Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I liked the bits with the rakes and Rimmer with the corner of the desk.
[Sir_LANs-a-lot]
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
- Gorecki
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5962
- Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
- Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
75 minutes to do a less funny version of an episode that previously took less than half an hour padded out with Blade Runner and Corrie ref's. If you're not a Red Dwarf fan-boy 0.5/10. If you are a Red Dwarf fan-boy (like me) 3, maybe 4/10.
Please, just let it die now, please.
Please, just let it die now, please.
Tang Sou!
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Cool, it wasopaopa wrote:I'm just hoping, and pleading to god that:
Spoiler: show
- Hajile
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1086
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 10:10 pm 0
- Location: Exactly where you don't want me to be
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I liked it. Not a lot, but I thought it was quite good. Lister got a wonderful sendoff. I was half expecting it to end
It'll work better when it's watched all in one go, though. That much is very, very clear. It took me a few seconds to twig that
And the bit with Rimmer and the desk had me pissing myself. Red Dwarf physical humour at its best. 
It makes me wonder though - it's clear that it'll work better as a feature length story. There were some very obvious cuts along the way, presumably for time's sake. So why make the decision to broadcast it as a three-parter when it would have worked so much better without the strict time constraints, in the form of a two hour long movie length special. Certainly would have seemed more epic and conclusion-y, if they want it to serve as a swansong. Digesting it in 25 minute long chunks made it seem altogether too ordinary.
Hell, that could have been the Red Dwarf movie, albeit a TV movie.
[EDIT]I know I've harped on about it before, but I really was astonished at the performance of Craig Charles. In that final episode he nearly had me in tears. It seems it also caught the attention of the cast - In the making of broadcast afterwards, Robert Llewellyn was mentioning how impressed he was that there was actual acting in Red Dwarf.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
It makes me wonder though - it's clear that it'll work better as a feature length story. There were some very obvious cuts along the way, presumably for time's sake. So why make the decision to broadcast it as a three-parter when it would have worked so much better without the strict time constraints, in the form of a two hour long movie length special. Certainly would have seemed more epic and conclusion-y, if they want it to serve as a swansong. Digesting it in 25 minute long chunks made it seem altogether too ordinary.
Hell, that could have been the Red Dwarf movie, albeit a TV movie.
[EDIT]I know I've harped on about it before, but I really was astonished at the performance of Craig Charles. In that final episode he nearly had me in tears. It seems it also caught the attention of the cast - In the making of broadcast afterwards, Robert Llewellyn was mentioning how impressed he was that there was actual acting in Red Dwarf.
"By the Celestial Spires!"
I go where the games are.
I go where the games are.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
And so are you and Cloudane:piku wrote:Ooh you're goodopaopa wrote:I'm just hoping, and pleading to god that:Spoiler: show
I am ashamed that I was not alerted to opaopa's prediction by the story title.piku wrote:That would actually be really funny, if it turns out the first bit was written poorly on purpose and there is some sort of entertaining conversation between the cast and their writers. It would need to fully acknowledge people like us who sit and moan about it on the Internet though. Something that says "we know you lot are out there moaning, hello! we made this for you!".Cloudane wrote:Still, there's now an in-story reason for this, so they can get away with it.
(The in-story reason is bad writing, but it's part of the story now so it's ok!)
that would be funny
I think that the star prize here, though, goes to KlaxonCow.
Other than being part of the body of work that spawned Grant and Naylor's SciFi fandom, the latter, I would think.piku wrote:Spoiler: show
I thought I was a fan. We appear to have differing definitions of the term.Gorecki wrote:[...] If you're not a Red Dwarf fan-boy 0.5/10. If you are a Red Dwarf fan-boy (like me) 3, maybe 4/10.
I thought much the same.Hajile wrote:Hell, that could have been the Red Dwarf movie, albeit a TV movie.
[EDIT]
Indeed. None of the main cast (prior to Chloë Annett) were professional actors before appearing in the series.Hajile wrote:[EDIT]I know I've harped on about it before, but I really was astonished at the performance of Craig Charles. In that final episode he nearly had me in tears. It seems it also caught the attention of the cast - In the making of broadcast afterwards, Robert Llewellyn was mentioning how impressed he was that there was actual acting in Red Dwarf.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I always thought (based on stuff I read) that the inspiration for RD was 2001, not blade runner (where were the blade runner gags in the original series!!!)piku wrote:opaopa wrote:I'm just hoping, and pleading to god that:
Spoiler: show
[/spoiler]
I just watched all 3 back-kcab and found ep 1 the funniest (in places), the only good bit in ep 2 was the
Spoiler: show
The crap explain holly's disapperance was shite (how would the ship function with no crew and no mainframe, redundant backup processors would not be enough with out a full crew! /geekmode). The get out from the series 8 cliffhanger, by having the fictional 'series 9' to explain but not explain the crews disappearance from series 8
Dave, Just let it lie now. Red dwarf should rest in peace!.
GamerTag: Peltazoid - Playing Fable 2 - Trying to Play: Gears of War
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I saved them up on my PVR and watched all 3 back-to-back last night and was pleased I did it that way. Some really GREAT moments:
I agree that no laughter track was disconcerting at first, but it's the fashion innit? These things come and go in cycles and later editions will probably add one. Episode 1 was very much an establishing phase, not many laughs and quite a lot of me getting used to them looking, well....... erm...... old. I DID actually laugh out loud at several points in episode 3 and think the whole trio or programmes (as an ensemble) was pretty well done.
Well done GrantNaylorDave.
Spoiler: show
Well done GrantNaylorDave.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
erm - me too.Hajile wrote:but I really was astonished at the performance of Craig Charles. In that final episode he nearly had me in tears.
- Hajile
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1086
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 10:10 pm 0
- Location: Exactly where you don't want me to be
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Just watched it again, and it does work far better if you see it as a whole. One thing that hasn't been commented on yet is the
Spoiler: show
"By the Celestial Spires!"
I go where the games are.
I go where the games are.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I really enjoyed it messing with my fanboy mind, given the title expecting it to resolve the issue of them getting back to earth and doing something I wasn't quite expecting (well considering my slightly drunktard state whilst watching,began to work it out at the beginning of eps. 3). I guess I'm used to cope out bad sci-fi endings from other shows. quite clearly it wasn't suppose to end there.
I felt that perhaps the creators asked themselves the question "what is red dwarf", and came to the conclusion that it was always about not answering questions and not being consistent and that really it was about the characters always being down on their luck and nothing ever going their way.
I suspect the lower the budget gets for red dwarf, the better everybody performs whilst making it, in much the same ratio as george lucas talent is related to how fat he is at any given time; was watching the "making of" and the budget must of been extremely tight as Doug mentioned having to buy a smart car from his own pocket.
I felt that perhaps the creators asked themselves the question "what is red dwarf", and came to the conclusion that it was always about not answering questions and not being consistent and that really it was about the characters always being down on their luck and nothing ever going their way.
I suspect the lower the budget gets for red dwarf, the better everybody performs whilst making it, in much the same ratio as george lucas talent is related to how fat he is at any given time; was watching the "making of" and the budget must of been extremely tight as Doug mentioned having to buy a smart car from his own pocket.
01000101 01000100 01000111 01000101
http://www.redbubble.com/people/fotofill/ buy my photos!
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Parts 2 & 3 were much better. Would have played better as a TV movie, as I said before. I'll get the DVD and wouldn't mind UKTV making a proper six-part series, but perhaps only let Naylor direct a couple of them, as his direction is somewhat lacking.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Mellers wrote:Well done GrantNaylorDave.
As previously mentioned, Rob Grant has not been involved in RD since the end of Season Six. This script was Naylor's alone.moosedude wrote:I felt that perhaps the creators asked themselves the question "what is red dwarf" [...]
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Well, I enjoyed the third episode. Not brilliant, but some good moments.
BTW, someone has added some canned laughter to a couple of scenes, here you go:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoukWv5rD4E
BTW, someone has added some canned laughter to a couple of scenes, here you go:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoukWv5rD4E
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
Fairly weak, I thought. What humour there was was OK, but there wasn't much of it. It might still have been interesting enough if it hadn't been quite so open and obviously derivative. In addition, Naylor seems to like the 'back to reality' storylines and I've always thought they were a bit naff.
Bit of a pity. I'm not calling for it to be put to rest forever, but it needs a stronger script than this.
Bit of a pity. I'm not calling for it to be put to rest forever, but it needs a stronger script than this.
Re: Red Dwarf is REALLY coming back? :O
I liked it.



