The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
Wow, what a great episode. I haven't liked an episode this much since the Torchwood finale. Easily the best Doctor-lite episode and the best episode this year. If the next two episodes are as good, this series may be better than series three. Folk cannot doubt Tate's acting now, surely - that was a BAFTA-worthy performance IMO.
Re: The Dr Who thread
No way was that better then Blink.
But it was very very good indeed.
A few minor nitpicks from me though;
Incidently, I notice this christmass eppisode is called "Ghosts In Machines"
But it was very very good indeed.
A few minor nitpicks from me though;
Spoiler: show
Incidently, I notice this christmass eppisode is called "Ghosts In Machines"
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Rocco had better appear later on somewhere.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Excellent, six809!
Re: The Dr Who thread
Really enjoyed that and so did my kids, they've watched it 4 times already and still don't quite get it all
Neither did I to be honest, I have my theories but why did all the signs outside inc the tardis change to bad wolf
And what the hell did Billie do to her mouth so she couldn't talk properly
Could do with updating this now though
http://www.badwolf.org.uk/
Neither did I to be honest, I have my theories but why did all the signs outside inc the tardis change to bad wolf
And what the hell did Billie do to her mouth so she couldn't talk properly
Could do with updating this now though
http://www.badwolf.org.uk/
blurgh!!!
Re: The Dr Who thread
I have to admit, that was both a good episode and probably RTD's finest moment. It shows what he can do when he's not pandering to the "people who don't like scifi and love soap operas" demographic[*].
It was also interesting to see all the "what ifs" being explored throughout the episode and Ms Tate confirmed yet again that she is capable of playing good roles beyond just being a motormouth . Though I still think she's too old to be a companion
I think the biggest disappointment for me was the Monster of the Week: the model was pathetic, frankly. I know the DW team claim people find "real" things more scary, but the Daleks have scared generations without needing to look natural. Then too, a more alien-looking creature would have made it easier to animate in a "realistic" way - not least because people are a lot more critical when they think they know how something is meant to move and behave.
Two things past there:
1) What did the fortune teller get out of the deal? Was there some sort of symbiotic relationship there?
2) Why did we have two mega-depressing episodes in a row? Was RTD doing some sort of symbolic bridge-burning?
Roll on the grand finale!
[*] Admittedly, the entire episode was Yet Another 21st Century England scenario, but at least the context was justified within the story and there was a minimum of family histronics...
It was also interesting to see all the "what ifs" being explored throughout the episode and Ms Tate confirmed yet again that she is capable of playing good roles beyond just being a motormouth . Though I still think she's too old to be a companion
Welp...Darkflame wrote: A few minor nitpicks from me though;Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Two things past there:
1) What did the fortune teller get out of the deal? Was there some sort of symbiotic relationship there?
2) Why did we have two mega-depressing episodes in a row? Was RTD doing some sort of symbolic bridge-burning?
Roll on the grand finale!
[*] Admittedly, the entire episode was Yet Another 21st Century England scenario, but at least the context was justified within the story and there was a minimum of family histronics...
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
Re: The Dr Who thread
That's exactly what I thought that episode was. Lot of soap, lot of self-referential nod-and-wink name-dropping, tiny bit of scifi.juice wrote:It shows what he can do when he's not pandering to the "people who don't like scifi and love soap operas" demographic.
I doubt question 1 is meaningful at this stage, it was just a thread to hang a story on.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
http://www.yakyak.org/viewtopic.php?p=1300190#p1300190clovis wrote:Neither did I to be honest, I have my theories but why did all the signs outside inc the tardis change to bad wolf
The explanation might be repeated in the finale for those who did not see the Eccleston season.
http://www.yakyak.org/viewtopic.php?p=1299926#p1299926clovis wrote:And what the hell did Billie do to her mouth so she couldn't talk properly
I suspect that she had a similar deal with the beetle as Andrea Yates had with the Trickster in the SJA story, Whatever Happened to Sarah Jane?.juice wrote:1) What did the fortune teller get out of the deal? Was there some sort of symbiotic relationship there?
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Jedburgh
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5904
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:50 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: dariusjedburgh23
- Location: Uncanny Valley
Re: The Dr Who thread
WILFRED MOTT - TIME LORD FTW
Jedburgh
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
- HippyDave
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 529
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 8:13 am 0
- Location: Worcestershire, UK
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
This sort of It's A Wonderful Life-style "what would have happened to everyone if I wasn't around?" story has been done by just about every sci-fi show going, but even if it wasn't anything new, I thought this one was pretty good overall. There were definitely some annoying omissions (it wouldn't have hurt to explain, even in passing, what the fortune teller was getting out of it all), and yes, the 'Time Scarab' was pretty ropey-looking - I bet they're wishing they'd have done a completely computer-generated creature for those shots now, since it's not like it was in a lot of scenes or even seen in a great amount of detail - but it held my attention.
I liked that they showed the cumulative effects of the various alien attacks on Earth, in the process demonstrating just how vital the Doc's influence really is, and I think pretty much everyone acquitted themselves really well, Catherine Tate in particular. Personally I find her 'comedy' show about as much fun as terminal illness, and was absolutely dreading her involvement in the show, but overall I'd say she's definitely the best companion the Doc has had since his return to active duty. The lass can act, no doubt about it. This contrasts sharply with the wooden and frankly weird turn from Billie Piper - I don't remember Rose being such a squib. Perhaps it's just the rose (haha) tinted specs effect! Good turns from the rest of Donna's family, too. What *is* going on with Donna and her mum? There's definitely something amiss there, and I'm intrigued by some of the theories. It does, however, appear that the unspoken references to Donna's demise have been answered, though.
It really looks like they're pulling out all of the stops for this final two-parter. I admit I've found RTD's writing hit-and-miss: he does rely far too heavily on deus ex machina endings (I pray this isn't another one on its way), and he is rather too fond of the apocalyptic mega-epics, but hey, no-one's pretending this is the new Galactica, right?
Looking forward to the last two. Bring on the pepperpots!
I liked that they showed the cumulative effects of the various alien attacks on Earth, in the process demonstrating just how vital the Doc's influence really is, and I think pretty much everyone acquitted themselves really well, Catherine Tate in particular. Personally I find her 'comedy' show about as much fun as terminal illness, and was absolutely dreading her involvement in the show, but overall I'd say she's definitely the best companion the Doc has had since his return to active duty. The lass can act, no doubt about it. This contrasts sharply with the wooden and frankly weird turn from Billie Piper - I don't remember Rose being such a squib. Perhaps it's just the rose (haha) tinted specs effect! Good turns from the rest of Donna's family, too. What *is* going on with Donna and her mum? There's definitely something amiss there, and I'm intrigued by some of the theories. It does, however, appear that the unspoken references to Donna's demise have been answered, though.
It really looks like they're pulling out all of the stops for this final two-parter. I admit I've found RTD's writing hit-and-miss: he does rely far too heavily on deus ex machina endings (I pray this isn't another one on its way), and he is rather too fond of the apocalyptic mega-epics, but hey, no-one's pretending this is the new Galactica, right?
Looking forward to the last two. Bring on the pepperpots!
"...a chicken vindaloo, kamikaze hot, with a fire extinguisher on standby."
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Digital Spy have listed their spoilers for the next episode. As usual three of them are fake. Part of the fun is figuring out which.
Here's which ones I think are fake
Which would mean quite possibly the most interesting tidbit for the next two episodes is
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
My bag is called Mr Shitface
Re: The Dr Who thread
Awesome episode. An absolute work of genius, and proof that RTD *can* write brilliantly if he puts his mind to it. Also proof that you don't always need the Doctor to be there (although it's nice to see him when he returns).
Everyone seems to have gone anorexic? First there's Billie who seems to be all bones and jaw now (and her 'accent' is exactly how I'd expect FF8's Ultimecia to sound if it was voiced. "Kurse all SeeDs!") and then when the Doctor "returned" at the end his face had the same sort of starved bony appearance!
The bug was clearly a nod to the fans of the old series, as it was so bad/cheap it was hilarious
Tate has really done well, and even with the "shouty" scenes in this episode which might've seemed a bit Lauren-esque, they do fit Donna's character. But the drama with her impending "death" (and the event itself) was really well done. A big "told you so" to the naysayers from early on
Regarding her contract/status (I think we know already but spoiler tagged)
A big +1 to whoever it was that said along the lines of "Feck off with your Daleks" (sorry, it was a few pages ago). I quite agree - they've been wayyy over-done already, I hope there's at least something original around them.
Everyone seems to have gone anorexic? First there's Billie who seems to be all bones and jaw now (and her 'accent' is exactly how I'd expect FF8's Ultimecia to sound if it was voiced. "Kurse all SeeDs!") and then when the Doctor "returned" at the end his face had the same sort of starved bony appearance!
The bug was clearly a nod to the fans of the old series, as it was so bad/cheap it was hilarious
Tate has really done well, and even with the "shouty" scenes in this episode which might've seemed a bit Lauren-esque, they do fit Donna's character. But the drama with her impending "death" (and the event itself) was really well done. A big "told you so" to the naysayers from early on
Regarding her contract/status (I think we know already but spoiler tagged)
Spoiler: show
Last edited by Cloudane on Tue Jun 24, 2008 12:15 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
- HippyDave
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 529
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 8:13 am 0
- Location: Worcestershire, UK
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
Amen. I've been praying that this is finally addressed in some way, other than the vague comments about it that we've been handed every so often since the series returned. Here's hoping this means there's something positive that the Doc can do about the current state of affairs...HGFB wrote:Which would mean quite possibly the most interesting tidbit for the next two episodes isSpoiler: show
"...a chicken vindaloo, kamikaze hot, with a fire extinguisher on standby."







