Jonesey wrote:It was a bit shit really though, eh? Belongs in the same place as Love & Monsters and Fear Her I reckon.
For me, Love & Monsters in the only decent episode penned by RTD.
I didn't even bother watching the Confidential this week.
I haven't watched any Confidentials this series - seeing Collinson and RTD constantly patting themselves on the backs for serving up tripe kind of gets tiresome after a while.
I turned the telly off halfway through and went to make some nosh, which is a first for Who.
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
Dr Who goes back to its old school roots with a decent monster of the week/time travel premise and people complain. Business as usual on the YY forums
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
I quite liked it from the viewpoint of those "battling some monsters in the future" eps get tiresome, although even set back in the Agatha Christie times, the arrival of the Doctor just when a giant bee (conceived by a space visitor) performs a murder seems to be a lil coincidental.
IronGiant wrote:For me, Love & Monsters in the only decent episode penned by RTD.
Agreed.
I haven't watched any Confidentials this series - seeing Collinson and RTD constantly patting themselves on the backs for serving up tripe kind of gets tiresome after a while.
Also agreed. I stopped watching them halfway through the last Christmas Special one, for exactly the same reason.
I made a bit of an exception last week, though, in the interest of seeing Georgia Moffet as a redhead
KlaxonCow wrote:In the Doctor Who Confidential episode, RTD says that he was travelling from Cardiff to Manchester, when the producer, Phil Collinson, suggested to him the idea of an episode that's a "whodunnit" with Agatha Christie in it. At which point, I quote, RTD "laughed for 20 miles and 10 minutes".
no, its a compound function denoted by the word 'and' so clearly RTD laughed for 20 miles at an unknown speed, (my average over the last 2000 miles is 30mph so 40 ish minutes), and then 10 minutes probably stationary.
In conclusion RTD laughed for nearly an hour and still thought it was a good idea at the end of it.
Gorecki wrote:You really are taking rabid internet sniping and bitching to new heights with that post. How dare somebody not back up an amusing anecdote with accurate data and statistics.
Yes, an absurd thing of me to say, wasn't it?
Hmm, you don't think that maybe - just maybe - that might be a strong indication that I wasn't being remotely serious?
Just because I can be an annoyingly pedantic arsehole from time to time doesn't mean I don't realise it and am unable to take the piss out of myself about that sometimes for comic effect.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
betamax wrote:Dr Who goes back to its old school roots with a decent monster of the week/time travel premise and people complain. Business as usual on the YY forums
My thoughts exactly...the writing was very much in the style of classic 4th Doctor Who and I enjoyed it immensely as such!
WiteWulf wrote:the writing was very much in the style of classic 4th Doctor Who
Go on then, give us an example (story title).
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."