolutely right (which is why I didn't bother replying to that post because what he says is perfectly right) - but it's not solely a synch problem in this case. They've definitely chopped bits out (which, to be fair, were probably silences when no-one was saying anything).
Anyway, as I say, it's not really that much of a big deal. Just thought I'd mention it for anyone else who might want to try the same thing of running it in iPlayer (as the commentary does make seriously more sense in a big way, when you can actually see what they're talking about). Basically, the trick is to have the MP3 player's pause button handy and whenever they say something like "Ah, David, you just love that TARDIS set, don't you?" and you can't see the TARDIS set, hit pause. Wait until you can see the TARDIS set and then hit unpause. Then it all fits again (at least for another five minutes or so). To be honest, it's not even the pausing and unpausing that was most annoying - it was because I couldn't, therefore, play it full screen all the way through, as I needed access to that pause button.
No, it's not a big problem or anything. Just something I'd encountered while doing it that I thought might be worth mentioning. Maybe.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I'm quite surprised they made an audio commentary that's shorter than the episode. It pretty much defeats the purpose. I listened to one during series 2 and it didn't have huge gaps. Perhaps this is a mistake. It might be worth emailing the Website team and telling them. Even if it's deliberate if they start getting people complaining they might change it. I have a sneaking suspicion that silence probably wouldn't up the download size very much. 
My bag is called Mr Shitface
Re: The Dr Who thread
Maybe it's just me, but I listened to the commentary on its own, while working on other things, not while watching the episode at all.
So not having 10 minutes of empty space was perfect for me
I found I didn't have too much trouble remembering what had happened, and it all seemed to make sense and I got what they were talking about even without the video.
Certainly stops any issues with sync!
So not having 10 minutes of empty space was perfect for me
I found I didn't have too much trouble remembering what had happened, and it all seemed to make sense and I got what they were talking about even without the video.
Certainly stops any issues with sync!
Re: The Dr Who thread
Looks like the reason they might have done this is to make it fit into a 30-minute time slot on BBC7. Whether putting the shortened version on the website to download is an honest mistake, or whether it's deliberate and they're just daft in the head, I don't know.
Why are you breaking my kayak?
Re: The Dr Who thread
Boy, the toy shops are going to be happy tomorrow, with all those out-of-season sales... 
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I liked that one a lot.
Spoiler: show
Re: The Dr Who thread
I'm just watching Confidential, and they have this wonderful Italian volcano expert talking about... er... volcanoes, and hes just confirmed one little suspicion, which is that the Doctor is a very fast runner indeed. 
Last edited by F-ZeroOne on Sat Apr 12, 2008 8:31 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.



