amanset wrote:You're not grasping this "proportional response" thing, are you? Even if it is a response, seeing as everyone thinks they are responding to something.
To be honest, no. There's nothing in war, or politics, that mandates that Israel use "proportional response", nor is it a good idea. Aiming for "an eye for an eye" is a losing strategy.
No, the Powell doctrine is the way to go. In the words of Sean Connery (well, in The Untouchables, anyway): "He pulls a knife; you pull a gun. He puts one our guys in the hospital; you put one of his guys in the morgue!"
So the Palestinians should concentrate on acquiring substantially more powerful armaments in order to play at being Connery?
It might perhaps be better to ask what purpose, in the minds of Israel's leaders, this massacre is intended to serve. If it is supposed to put an end to Israel being attacked then this presumably cannot be achieved without wholesale genocide.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
amanset wrote:
You're not grasping this "proportional response" thing, are you? Even if it is a response, seeing as everyone thinks they are responding to something.
To be honest, no. There's nothing in war, or politics, that mandates that Israel use "proportional response", nor is it a good idea. Aiming for "an eye for an eye" is a losing strategy.
No, the Powell doctrine is the way to go. In the words of Sean Connery (well, in The Untouchables, anyway): "He pulls a knife; you pull a gun. He puts one our guys in the hospital; you put one of his guys in the morgue!"
To be fair though. If you're going to fight a war the general idea is to get your opponent to stop fighting you as quickly as possible. I'm not saying Israel's tactics are correct but using overwhelming force is a fairly normal (if brutal) tactic to use.
amanset wrote:
You're not grasping this "proportional response" thing, are you? Even if it is a response, seeing as everyone thinks they are responding to something.
To be honest, no. There's nothing in war, or politics, that mandates that Israel use "proportional response", nor is it a good idea. Aiming for "an eye for an eye" is a losing strategy.
No, the Powell doctrine is the way to go. In the words of Sean Connery (well, in The Untouchables, anyway): "He pulls a knife; you pull a gun. He puts one our guys in the hospital; you put one of his guys in the morgue!"
There's this thing called humanity.
I can't decide between "In war?" or "Oh, the humanity!" as responses. Think I'll send in a gunboat instead.
HGFB wrote:To be fair though. If you're going to fight a war the general idea is to get your opponent to stop fighting you as quickly as possible. I'm not saying Israel's tactics are correct but using overwhelming force is a fairly normal (if brutal) tactic to use.
Although if they'd read any history books they'd note largely ineffectual against terrorism. See Afghanistan 1980s, the French Resistance, Northern Ireland, etc.
HGFB wrote:To be fair though. If you're going to fight a war the general idea is to get your opponent to stop fighting you as quickly as possible. I'm not saying Israel's tactics are correct but using overwhelming force is a fairly normal (if brutal) tactic to use.
HGFB wrote:To be fair though. If you're going to fight a war the general idea is to get your opponent to stop fighting you as quickly as possible. I'm not saying Israel's tactics are correct but using overwhelming force is a fairly normal (if brutal) tactic to use.
Harlequin wrote:It might perhaps be better to ask what purpose, in the minds of Israel's leaders, this massacre is intended to serve. If it is supposed to put an end to Israel being attacked then this presumably cannot be achieved without wholesale genocide.
I don't now think this is intended as genocide, the casualty figures are too low for that.
I too have no idea what the outcome expected by Israel could be.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Harlequin wrote:It might perhaps be better to ask what purpose, in the minds of Israel's leaders, this massacre is intended to serve. If it is supposed to put an end to Israel being attacked then this presumably cannot be achieved without wholesale genocide.
I don't now think this is intended as genocide, the casualty figures are too low for that.
I too have no idea what the outcome expected by Israel could be.
I agree that the intent of genocide is unlikely. This suggests, however, that ending the attacks upon Israel is also not the immediate intent. Surely its government is aware that the bombardment is only going to have the opposite effect.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Israel has an election coming. The current administration is essentially centrist, they're keen not to be outflanked on the security front by the right-wing Likud. You might too.
Hamas literally thrives on the misery of its people, simple as.
Rib wrote:Personally if I was in charge of the world, I would just move Israel to some empty state in America and put up with their moaning about religious persecution rather than the corpses on both sides.
If only that could work. I send them to Utah and make them live with the Mormans.
They don't accept Jesus and the old testament, it would be amusing to see them trying to cope with people knocking on the door to teach them about the profit Joseph Smith and his book.
Would the Palestinians accept relocation? I'm thinking not, because of the heritage they have dating so far back. But the people are pretty damn miserable, and might welcome a chance for a better future. Has anyone offered?