Wooden barrel-type submarines, so that doesn't count.GeeZa wrote:Wasn't there a submarine in Wind Waker or am I getting confused?Kon-Tiki wrote:The same could be said about the steamboat in Phantom Hourglass then, or the Dark Link switchamaroony thing in Twilight Princess, I think, or about that 2D platform thing in Zelda 2.IronGiant wrote: Looks good and I like the music, but no doubt some will moan about the presence of a steam train.
Nintendo DS > God
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Re: Nintendo DS > God
But it might have had sonar navigation inside.Kon-Tiki wrote:Wooden barrel-type submarines, so that doesn't count.GeeZa wrote: Wasn't there a submarine in Wind Waker or am I getting confused?
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Always mystified when people complain about the touch controls on PH - I thought they were great.
Having said that, if an option to use trad controls instead would shut the whiners up, then why not. Though I reckon it would likely cause problems wherever there's a real-time in-game mechanic that requires the stylus to function properly, e.g. pathfinding for the boomerang, which is infinitely more useful with touch controls than it ever was with joypad-only. So you're either going to still be holding a stylus for long periods of time, just in case you need to use it quickly, or putting it down/away and then scrambling for it when required.
Personally, I'd rather just use the stylus.
Must admit I'm not 100% sold on the train thing, but given that the free movement of the boat in PH was largely pointless, since 99% of the time you went to the most obvious "next" place to be, it might as well have been on tracks.
(WW felt different for some reason, and encouraged me to explore far more than I did in PH. Not sure why; possibly since WW was one continuous world, rather than separate "ocean" and "island" states, it made me want to skirt around every island and outcrop, to see if anything was hidden there.)
Anyway, the main thing is: new Zelda for DS! Woo!
Having said that, if an option to use trad controls instead would shut the whiners up, then why not. Though I reckon it would likely cause problems wherever there's a real-time in-game mechanic that requires the stylus to function properly, e.g. pathfinding for the boomerang, which is infinitely more useful with touch controls than it ever was with joypad-only. So you're either going to still be holding a stylus for long periods of time, just in case you need to use it quickly, or putting it down/away and then scrambling for it when required.
Personally, I'd rather just use the stylus.
Must admit I'm not 100% sold on the train thing, but given that the free movement of the boat in PH was largely pointless, since 99% of the time you went to the most obvious "next" place to be, it might as well have been on tracks.
(WW felt different for some reason, and encouraged me to explore far more than I did in PH. Not sure why; possibly since WW was one continuous world, rather than separate "ocean" and "island" states, it made me want to skirt around every island and outcrop, to see if anything was hidden there.)
Anyway, the main thing is: new Zelda for DS! Woo!
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Regular movement/fighting with D-pad and ABXY-buttons and boomerang/bombchu/etc with the stylus wouldn't be any different from any other game that uses both. Personally, I always end up with the stylus in the corner of my mouth. Getting it from there's absolutely no hassle whatsoever. Attacking while dodging incoming attacks, however, is near impossible with stylus-only controls (as shown in the ghost pingpong boss fight)Foozwah wrote:Always mystified when people complain about the touch controls on PH - I thought they were great.
Having said that, if an option to use trad controls instead would shut the whiners up, then why not. Though I reckon it would likely cause problems wherever there's a real-time in-game mechanic that requires the stylus to function properly, e.g. pathfinding for the boomerang, which is infinitely more useful with touch controls than it ever was with joypad-only. So you're either going to still be holding a stylus for long periods of time, just in case you need to use it quickly, or putting it down/away and then scrambling for it when required.
Personally, I'd rather just use the stylus.
Must admit I'm not 100% sold on the train thing, but given that the free movement of the boat in PH was largely pointless, since 99% of the time you went to the most obvious "next" place to be, it might as well have been on tracks.![]()
(WW felt different for some reason, and encouraged me to explore far more than I did in PH. Not sure why; possibly since WW was one continuous world, rather than separate "ocean" and "island" states, it made me want to skirt around every island and outcrop, to see if anything was hidden there.)
Anyway, the main thing is: new Zelda for DS! Woo!
Re: Nintendo DS > God
I thought the stylus controls in Phantom Hourglass were nigh-on perfect. I'd love to see what they could do with a (proper) Wii Zelda.
Also: steam train huzzah!
Also: steam train huzzah!
- Phineasfool
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:57 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Phineasfool
- PSN: Phineasfool
- Location: Colorado, USA
Re: Nintendo DS > God
If they had done this instead I would of loved Phantom Hourglass. I hated having to use the stylus for regular movement and basic attacks.Kon-Tiki wrote:Regular movement/fighting with D-pad and ABXY-buttons and boomerang/bombchu/etc with the stylus wouldn't be any different from any other game that uses both. Personally, I always end up with the stylus in the corner of my mouth. Getting it from there's absolutely no hassle whatsoever. Attacking while dodging incoming attacks, however, is near impossible with stylus-only controls (as shown in the ghost pingpong boss fight)Foozwah wrote:Always mystified when people complain about the touch controls on PH - I thought they were great.
Having said that, if an option to use trad controls instead would shut the whiners up, then why not. Though I reckon it would likely cause problems wherever there's a real-time in-game mechanic that requires the stylus to function properly, e.g. pathfinding for the boomerang, which is infinitely more useful with touch controls than it ever was with joypad-only. So you're either going to still be holding a stylus for long periods of time, just in case you need to use it quickly, or putting it down/away and then scrambling for it when required.
Personally, I'd rather just use the stylus.
Must admit I'm not 100% sold on the train thing, but given that the free movement of the boat in PH was largely pointless, since 99% of the time you went to the most obvious "next" place to be, it might as well have been on tracks.![]()
(WW felt different for some reason, and encouraged me to explore far more than I did in PH. Not sure why; possibly since WW was one continuous world, rather than separate "ocean" and "island" states, it made me want to skirt around every island and outcrop, to see if anything was hidden there.)
Anyway, the main thing is: new Zelda for DS! Woo!
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Absolutely.Always mystified when people complain about the touch controls on PH - I thought they were great.
I found it perfect for movement and puzzles alike, while simultaniously making all the old items fresh and new again.
(Rope, Bomberange, even Bombshu's.....it was basicaly like they were new items).
I never had any trouble during boss fights either. Maybe I hold it differently or something.
Either way, DPad would have killed the majority of the game for me.
Even giving Dpad as an option means the game has to be designed for it. (which effects movement precisions, directions, as well as puzzles.....I think many people underestimate just how much a change of controlls can effect gameplay. Okami is far too easy on the Wii compared to the PS2, for example....thanks to the drawing now being so easy/quick, the balance is lost).
Only downside I see to stylus-only is its not so playable when moving about (train/bus etc).
Probably.but no doubt some will moan about the presence of a steam train.
But a steamboat is going to be harder to make then a steamtrain no? (especialy one with auto-guidence).
What concerns me though is more the style. Hyrule should have different technology, not merely mimicking ours.
Jurles-Verne style stuff or steampunk is fine to move towards, but just slapping earth tech isnt
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Indeed they can which is why, for me, the stylus control method was awful.Darkflame wrote:I think many people underestimate just how much a change of controlls can effect gameplay.
My main issues were:
a) It just didn't feel right - however much I tried I just couldn't adjust to that control method
b) The stylus kept getting in the way
c) It all felt very 'gimmicky' and 'bolted on' just for the sake of using the stylus
So, stylus control in Spirit Tracks = no sale to me.
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Nothing that essential to making the majority of the puzzles work is "bolted on"
(Drawing a rope between two points with the dpad would be pretty sucky, for example.)
(Drawing a rope between two points with the dpad would be pretty sucky, for example.)
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Phineasfool
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:57 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Phineasfool
- PSN: Phineasfool
- Location: Colorado, USA
Re: Nintendo DS > God
For the puzzles and stuff like the boomerang the stylus was fine, but for regular moving and attacking I thought it was annoying to use the stylus.Darkflame wrote:Nothing that essential to making the majority of the puzzles work is "bolted on"
(Drawing a rope between two points with the dpad would be pretty sucky, for example.)
- Gorecki
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5962
- Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
- Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Nope. No feedback for the gesture controls, see. I gave up on the game after trying for the hundredth time to do a roll by drawing a circle near the edge of the screen, as instructed, and only about a quarter of them resulted in a roll with no feedback what-so-ever as to what I was doing right/wrong.Alarm wrote:I thought the stylus controls in Phantom Hourglass were nigh-on perfect.
If you have to press a button to perform an action then there's no grey area, you've either pressed the button or not. If you have to make a gesture then there's a million things that can go wrong an unless you give the player some kind of feedback then they can't learn from their mistakes.
Some people will get it first time and won't see what the problem is. Everyone else will just get pissed off and stop trying.
Tang Sou!
Re: Nintendo DS > God
It took me a few attempts to perfect the rolling gesture so that it worked every time. I can see that this could be could be a problem for some folk, but apart from this little niggle, I loved the controls.Gorecki wrote: Some people will get it first time and won't see what the problem is. Everyone else will just get pissed off and stop trying.
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Just a heads up that the American version of Rhythm Tengoku Gold (Rhythm Heaven) is now...erm..."out".
Checking it out now
Checking it out now
Re: Nintendo DS > God
Indeed.Alarm wrote:It took me a few attempts to perfect the rolling gesture so that it worked every time. I can see that this could be could be a problem for some folk, but apart from this little niggle, I loved the controls.Gorecki wrote: Some people will get it first time and won't see what the problem is. Everyone else will just get pissed off and stop trying.
Its not like you need to roll often, if at all (its not like OoT where it feels quicker to move that way).
Whereas moving with the stylus sure as hell felt quicker then moving in Minish Cap/Links Awakening etc.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Nintendo DS > God
I think we'll have to agree to differ on this one - some hate the stylus control, some love it.
It sure does suck for us stylus haters though who can't/won't play the game because of it.
It sure does suck for us stylus haters though who can't/won't play the game because of it.




