Salty wrote:xav wrote:And I could provide a few counter-cases where I've set up non-techie users with Linux machines, and they've got on perfectly well with them. The plural of anecdote is not data.
I'm sure you can, but could they have done it themselves? I doubt it.
Possibly not - but then they wouldn't try to install Windows themselves, either. In that respect I was just serving the same purpose as Dell or some other vendor - supplying them with a machine with a working OS.
Having said that, yes I think they
could have done it themselves - their failure to do so was more due to fear of the unknown rather than any specific difficulty with installing Ubuntu. Generally I find that the Ubuntu installer is miles ahead of the Windows installer in terms of ease-of-use. The only tricky bit is dealing with partitions - but as these were bare-bones installations with no existing Windows partition to preserve it was a simple case of clicking "Next".
Salty wrote:It's what is provided when you buy a PC with Windows on it. I think I'm a fairly advanced user of 'computers', moreso than the general population at least, and I struggle with it although I get there in the end. Linux is getting better and I hope it gets more attention from the likes of PC World where more customer feedback will make it more accessible for people.
Freely downloaded Linux distributions can't legally ship with various codecs (MP3 and DVD playback spring to mind), but there's nothing to stop a vendor adding those things, like they do with Windows. There's nothing to stop a customer from subsequently buying those codecs and apps, in which case the installation will be much like any Windows app (double click on the installer, and click "Next" a few times). If they want to add them without paying then there might be a little bit more effort involved - but even that has become much simpler recently (double click on an MP3 file in Ubuntu and it will install the codec for you, for example).
Conversely a bare Windows XP installation comes with no spreadsheet application, no presentation app, no vector graphics editor, no photo manager, no bitTorrent client. Of the apps it does come with, the text editor is dreadful, the word processor (WordPad) lacks much functionality, the bitmap graphics editor is poor, the selection of games is very limited, the IM app only works with one protocol and the web browser is widely considered to be one of the worst ones available. Vista probably improves on a few of these areas, but I haven't used it enough to comment.
A fresh Ubuntu installation comes with all those missing apps, plus better and more comprehensive versions of the neutered XP apps. That's without going anywhere near the "Add/remove..." menu item.
So basically you consider Linux to be worse than Windows because it used to be a bit tricky to install an MP3 codec, whereas I consider Windows to be inferior to Linux because I have to subsequently add a load of apps that I expect to see as standard. In either case the issue can be solved by the vendor bundling apps and/or codecs to deal with these shortcomings - generally at a cost to the customer. However I suspect that you haven't been comparing like with like. If I had to guess, it was probably something like this:
- System 1: Bought with Windows already installed, with MP3 and DVD codecs bundled by the vendor, and possibly with other software bundled as well.
- System 2: Installed Linux yourself - possibly having to deal with the issue of dual-booting. Not vendor supplied, so no codecs or additional software bundled.