Interesting ideas.I think that it has possibilities, and also shows the madness of a Time War, with certain parallels to Nuclear War. Once you start one, there virtually no way to end it. Your only safety is to have a timeline that isn't affected by the events that occur, which becomes less and less likely as the war spreads across time and space. I thought that it might be be clever for the Doctor, Jack and companions to work together to shore up key "events" that might wipe them out to give them time to defuse the "origin" of the war, and stop it from happening, by removing the causes - development of key technology, removal of certain people from possible conflict..could be a number of factors.. The issue is that the two sides who are fighting will probably notice the interference and try to thwart it, because they've already got so entrenched in the conflict and aren't willing to lose given the horrific events of what has already happened.
I think The 4400 tried something like that, but lost it pretty quick.
I do think though the fight would have to be a very small critical group on both sides, while their "armys" would be unware of timeline changes, being constantly effected by them themselfs. (so if someone was never born, it would only be those immune to the changes that would be upset).
Still getting Terminator analogys here :pThe final shot of this story is that the whole thing was kicked off from it being the result of someone getting hold of a TARDIS, and as the Doctor only has the only one left, then the only way to put paid to the Time War for good is to destroy the one he has.
The idea of a "villian" being put on trail, and the good guy having to defend them because despite being guilty of many things they are not guilty of what they are accused of certainly has been done. But its normaly quite effective, and can be used as a springboard for many things.The other idea about the Master being on trial is also something I've considered as being interesting in how someone who has such a history of evil might actually be innocent of what he is accused of doing. If it was done in a clever way, you'd start of with the Defence (the Doctor) and you could add the evidence that make the Master look innocent, then guilty, then innocent. Perhaps then it might seem that the Master is actually in collusion with the people running the trial to trap the Doctor. If it was done right, you could keep people pretty much guessing from the fragments of evidence until right up to the end. The reason why I think that this would work is that if the Doctor was on trial, you know he's pretty much innocent of anything he could be accused of. But with the Master being accused of something completely outside of his typical MO..I think that people would be stuck on whether he was blameless or whether something else was going on that wasn't immediately obvious. You'd run it over two or three parts, and like all the best mysteries put all the evidence in plain view but not draw attention to it so people could argue over it scattered over the programmes in the series..
Sadly, I think both these ideas sound like season story arcs of an intensity that they dont seem to like doing these days.







