Space Cowboy wrote:Peter St. John wrote:I will ask again though - what does Israel think this is going to do?
Do you really think they should do nothing? That rockets being launched in to Israel should be met with nothing more than, what, diplomatic pressure? What kind of signal does a failure to respond to repeated provocation by Hamas send out? I think that's what forces Israel's response, but I agree with you in as much as I fail to see it actually resolving anything, but perhaps doing nothing would actually make things worse.
Who was it who broke the most recent ceasefire? Also, where is the ground for negotiation while Hamas are still vowing to wipe Israel from the face of the Earth? I would suggest there's not really grounds for negotiation while that's their public, very public stance. Perhaps that's what Israel also feels.
Space Cowboy, Back in November 4th, Israel Violated the 6 month Cease-Fire, several times apparently, whereas Hamas honoured the Cease-Fire. It responded when the Cease-Fire was over, and was accused of "Violating the cease-fire", we all know what happened then. I guess their media did a good job convincing the tools in the world
Not saying Hamas is doing the right thing firing rockets in Israel, but, could it be, that their firing rockets due to the ill-treatment off Palestinians from Israeli Hands?
As for "Diplomatic Pressure". Israel has always used Physical ad Military pressure against all Palestinians when it has met any opposition. To the extent it is responsible for illegal killings, illegal kidnapings, illegally bull dozing houses for "security purposes" etc.
How come there is no "Diplomatic Pressure" against Israel to punish the soldiers reposible? like you said, "what kind of signal does a failure to respod to repeated provation by the
Israeli Army send out?"
Surely not punishing it's soldiers and simply "throwing" them out of the army is not going to look well i the eyes of Palestians? Or do their opinios not count anymore?
Even when an American Human Rights Worker, Rachel Corrie who bull dozed over, video footage and eye-witness accounts all pointed at one clear intetion, Intention to take her out.
How about James Miller? The Cameraman shot. IDF first insisted it was Palestiniant "Terrorists", then insisted it was due to a Cross-Fire and he was caught in the middle. Turned out, according to the ATPN tape, only 2 shots were heard. 1 shot, which resulted in the cry "We are British Journalists", the 2nd shot killed James Miller. The Soldier responsible was ot punished, just disciplined for changing his story. End of Discussion.
Do't let me get started on countless of civillians been sniped in the head. Kids playing Football to toddlers, shot by a sniper. IDF says: Cross Fire, Case Closed.
This current conflict has shown the true colours of the Israeli Army too, Leaving toddlers for dead, "Evacuating" 100 civllians into a building, then shelled it:http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1054217.html
Fact of the matter is, When Israel can do crap like this, and get away with it, you can't be surprised if somebody getst ticked off and decides to fight back.
It does not matter who it is, If they oppose ISrael, their considered a terrorist, and Israel will have it's excuse to do as it is doing now.
I don't buy into the "Oh they voted for Hamas not Fatah, so it was going to happen" BS either.
When Arafat was in charage, Fatah was made out to be the leader of the world evil terrorist organization etc. He was a blood thirsty idiot, and all problems in Gaza and the West Bank had nothing to do with Israel, but was Fatah's fault.
So i find it ironic when the Israeli government 'insists' Palestinians should have voted for Fatah, when it knows fully well what happened when Fatah was in charge last time