Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

The Joy of Tech - Anything and everything about all things shiny..
Post Reply
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Kamineko »

- RAW. Raw never changes.
Heh, ironic, because RAW does change. RAW changes a LOT.
shiuming
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 186
Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:07 am 0
Location: London, UK
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by shiuming »

Kamineko wrote:That last shot has the eerie, slightly exaggerated lit feel of a still shot of a film set.

This is a good thread. :D
Cheers - I played around with camera settings to achieve that. It's straight from the camera.
My main reason for getting a DSLR is that my trusty Kodak point and shoot compact cameras always seem to do stupid crap after a year. My first Kodak, an Easyshare CX7330 simply blank died one day about a week before my 'shoot the same thing every day' spree had reached a year. My second Kodak, an Easyshare DX6340 is showing the same symptoms as the first camera (very short battery life, spontaneously turning itself off unsafely), but I'm not certain whether it's the camera being strange or my rechargeable batteries going pants over time.
I think you've just been unlucky, I've known many cameras of different makes to usually last many years unless they were sat on or dropped.
6-10 megapixel, entry-level digital SLR, with kit lens. £150-£300
You won't get anything new for under £200 even without a lens (OK that's not strictly true - I just got my dad a Sony A200 body for his 60th for £190 but he already had a lens)
Canon 350D 400D 450D 30D 40D ~
350D is long discontinued, forget it. Even the 400D is also really old now but a good buy if you can find it. The 450D is most likely to be still available as it is now replaced by the 1000D. Canon's x0D models are the advanced/enthusiast models and occupy the £600-£800 bracket.
Sony a100, a200k
A100 is long discontinued. A200 has £30 cashback at the moment but the offer ends this month I think.
Nikon D40 ~, D50
D40 is long discontinued. The 10 MP replacement, D40x and the newer D60 lack in-body focus motors so bear that in mind because it means they can't use legacy lenses, only newer ones with the AF motor in the lens itself. D50 is really old, you won't find it now. D60 is your best bet for the money.
These would be nice also.

- CF storage. Only because I have a couple of unopened CF cards that I've had just for this exact purpose. I don't really care what the storage is, though. Just as long as it isn't stupid expensive like XD, MS or MSPD. I don't know much about SDHC, and I don't know if my reader can handle it. It almost certainly can, I bought a Good One after my previous Crap One stopped working.
CF is fine for most DSLRs, some entry level Canons use SD. None of the formats are expensive now, that's old news. Your old CF cards may only show their age if you need to do rapid-fire sequence shooting, but just use them until you feel the need to replace.
- Not ordinary AA batteries. I'm going to guess that cameras are designed with stupid proprietary batteries because the camera companies want you to buy their accessories, but with the probably unintentional side-effect that the batteries actually work quite well. Please correct me. In fact, if you can tell me a camera that runs well on ordinary AA batteries (or rechargeables), then you win! (Pentax K200D?)
The battery thing is a really boring subject that's been debated to death, I personally have no issue with so-called proprietary batteries. If you're really shooting so much that you might run out in the field (and modern DSLRs with Li-Ion batteries typically get over 600 shots per charge) then you're probably a keen enough photographer to have more than one battery and a few accessories. AA batteries really don't have a place in a modern DSLR apart from external flash guns where the NiMH technology is actually more suited to the type of discharge than Li-Ion.

I can take the battery from my DSLR and pop it in my 5 year old Sony Cyber-shot and it works perfectly and even gives two more hours of shooting time (that's 6.5 hours in total with a minute by minute charge countdown)
- Pentax / K lens mount... so, I guess I should start my search with a Pentax ._.. My musty box contains an everyday Yashica lens, and a mixture of M42 shiny things. I've read that I can decent results with almost any camera if I use the appropriate adapter, which is nice. I could probably get a decent digital lens if I sold these, but they're lenses. Real lenses! And they're mine!
I can understand the nostalgia and the tank like build quality of old lenses. Downsides are that using adapters you lose things like autofocus, distance encoding for the flash system, lens ID data and whatever else may be stored in the lens ROM if it has one - also older lenses lack the coatings that reduce the internal reflections from digital sensors which film didn't have.
- In body auto focus would really help if used my old lenses. MAGIC would take place.
Canon's EOS mount has always been totally electronic, so all the lenses have the motor inside them (ranging from ultrasonic ring motors to micro motors depending on price range... USM is the quiet and expensive one)
- In body stabilisation. It sounds like the dog's bits. Or something.
Pentax/Samsung (the two work together and sell the same cameras with different internal image processing software, in a nutshell...), Olympus and Sony use in-body sensor shift stabilisation. The others have the stabilisation in the lens and sometimes the lens choice can be confusing as there may be different versions of the same lens and you have to read the small print to see if it is stabilised or not (Nikon's own range of stabilised lenses are designated VR, for Vibration Reduction... Tamron, a third party maker, labels its system VC, for Vibration Compensation, while Sigma, the other main third party lens maker, uses OS for Optical Stabilisation), has ultrasonic AF motor or not, whether it's a MkII version of the lens and so on... There is so much overlap with D/SLR lenses it's not funny.
- Live view would be nifty. But, I know that if one wants to use the camera well, one should probably use the viewfinder.
Live view is another subject of endless and incredibly tedious debate in the DSLR world. It has its uses but the very fact that a DSLR by definition has a mirror box in the way means that all current implementations of it on DSLRs are not too good. They are either slow as hell because the mirror keeps having to be flipped out of the way to feed the sensor an image when you prime the focus (plus, the contrast detect method of autofocus as used in all compact camera live view systems is inherently slower than the phase detect method employed by SLR cameras), or if a secondary sensor is used to read the image via the mirror so the phase detect AF can still be used a la Sony or Olympus, the optical viewfinder is compromised. Make no mistake, live view on DSLRs is an afterthought. Saying that, Panasonic has launched the fantastic looking Lumix G1 which is basically a DSLR minus the mirror box (and therefore by definition not a reflex camera), so everything is live view. It is based on the Micro Four Thirds system, derived from Olympus' original Four Thirds.

I like live view because, no matter how good an optical viewfinder, they simply do not show anything approaching what the image sensor will actually capture. I know "real" old school film shooters scoff at the idea but that's just the way it is. I have both a decent spec DSLR and a decent spec non-DSLR depending on what I want to shoot (when I do night shots like the foggy London eye photo on the previous page I almost never take the DSLR - anything requiring a specific lens type, the best quality or fast action, DSLR every time).
- Controls that aren't cryptic or rubbish. Most of the examples I've seen of digital camera interfaces (and Steve's Digicams are fantastically thorough on that regard) seem to be a screen full of X 240D S23--3CR PWO SOG EIBN...
The basics on most of them are pretty straightforward. Camera reviews are by necessity a bit boring. Delve only as deep as you need to. All of the systems on the market now are capable of producing excellent quality photos.

As for RAW, I woulnd't worry too much about it. You have to know what you're doing and be dedicated to shoot RAW and be able to produce a better result than the in-camera JPEG engine. Use it as and when you feel you've reached the limit of what the camera renders as a JPEG. Again, "purists" will scoff at the idea of buying a DSLR and shooting JPEG but at the end of the day it's about the photography, shooting RAW won't make a better photographer out of anyone.
User avatar
piku
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20960
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
Location: Wakefield
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by piku »

I bought a Nikon D40, and I like it lots. The best thing with my camera compared to previous digital cameras is the lack of shutter lag. Press button, picture is taken. There isn't the constipated pause digital cameras can have.

I spent way too long pondering over which camera to buy, and now realise it was mostly wasted energy - I'd probably be equally happy with a Sony or Canon or whatever dSLR. The only productive thing I learnt was that there are two types of camera review - the anally retentive ones and the professional photographer ones, so you get reviews ranging from "If you shoot a totally black image, there's some blown pixels... this camera is crap" to "I am really a professional photographer, why am I being forced to use this child's toy? Take it away". And then at the end they don't actually say anything useful or decisive.

I follow the blog and forum over at Digital Photography School. The blog is interesting, and the forum is newbie friendly. For a bit of shameless plugging, I like to put my own photos on my photo blog.
return (0);
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Rhythm »

piku wrote:The only productive thing I learnt was that there are two types of camera review - the anally retentive ones and the professional photographer ones, so you get reviews ranging from "If you shoot a totally black image, there's some blown pixels... this camera is crap" to "I am really a professional photographer, why am I being forced to use this child's toy? Take it away". And then at the end they don't actually say anything useful or decisive.

LOL! Extremely well put :-D
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Kamineko »

Thanks for the informative post, shiuming.

Most of the stuff I pointed out are more 'points of interest', rather than really important things. What I'm trying to get is a good all-round camera that'll hopefully last me a million years. I think that if I can get a second hand one in the range I mentioned, I should be good forever. :)

Such a thing is shiny....!

Your shameless plugging is encouraged.
shiuming
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 186
Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:07 am 0
Location: London, UK
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by shiuming »

Overpriced. The D40 is a very good quality camera no doubt, but it has been succeeded twice in the two years since its launch. It's a tad cheeky trying to sell it at today's class equivalent price regardless of how much it was originally. I would try to pick up a used one for considerably less and put most of my money towards quality lenses - these are really what you'll keep for a long time to come. The body can be upgraded and give you better image quality and features with each new generation.

If you can possibly stretch to it, consider the Nikkor 16-85. This is a thoroughly modern design featuring a very useful range for a daily walkaround lens (from landscape to portrait - the standard 18-55 is a bit limiting, basically 3x zoom vs 5x), it also has a fast, silent ultrasonic focus motor, image stabiliser and high grade lens elements for clearer images with less distortion. It is about £349 if you shop around.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by pogo »

shiuming wrote:As for RAW, I woulnd't worry too much about it. You have to know what you're doing and be dedicated to shoot RAW and be able to produce a better result than the in-camera JPEG engine. Use it as and when you feel you've reached the limit of what the camera renders as a JPEG. Again, "purists" will scoff at the idea of buying a DSLR and shooting JPEG but at the end of the day it's about the photography, shooting RAW won't make a better photographer out of anyone.
It won't but it's still a good thing to have, perhaps more so if you don't always know what you're doing. On a compact you generally can't do better than it's default auto-everything mode, and if you want to use the SLR like that then you'll be fine with JPEG. But you're then only using a small part of it's functionality. But when you start trying things out, like turning off auto exposure and aperture to play with depth of field or manually set the exposure on a difficult scene, you'll make mistakes and end up with some over exposed and under exposed shots.

If you want to recover these later it's far easier with the 12 or 14 bits of colour depth in RAW than JPEG, as far more detail is preserved in under and over exposed areas. Fixing the white balance is also easier, if you do so by selecting one or more neutral colour points in the picture, as often the best such points are the same white ones that get clamped to 0xffffff and so lose information in a JPEG. With storage cheap and RAW support built into modern OSes there's little reason not to use it.
User avatar
matt303
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4219
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 3:37 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: matt303uk
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by matt303 »

I shoot everything on my 350D in RAW, as soon as you start using software like Lightroom, Aperture or Photoshop you'd be stupid not to because you are throwing a lot of the functionality of the software away if you shoot in JPEG. Memory cards are silly cheap now so why limit your post processing for the want of a few quid, I don't think you can even get a DSLR that can't shoot in RAW.
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Kamineko »

My dad just bought himself a Nikon D40 right out of nowhere. I didn't even know he wanted a camera.

He's gone down the prom with it. I really, really hope he doesn't get it covered in sand and poo.

He's going to have a right laugh when he tries to get a picture out of it. (He's set it to NEF.)
User avatar
piku
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20960
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
Location: Wakefield
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by piku »

Kamineko wrote: He's going to have a right laugh when he tries to get a picture out of it. (He's set it to NEF.)
That'll be amusing if he's using Windows :)

"Borrow" the camera and change the setting back to JPEG or JPEG+RAW.

Then point him at this URL to read... http://digital-photography-school.com/b ... ould-know/
return (0);
User avatar
Portland
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8828
Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 8:16 am 0
Location: Swinton, South Yorkshire

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Portland »

D3X :wink:
Portland 3.0.1.0 public release rolled out
User avatar
ThetaReactor
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3543
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2004 4:46 am 0
Location: Face-down in the shag rug.

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by ThetaReactor »

Hi, I'm just gonna jump right on in here.

My dad's an amateur photographer. He's got an old Nikon FG that's pushing thirty, and three different lenses. I'd like to get him a DSLR. I figure I'd rather surprise him with "Let's go get a camera" rather than "Hey, here's a camera", because I think they're rather personal things and one should have some input into one's camera. But I digress.

Part of me says to get a Nikon so he can use the old lenses. The other part says that they're older than dirt, and apparently even the metering won't work on the consumer-level models. While he's obviously quite used to manual focus, asking him to do exposure the hard way just seems barbaric. Would he be better off leaving the old stuff for the occasional 35mm adventure and just getting new lenses with bells and whistles?
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Kamineko »

I've asked the sage at the camera shop.

He says that, in my range, the Nikons are good, the Canons are good, the Pentaxes are good (apparently it would be a very neat trick if I could get one), the Sonys are not so good.
shiuming
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 186
Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:07 am 0
Location: London, UK
Contact:

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by shiuming »

ThetaReactor wrote:Part of me says to get a Nikon so he can use the old lenses. The other part says that they're older than dirt, and apparently even the metering won't work on the consumer-level models. While he's obviously quite used to manual focus, asking him to do exposure the hard way just seems barbaric. Would he be better off leaving the old stuff for the occasional 35mm adventure and just getting new lenses with bells and whistles?
Unless they're particulary good lenses and/or money is really tight, I'd go for new lenses. Perhaps even a high quality zoom with a useful range like the 16-85 or 18-200 VR, for more convenience. Fast silent AF, stabilisation and digital sensor specific coatings. The idea of using old film lenses on a digital body is nice in theory and in most cases works fine but some exhibit weaknesses when used on digital bodies.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Camera shopping (entry level DSLR)

Post by Dio »

I'm trying to get hold of a couple of cheap older Minolta lenses for Christmas' Sony A200, but they're ones I've heard work well with digital. (And I can hopefully pick up a decent suite for ~£150 that will let me learn a bit more about things before I decide to splash any cash).
Post Reply