Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Mark
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3611
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 7:53 pm 0
Location: England

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Mark »

arron wrote:As I said, it's a illusion set up through convenience and convention. If anything, it reduces the IT skills of the owner, by ensuring that they have no experience of actually setting up a computer. This then plays into MS hands as it then makes it easier to sell their PC management services and removes the ability of the user to (1) fix problems with something they own and (2) stops people understanding enough to differentiate whether they actually have a choice. Not supplying install media for Windows is pretty clever in that it instils the sense of fragility to the software installed. A recovery disk means you can't move it to another machine. It makes it a non-replaceable non-transferable component. If you lose it, then you might as well buy another machine, or buy a newer version of Windows.


I know people who if I gave them an install disk for an OS, have no idea how to install it, have no idea what a disk partition is..or will never remove the side off their PC to install new hardware because they're scared it will stop working. They'd rather go out and buy a new one just because they can stop worrying about breaking it by changing something. This is what happens when you take the knowledge out of the hands of people and replace it with ignorance.
Most drivers can't fix their own car. They pay garages to do that.

Computers are the same. More people using them is good and empowering, and will make them ever more accessible. If their next of kin can fix the bloody things over the phone (which I can if it's Windows) - that's also good. Expecting an end user to install their chosen operating system (when most of them don't know what an OS is and just want a "computer", let alone having a preference between potential operating systems) is so far beyond most peoples' understanding it's untrue.

You may as well try to explain how to perform a spinning bird kick to your average Wii owner.
Benevolent Dictator of Bearcat Games
Twitter: #BearcatGames
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Absolute_Zero »

arron wrote:I know people who if I gave them an install disk for an OS, have no idea how to install it, have no idea what a disk partition is..
8O
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by arron »

Mark wrote:Expecting an end user to install their chosen operating system (when most of them don't know what an OS is and just want a "computer", let alone having a preference between potential operating systems) is so far beyond most peoples' understanding it's untrue.
If that were true, then I'd have never learned to do that for myself, along with everyone else I know who used to do it. Installing OSes is not a difficult job, and can teach you quite a bit if you don't hide it all behind a progress bar. I originally installed Redhat 5 on my machine about twelve years ago, and I was surprised how much information was presented compared to installing Win95. Sure it was more difficult at first to understand what was going on, but I've never found learning to be something to be avoided.

Compare the documentation that came with an 80s computer vs. a modern PC. In the eighties, having technical info and a BASIC interpreter turned people into people who understood computers. Yak himself in the Llamasoft History got into programming through the BASIC installed in the Commodore PET. And what of technology today? It's all geared to making people unthinking unquestioning consumers who don't think about what they've lost and keep spending money when prompted in the right way.

The point is that although you can have the choice to take your car to your garage, you can learn to fix it yourself and buy the tools to do a lot of the repairs yourself. I did for my first two cars. With my current car (a Vauxhall Vectra) I am told that I'm only supposed to touch things under a bonnet that are coloured yellow. I've seen concept cars that you can't lift the bonnet on without a key and you fill water and oil through flaps like filling a car with fuel. I had the engineer at the dealer telling me that I needed a replacement head gasket and steering rack, when on inspection it was clear that none of these two components were at fault. I couldn't even take off the engine covers as they are fitted with special bolts. If I'd merely agreed, then the only information I'd have had in the end was the bill. With modern cars, they're so geared to being "consumer devices" they are effectively hired from the manufacturer. You have little power to find out how they work through the manufacturer and fix them yourselves. It's not in their interest to make it easy for you.

If the guy who supplied your software decides that he's not going to fix it any longer and wants you to pay him money for a new one, then do you risk losing your data going with someone else, or do you just pony up the dough assured by his promises it will still keep working afterwards?

Perhaps it's just me as a scientist and technology enthusiast, but I'd rather be empowered than exploited or pandered to. Then if I feel a need to rebel, I have the information and tools to do so. And if the Software Dinosaur Behemoths die out, then we have something to replace it by people with the skills and abilities. The mammals will continue on to inherit the Earth.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Absolute_Zero »

Nerd in delusions of normality, shocker.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Darkflame »

User's arnt as stupid as they think they are.

Mostly people can read, understand, and know what to do if the onscreen instructions are clear.
But they are scared of messing things up. Thats the biggest barrier, particularly to scary-sounding things like OS installations.
The actualy doing it is easy, however, and they have no trouble with, if they get over this fear.
OS's these days, Linux included, are hardly more then putting a disc in, and clicking "yes" half a dozen times.

Installing a webbrowser, even easier.
(and, more importantly, less likely to have unexpected problems)
piku wrote:
benedictw wrote:MS don't allow other browsers to be preinstalled with windows. Essentially this ties a large number of people to IE (and the resulting malware etc) from the start, as they aren't bright enough to download and install anything else.
That bit's wrong, but then again the same clueless newbie users wouldn't know why they should even use Firefox instead of MSIE.

Either the users need to get smarter, or the rest of us need to stop and realise that people don't really care what software they run, so long as they can do specific tasks like "go on the Internet" or "Read some email".

No point giving people a choice if they don't understand why there is a choice in the first place, .
People can benifit from things without knowing the exact reasons.

Even in very indirect ways;

If IE held a weaker market share, it might be made, you know, decent.
This would save web developers (like myself) shitloads of time when developeing websites, and thus reduce the cost of making and maintaining websites, which thus saves the end user either some money, or some adverts.

Its littarly true when I'm developing that a VERY large percentage of time is spent getting around random problems that ONLY appear in IE.

I dont think I'm alone.

Theres other areas where Microsoft's sloppy IE development is costing consumers too. For instance, the way they have completely disregarded SVG support consistently over many generations of browsers (no support in IE8 at all).
A few lines of SVG could, idly, give us a gradient background on a webpage, or beveled corners....or all manner of resolution-independent elements with just a few lines of code inline in the html. This could, cuncumlativity save *massive* bandwidth costs for consumers and hosters alike. All those little separate requests for gifs and jpegs, replaced with just a tiny amount more added to the main html. (a gradient in svg is, like, 2 lines, incidentally).
Arguing for SVG plugins, incidentally, is a no-no, as they overlay the image...making it useless for most webdesign.
---

I'm not sure what the best replacement is to have a good balance between removing microsofts monopoly, and maxium easy of use for the consumer, but I agree absolutely that IE should be removed from being a necessary part of the OS.
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by arron »

Absolute_Zero wrote:Nerd in delusions of normality, shocker.
I don't think it's unreasonable myself. I'm a geek (someone who learns obscure knowledge to understand, explore and do new useful things) rather than a nerd (ineffectual obsessive collector of trivia) who merely wants to lose himself in pointless activities to avoid life in the real world.

I was reading this, this evening and it made me consider how in exchange for the society we live in, we don't make much of an effort to understand it or what might happen if it went away. If a small part of it failed (such as oil, water, electricity, money etc) then pretty much all of it would go with it..and the internet would fall apart, so say goodbye to Googling for everything. You could argue that some of the information within is pretty useless (such as making lucky charms or "futurism") but how about how to make candles or milk a goat? Do you know where your local library is? Can you find a book on the subject instead? I think that we've probably lost touch with much of the basic mechanisms for survival as a species as it's all brought to us by other people.

You can read the various editions on-line.

http://www.wholeearth.com/issue-electro ... p?iss=1010
http://www.wholeearth.com/issue-electro ... p?iss=1230

So the EU decide that Microsoft should have less power over people through forcing them to unbundle a few things, or not pre-loading their software onto machines. Does that not actually help break people out of their cosy position to realising how they're responsible for their own machines? Or is it some kind of petty annoyance to stop people who don't care about computers getting their work done?

If MS suddenly failed due to a Enron style end, or a credit crunch collapse, would we be clamouring for our governments to bail them out because we are scared of our computers suddenly stopping working? It works for banks, because they're part of everything these days. MS have also managed to take over so much of computing and the internet, that if they went, a lot of what we are today would go with it. The way to avoid this is to ensure that more people know enough to cope should such an event happen. It's not in the interests of monopolistic corporations to do this, but that's tough for them in my book. It's gone too far their way.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Flabio
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8717
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2004 12:37 pm 0
Location: Guildford

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Flabio »

arron wrote:Or is it some kind of petty annoyance to stop people who don't care about computers getting their work done?
For the vast majority of people that use computers these days, it's this.

Rightly or wrongly.

Computers are an appliance now in the same way that a car, a fridge and a microwave are. Most people don't know how they actually work, they just need to know how to use them. When they stop working they pay someone to come make them work again.

Those of us that have grown up with computers don't view them that way. Someone who grows up tinkering with cars in his dads garage probably thinks the same thing about your average Ford Focus driver as we do about the average Windows user.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Absolute_Zero »

What download speeds do you get there on Mars, Arron?

Believe it or not, MS do not control the internet via IE or IIS... the world would merrily continue turning if they suddenly ceased to exist. New exploits? Firewalls, workarounds, 3rd-party solutions and virtual machines. How else is the digital ecosystem in imminent danger of catastrophic collapse?

Computers, for *most* people, are a tool, a means to an end... not an end, in and of itself. EU funded 'grep' classes for the over-sixties or 'partition tables' for teens? No, rather than legislating Microsoft out of existence [for fear that they might go out of existence, apparently] how about the revolutionaries get off their elitist command-line-warrior arses and a produce compelling solution for the desktop that *ordinary* people are willing to use? Otherwise, get a Mac.
User avatar
sack
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7077
Joined: Fri May 10, 2002 4:13 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: evilgopher
PSN: sixFiveOhTwo
Location: Rijswijk, The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by sack »

There is an 'economy of fear' around computing where every last person knows that the day the end user knows what they know they are screwed and going to be stacking shelves in Tesco pretty soon. If people feel helpless they'll come running and pay an 'expert' to do it for them. The techies feel particularly scared because they also know in the grand scheme of things they don't know much that can't be worked out by someone for themselves - because that's how they did it after all.

But I don't think Microsoft are the biggest problem in this case.

How many people were told to 'piss off back to windows, newbie!' when dipping their toes into Linux for the first time? Hell - until ubuntu got things sorted the average Linux distribution was an information overload, spewing every last piece of info to the screen in an unfriendly way, clunky window managers, the bloody 'man' system where you needed to know the oddly named command to find out how to use it, the 'who needs a manual, you've got the sourcecode!' approach to usability. It's the opposite effect of windows - provide so much information the user doesn't know where to start so actually absorbs none!

The open source business model is wholly reliant on overcomplicated and underdocumented software being given away for free. The reliance on the user being uneducated is still there. Just call Microsoft products 'toys' a few times to pander to the ego of the hardcore nerds and IT managers and soon you have them sat there staring at a screen full of bootup spew saying 'I don't know what the smeg is going on, but all that information in front of me means this HAS to be powerful'... and away you go! profit time! Just wander in offering 'strategic enterprise solutions' and make it work.

Software-wise I'm thinking with the latest Ubuntu linux really is getting there, despite the fact that usability and user-friendliness work against the open source business model, but the 'keeping the user dumb' tactics are used on both sides of the fence so I don't think it's fair that anyone just points the finger at Microsoft on this one.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Dio »

sack wrote:The open source business model is wholly reliant on overcomplicated and underdocumented software being given away for free.
Yeah, this is one of the things that I think is holding Linux back. No support needed == no revenue for Red Hat, Novell etc.

Ubuntu does seem to be making an effort, but I wouldn't be surprised if someone senior at either of those companies hasn't sent a 'concerned' email about it in the past.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Absolute_Zero »

benedictw wrote:MS don't allow other browsers to be preinstalled with windows. Essentially this ties a large number of people to IE (and the resulting malware etc) from the start, as they aren't bright enough to download and install anything else.
Since (against my better judgment) I've gotten sucked into this fest of misinformation and reflex MS bile... is that actually true?

http://news.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid ... 7&from=rss

In other news (it would seem for some): IE7 is compares quite well security-wise to its competitors. IE8 is more standards compatible. Personally, I prefer Firefox.
User avatar
Little stoned kiwi
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4598
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
Location: Christchurch

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Little stoned kiwi »

Absolute_Zero wrote:Believe it or not, MS do not control the internet via IE or IIS.
Yes, they do. Maybe not our personal spaces, but MS have a strangle-hold on the business market and education sectors. Many have package deals with MS that include using their server products, using IE, using Office...it's a monopoly. My girlfriend wasn't allowed to install a different browser or OpenOffice, it went against their IT policy as it would anger MS. There was an issue recently where NZ schools had to uninstall Office from any Apple's they had - the multi-million dollar contract the government had didn't cover Macs and were demanding more money than it was worth. Clearly to discourage Macs from being a viable option.
I don't have issues with MS selling/giving their OS, or selling/giving applications. Integrating them into the OS and forcing them on people who don't want/need it is wrong.
They never were nice about it. They have always had their own set of standards for IE. When javascript came out, MS wrote their own subtly different version. With the Java virtual machine, they wrote their own that wasn't completely compatible with Sun's. And because MS have such a large share of the 'browser market', websites and intranets are made to run on IE first, others last(if at all).
User avatar
seibu
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Dec 20, 2004 3:24 pm 0

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by seibu »

sack wrote:There is an 'economy of fear' around computing where every last person knows that the day the end user knows what they know they are screwed and going to be stacking shelves in Tesco pretty soon. If people feel helpless they'll come running and pay an 'expert' to do it for them. The techies feel particularly scared because they also know in the grand scheme of things they don't know much that can't be worked out by someone for themselves - because that's how they did it after all.
True and wise. I meet one nearly every day.
The open source business model is wholly reliant on overcomplicated and underdocumented software being given away for free. The reliance on the user being uneducated is still there. Just call Microsoft products 'toys' a few times to pander to the ego of the hardcore nerds and IT managers and soon you have them sat there staring at a screen full of bootup spew saying 'I don't know what the smeg is going on, but all that information in front of me means this HAS to be powerful'... and away you go! profit time! Just wander in offering 'strategic enterprise solutions' and make it work.

Software-wise I'm thinking with the latest Ubuntu linux really is getting there, despite the fact that usability and user-friendliness work against the open source business model, but the 'keeping the user dumb' tactics are used on both sides of the fence so I don't think it's fair that anyone just points the finger at Microsoft on this one.
I don't agree with this at all and I'm sorry you seem to have met such dicks when dealing with Open Source. I'm not surprised if you've met *some* private companies who behave like you describe because they sell (probably bad) support for Open Source software. But every Open Source project I've been involved with has bent over backwards to make their software usable, and indeed to encourage users to become developers. Funding Open Source development is hard, but the success of things like Ubuntu demonstrates that if your software is good enough and widely used, there will always be companies (and indeed individuals) who fund development, because it's in their own interests to do so. I notice you can't really explain the success of Ubuntu, and it does indeed run counter to your argument.

You don't need to maintain a climate of ignorance and fear among your general user base to stay afloat with Open Source, even if there are a few short sighted people who've come from the old proprietary culture and might still try it. Certainly, it's absolutely absurd to say it's part of the 'open source business model'. Indeed, it was informed users taking a stand against this culture which gave birth to Open Source in the first place.
User avatar
Zen-Chan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5499
Joined: Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:12 pm 0
Location: Glasgow, Scotland

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Zen-Chan »

I would see my parents as typical computer users - they can use the internet, they can send emails, print out documents, put music on an iPod with iTunes . . .

But they have absolutely no concept of anything beyond the desktop. They certainly couldn't comprehend disk partitions or even what an operating system essentially is, they can run the main programs on the desktop and that gives them everything they need.
User avatar
Kelloggs
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1859
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.

Re: Microsoft in trouble yet again....

Post by Kelloggs »

I think half the problem is that, yes, computers are becoming "appliances" like cars, food mixers, whatever, whereby it is assumed that people can just use them, given a minimum level of training/practise/pissing about with them, BUT... they aren't, really, are they? Precisely because they're so flexible, they can easily become fragile.

A handful of thoughts, worth no more than what you've paid for them:

- We've got a food mixer at home, must be at least 40 years old. What bits of it remain physically unbroken after 40 years probably work fine, but if it stops, I'm never going to try and pop the top and fix it, because we also have a food processor which is about five years old, which does all that the food mixer did. It probably won't still be working in 35 years, though.

- My car has had a few new clutches (due to garage-related fuckups) which is something I couldn't possibly have done myself (lack of tools/parts/knowledge) and when it no longer works, I'll sell the remains and get a new one. In all the time I've been driving (19 years) I've never hit anything that's been moving (don't ask).

Both of the above can be considered "appliances" in that, they are purchased to do a specific job (mix food, transport bodies) and if they stop doing that to spec, it's fairly obvious, and warranties and such are in place to catch the results. Computers, however, aren't purchased for a specific task (running Windows is probably as close to specific as you could twist it, and then there's the applications on top) but if it goes out of spec, you won't know for a while. You might eventually get a BSOD with error 0x80001327, but at that point it's too late. The oil warning light in the car would have come on 438 viruses ago, and you could have put more oil in, but now the engine's seized up, and it's fucked. Time for the mechanic.

(These are random thoughts, and as you can see, you can't really mix car analogies with computers very well, because there's no good overlap. I don't think we have a large enough body of humans alive for whom computers are innately understandable, as "appliances" are, and their complexity, whether engineered or emergent, seems to have outstripped our potential to catch up.)
Post Reply