Dunno - as with several other people, my main impression is "meh".Cloudane wrote:Sure is a Marmite episode this one. Love it / hate it, nobody seems to have gone for anything in the middle.
RTD took a lump of 21st century stereotypes, dumped them in a confined space, brought on the Monster Of The Week and then cranked up the mob-rule hysteria caricatures to maximum. The overall effect was unrealistic, crude and overly hammered home over the length of the episode.
Mind you, said "monster" itself was fairly intriguing - Lesley played an excellent role[*] and the monster's behaviour was genuinely creepy. It's a shame that it did turn out to be malicious: it could have been more interesting to trace the results if it had turned out to be benign.
It was also refreshing and unusual to see the Doctor having so little control over the situation - RTD and his cohorts have been so busy building up a messiah complex around the Man Who Can Stand Off Shadows And Leave Armies Trembling: here he was portrayed as a weak voice of reason with something of a superiority complex.
Overall: meh. Roll on the Moffat era
[*] and she got to be the token alternative-sexuality character of the week, along with the "ladies, gentlemen and variations thereof" which thronged the train. Admittedly, this may just be the usual syndrome of things standing out more once you've noticed them, but stuff like this does seem to have a habit of being more obvious in RTD episodes...






