I thought Craig Charles looked pretty good for a crackhead.piku wrote:It was amusing that all the cast looked wider and more wrinkly, except Kryten. However in real life Robert Llewellyn looks way older than all the others
Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
- WiteWulf
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10125
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
- PSN: WiteWulf
- Location: Loughborough(ish)
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Sophie Winkleman FTW, tho!


:::G:::
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
- piku
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 20960
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
- Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
That is the thing... They are all evidently much better actors than they used to be.Hajile wrote:The only saving grace in the entire episode was Craig Charles, who briefly showed that after all this time on our screens, he's finally learned how to act.
So now they're actually trying to seriously act, rather than playing along with the story and having a laugh. It was too serious, in the old stuff they played a bunch of clueless idiots and it was damn funny to watch. The acting might have improved, but it's killed their comedy timing and weird little mannerisms they used to have.
return (0);
- piku
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 20960
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
- Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
He looked tired and pissed off.Wudzi wrote:I thought Craig Charles looked pretty good for a crackhead.piku wrote:It was amusing that all the cast looked wider and more wrinkly, except Kryten. However in real life Robert Llewellyn looks way older than all the others
return (0);
- StarshipUK
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1141
- Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 3:33 pm 0
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Oh Yes!WiteWulf wrote:Sophie Winkleman FTW, tho!
Not sure about that accent though.
Whats the point. It only gets deleted.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I suspect that they might have actually filmed it on the presumption that it was going to have a laughter track and then decided in post-production not to add one (possibly because fans said they didn't want one? There was that April Fool's video on YouTube, where someone added an abysmally poor laughter track to some footage - maybe they judged people's reactions off that, as there were enough "I hope there isn't a laughter track" responses that could have swayed them, and pulled the laughter track out last minute).WiteWulf wrote:Don't get me wrong, I usually hate laughter tracks, it feels forced, but the actors are all so used to putting the pauses into their delivery that it leaves those minute, distracting, pauses. They should have either got them to adjust their performance or go with the laughter track like they used to.
One thing I don't believe is that the actors would be so amateurish as to put in those tiny pauses - nor the director allow them to stand - unless, when they filmed it, they actually expected that it would have a laughter track. Then they took the decision not to put one in after all, at the proverbial last minute, so they couldn't reshoot the whole thing from scratch.
In which case, I'd therefore say the problem is not the presence or absence of the laughter track - to be honest, once I realised it wasn't there, I adjusted and enjoyed it just fine - but the mismatch.
If the actors have performed on the assumption that one would be added, then it should have been added - because they've put in all those tiny little pauses for it and those just come across as awkward silences without the laughter track. Or, if they'd decided right from the start not to put one in and then performed and filmed it that way, that would have worked too.
It's a "?type mismatch error", in C64 parlance.
Either decide to have one and stick with it. Or decide not to have one and stick with that. But don't start mixing the two together and changing your mind half-way through - either removing a laughter track from something that was performed by the actors to have one, or, equally, adding one to a performance by actors who were not leaving the required pauses in there for it, because that would fuck up the "flow" as well and have wails of laughters cutting across the next line so you can't hear it.
These are professional actors - who've been in other things where they have and haven't had to work with laughter tracks - so if they put the pauses in there, I'm definitely sure that they did it purposefully because they were told to do so (and even if they did do subconsciously, then the director should have picked up on that and shouted "cut!" then asked them to do it again - "once more...with feeling").
I think it must have been a post-production thing to change their minds and not add the laugh track.
I enjoyed it anyway - indeed, when it ended, it absolutely did not feel like I'd been watching it for half an hour.
Also, that hologram woman. I'd knob her silly.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Hajile
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1086
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 10:10 pm 0
- Location: Exactly where you don't want me to be
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Peculiar thing is, I think one of the major missteps they made in later series was the change in Lister's character - by series 6 he'd become quite a multi-layered character, the backbone that the series was based on. The curry obsession and the lager gags were still there, but as a whole he'd become a much more worldly character, as befitting someone barely surviving on the frontier. After Rob Grant's departure, boom - he was a childish idiot again, and all the positive aspects of the character were surrendered for cheap laughs.piku wrote:That is the thing... They are all evidently much better actors than they used to be.Hajile wrote:The only saving grace in the entire episode was Craig Charles, who briefly showed that after all this time on our screens, he's finally learned how to act.
So now they're actually trying to seriously act, rather than playing along with the story and having a laugh. It was too serious, in the old stuff they played a bunch of clueless idiots and it was damn funny to watch. The acting might have improved, but it's killed their comedy timing and weird little mannerisms they used to have.
If anything, the problem with Lister is that Craig Charles has become a more accomplished actor, capable of more sophisticated things, and the character he plays has been retardified, leaving him floundering, desperately trying to find a character he'd previously understood. And that's the fault of the writer.
"By the Celestial Spires!"
I go where the games are.
I go where the games are.
- piku
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 20960
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
- Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Look on the bright side, it could have been much worse.
Much, much worse...

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... 2019000687

Much, much worse...

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... 2019000687
return (0);
- The Caffeine Kid
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5691
- Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 9:24 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheCaffeineKid
- PSN: caffeinekid
- Yahoo Messenger: caffeinekid
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
From Robert's Twitter.@_micster No audience was entirely budget related, it's very expensive to have the crew and staff to organise audience.
It really suffered from lack of "live studio audience" in my opinion. Felt too quiet and bleak.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Oh dear, it's a shame when one of your favourite sci-fi comedy programmes slides uncomfortably into One Foot in the Grave and Keeping Up Appearances. They really did look like they'd were going through the motions of playing the characters, like watching Laurel and Hardy in Atoll K. I hope they're getting paid loads for this, it will definitely be the last time they all act together given this first episode..
What happened to the comedy? I was expecting Kryten to come out with some kind of witty put down..or or any of them some story of some kind. And where did the hologram come from? Did they just materialise a woman on board to distract everyone from a plot so weak you could have served it up in the afternoon at a old persons home with milk and sugar? With nearly ten years since the last one they surely could have come up with 90 minutes of solid comedy in that time to go out on?
For a twenty-five minute programme, they managed to put several minutes of filler in as well that didn't add anything at all - the scene in the diving bell when they were fighting the squid, the "science scene" and then they crashed out on a cliffhanger that wasn't. I don't know what they've done to Red Dwarf, but I hope they dub it into japanese. It will be a lot funnier to watch then..
What happened to the comedy? I was expecting Kryten to come out with some kind of witty put down..or or any of them some story of some kind. And where did the hologram come from? Did they just materialise a woman on board to distract everyone from a plot so weak you could have served it up in the afternoon at a old persons home with milk and sugar? With nearly ten years since the last one they surely could have come up with 90 minutes of solid comedy in that time to go out on?
For a twenty-five minute programme, they managed to put several minutes of filler in as well that didn't add anything at all - the scene in the diving bell when they were fighting the squid, the "science scene" and then they crashed out on a cliffhanger that wasn't. I don't know what they've done to Red Dwarf, but I hope they dub it into japanese. It will be a lot funnier to watch then..
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Not a bad start... I feel the two unanswered questions (where did Katerina come from, and how she didn't respond to Rimmer's question about how the ship could support two hard-light holograms at the same time) might be key to things. The diving bell section with Rimmer bopping away was classic though. Sorry, but it was 
Lie with passion and be forever damned...
Xbox: Mayhem64
Xbox: Mayhem64
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I don't think that stuffs really important. Red Dwarf is about the LOLs rather than the storyline.Mayhem wrote:Not a bad start... I feel the two unanswered questions (where did Katerina come from, and how she didn't respond to Rimmer's question about how the ship could support two hard-light holograms at the same time) might be key to things.
- piku
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 20960
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
- Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Yeah, so where were the LOLs thenWudzi wrote:I don't think that stuffs really important. Red Dwarf is about the LOLs rather than the storyline.Mayhem wrote:Not a bad start... I feel the two unanswered questions (where did Katerina come from, and how she didn't respond to Rimmer's question about how the ship could support two hard-light holograms at the same time) might be key to things.
And the main thing they've always drilled into the Red Dwarf universe is that there can only ever be one hologram at once (otherwise they could simply fill the ship with crew and write H on their heads), it's the very first thing we ever learn in the show if you watch episode 1, and then they keep banging on about it all the time (like in Quarantine, which they showed afterwards).
Oh, and holograms are soft light, the hard light thing was done to Rimmer specifically.
So either they're glossing over that by not answering the question, or it's important to the plot. The squid thing vanished out of the ship and was replaced by the hologram woman, so that's related somehow.
And doesn't she seem just a bit too intelligent, knowing everything about what's going on? Surely her last memories should be "OMG what is this hot radioactive air burning my skin off?".
Needs more comedy, it's not supposed to be a serious program. They always used to fill in plot holes by putting in a few extra funny bits to distract us.
return (0);
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
The lovely Big Suze.StarshipUK wrote:Oh Yes!WiteWulf wrote:Sophie Winkleman FTW, tho!
Not sure about that accent though.
So I just did a Google image search for her, of course, and you know sometimes when you realise just how far someone is out of your league that it's almost incomprehensible? Well I found out that she's engaged to Lord Frederick Windsor, FFS.
/suicide
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Well, she's probably the equivalent of Rimmer from another dimension, who has met the weird masked geezer who made his light bee hard-light and all that malarkey. A bit like that episode where they end up meeting their female selves (the Holly crossover one with both Norman and Hattie in it)
I didn't think it was as bad as some are making out - BUT, it's definitely not met the expectations that come from 9 years of development. What's next, Duke Nukem Forever comes out and is basically just Doom 3 with space-pigs and we're like "couldn't you have simply done this 15 years ago?"
I agree that 30 minutes was far too short, was just starting to get into it and then it ended. Just hoping that the next one makes up for it with 30 minutes of pure unadulterated Awesome. At the VERY LEAST, even if it's shit, don't end as shit as Series 8. Is that even possible?
I didn't think it was as bad as some are making out - BUT, it's definitely not met the expectations that come from 9 years of development. What's next, Duke Nukem Forever comes out and is basically just Doom 3 with space-pigs and we're like "couldn't you have simply done this 15 years ago?"
I agree that 30 minutes was far too short, was just starting to get into it and then it ended. Just hoping that the next one makes up for it with 30 minutes of pure unadulterated Awesome. At the VERY LEAST, even if it's shit, don't end as shit as Series 8. Is that even possible?

