Gorecki wrote:You haven't liked it since the start and you're criticisms haven't changed since then either. You're repeating yourself and adding nothing, only detracting. Now, please leave this thread..
That's not true, but I can see that it makes your life a bit easier if you believe that. The Moffat episodes have been good. Utopia and The Sound of Drums were surprisingly good with some excellent characterisation from both Derek Jacobi and John Sims. The latter's take on the Master was very good. And when I do have a problem with something, I do try to point out why it doesn't work. And in most cases, it's annoying that given they put so much effort into making Who better and more contemporary, they ruin it all by the equivalent of adding a spoonful of salt to the tea. I would dearly like it to be better. And with Moffat in charge, it has all the makings of being a better programme. It did get better once David Tennant became the Doctor.
You can always leave the thread yourself if you only want to read 100% positive reviews of something. I've never told people to leave because they like something unconditionally. That's up to them. People are always ripping what I have to say to pieces, but I'm not scared to defend my corner if what is said has no merit, or at variance with the evidence on offer. And I am (on occasions) wrong.
Dio wrote:Blake's Seven explicitly WAS adult drama and always made that point clear. They were totally different shows in totally different formats and time slots.
Fifty minute episodes? 7pm in the evening..Spaceships, computers, guns, good on evil action, running around, pre watershed, no blood, no bad language, no sex? Looks like Doctor Who's target audience to me..and I was nine at the time it was shown. And I understood what was going on with the stories, so hardly an adult drama. The only difference between the two series was that the initial premise of the programme was largely political, whereas Doctor Who was originally planned to be a historical drama programme. Both went into fantasy (I think the term was Bug Eyed Monsters or BEMs) shortly after the first few programmes.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."