Health Care System Questions

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Fawfulhasfury
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 1:30 am 0

Health Care System Questions

Post by Fawfulhasfury »

I'm an American, and I am incredibly curious about the way health care is run in other countries, such as in Europe and around the world, not only in system, but also in relation to the U.S. system. There are many members here from all over the world. I would like to learn as much on this topic as I can from all sides and viewpoints. So please post what you know and think, definitions and complaints. :)

Thanks!
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by teamonkey »

The UK's NHS is awesome. Huge, slow, bureaucratic, and MRSA-laden, but healthcare is a right, not a privilege. In the UK, paying for private healthcare generally gets you seen faster and a comfier bed as you recover. If you fall ill, they'll usually fix you before asking if you have private insurance.

Canada's system is touted as being the model for the US to follow. While undoubtedly better than the US model, as a UK expat the notion of having to pay for an ambulance still seems barbaric. Priorities are skewed as well. I loaded up on the most expensive private healthcare I could, because it offers me roughly the same security as the NHS if I, say, break my arm, but I'm now also entitled to $200 a year of cosmetic surgery, which I feel I need to take advantage of to get my money's worth. I don't want that crap, I just want to be fixed if I'm broken.
User avatar
wanye
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3047
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 12:46 pm 0
PSN: wanye_m
Location: nottingham
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by wanye »

have you seen "sicko"?

it may be a bit biased and full of michael-moore propaganda, but its a pretty good insight into how the US compares with canada, the uk and france...

hth
---
psn: spazhammer75
http://nottsdj.co.uk - Nottinghamshire Weddings and Events DJ
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6653
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by venusian »

teamonkey wrote:I'm now also entitled to $200 a year of cosmetic surgery, which I feel I need to take advantage of
Do tell! What are you going to get done? I hear there may be some slightly used nose tips going spare.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by gilesgoat »

Italian system despite all I'd say is pretty good, it suffers from ( at least ) 2 things, quite lot of people "overusing" it and lot
of cuts from financial support.

However despite all that been said and complaint about it I would say it works really well, it can be quite fast and you can
have lot of support "for nothing" and even when we think it is slow I had to see it's still reasonably fast compared to some
waiting times I've seen in other countries.

There are some other problems as well, sometime there are so many doctors that not all of them are equally good and/or some
of them are specialised only in one thing despite claiming they are in many, you may end up in being treated for years for
something and then finally met "the right doctor" and discover that "well actually what you really needed was all else".

Often is better you go around to have a second, third and even fourth opinion before to decide what to do, also despite
"as a whole" all hospital are good some can be more good than others depending on what kind of treatment you need so you
better have to choose the right doctor and the right hospital depending on what you need.

There's another "drawback" but this is not directly connected to the health system, taxes we pay in Italy are very high, not
so high as some other countries but still can be well over 50% of your income, quite often you have to pay some "little extras"
on stuff you get.

In a way the system works better for you if you really are poor/can't afford to pay a thing, then you'll have all for free but
the moment you can pay something there will be something else to pay for.

Yet is still not too bad, it does not cost you gazillions and/or figures you can't pay and you don't need to open mortgages
or loan to get medical assistance :wink:

Can take a while anyway sometime to properly sort out the beauracracy to get it ( for free ) anyway ... but they tell me
that sometime you can get awesome experience/support from some voluntary associations.

Ah yes of course health is a constitutional right and the state has to supply it.

As a little note of facts Italy has a "super abundance" of dentists, I'd say there are as many dentists studios as Bar ( pubs ) :lol:

Some Italian people have a real "mania" for "having ultra perfect theet", many Italians as well as an "overall tendency" to
go to the doctor "as soon as they see a black spot in their face", doctors waiting rooms are normally very crowded with
lot of people that seems "they live there" :roll:

When you go to a doctor/hospital expect to loose the whole day, hospitals are getting a bit faster in "doing things quick"
yet they have loads and loads of people to deal with, last time I had some blood tests the hospital reception for that was
opening at 6.00 AM in the morning, I went there 5.40 AM .. YES 5.40 AM no mistakes .. I had 27 people already in front of me ..

The whole test took about 5 mins, it was like to be in the army .. lot of people coming in, lot of people coming out ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
bumblebee
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1693
Joined: Sat Jun 03, 2006 7:33 pm 0
Location: Snobdorf, Germany
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by bumblebee »

I find it amusing to constantly hear people in the US say that in Europe healthcare is free. It is not.

In Germany if you are employed, you pay 50% of your insurance and the employer pays the other 50% to a so-called compulsory health insurance. If you are a freelancer, like myself, you are free to choose among the public and the private insurance companies, but either way, you are obliged to be insured. Paying for the public you pay a rather high basic rate for a pretty low coverage, whereas in the private, you will get better coverage for sometimes less money (at least in my case it is 100€ less than what I was paying as a basic rate at the public insurer). The public one is based on a "solidarity principle" where everyone pays but say, families with many kids get all covered on the insurance of one parent, so it is far from fair.

Another unpleasant thing is that if you end up in hospital, often the first question you get is not what's hurting but if you have your insurance card. Meanwhile, medical staff are complaining of low salaries and running to other countries and from what I hear from a friend who works at a local hospital lab, they get foreigners who sometimes can't speak much German. Which is not to say that German doctors are doing always a good job. In fact, my dentist, for instance, is Iranian (after I went to about 5 other before her - all were German and all sucked). There is a business mentality among German doctors - not a medical one. One can excuse them with the system, but I think that there is more to it (and I speak from the position of someone who belongs to largely medical family where responsibility to patient has always come first).

So, yes, there is something that is broken here. I think the UK are doing a better job with the construct. Not sure about efficiency.
"This nail is bent and broken, straighten it out with the hands of love" — Sivert Høyem
Tumblog | Twitter
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by Dio »

According to my mate who's a consultant, the UK system offers mostly good to excellent care at, relatively, bargain prices. It is definitely not a money-no-object service. His best guess is that it will become politically unsustainable to keep it as part of the mainstream tax system at some point in the next 20 years (mostly because of the drugs bill) and the NHS will be officially hived off to a separate, formally itemised tax which the government can raise with relative impunity.

The most obvious difference to the US is that as soon as you have any kind of problem there they will send you for endless tests; there is little incentive for doctors to reduce cost and a fear of malpractice suits have they not done 'everything' (even when 'everything' is ridiculously pointless).
User avatar
Orava
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12698
Joined: Sat Mar 13, 2004 12:13 am 0
Location: The West Country

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by Orava »

Finnish system is much the same as in UK - although I would say better maintained and with more up-to-date treatments. Dentistry access although is on an another planet compared to UK.

However, it is not completely free, you pay a small fee when seeing a GP (11 euros) but this is capped at 33 euros maximum per year. Hospital stays are also not free but again capped at about 600 euros per year max.

Also prescription drugs are not free but you can claim back the cost from social services, if you think you are entitled. They might think otherwise though.

Cost-wise Finland (US$2,824) spends slightly less per capita than UK (US$3,065).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_car ... by_country
Holier than thou
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by gravy »

CLIVE:

But I'll say one thing for Russia. The health service is tremendous.

DEREK:

Oh, yeah.

CLIVE:

As soon as you're ill they kill you.

DEREK:

Yeah?

CLIVE:

Yeah. Oh, there's no fucking about with cures.
User avatar
l1n3n01z
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1777
Joined: Tue Nov 19, 2002 12:14 pm 0
Location: Iceland
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by l1n3n01z »

Iceland, this may not be 100% accurate:
If you visit a GP during office hours, you pay around 5 euro, free if for a child/handicapped/old. If you visit a specialist you pay around 40 euro per session. Around 10 for a child. The barbaric practice of charging for ambulances is here as well, around 70 euros. A trip to the emergency room will cost you 20 euro.

There is also a very strange rule that if you go to a hospital for a relatively non-invasive procedure (i.e. you don't have to stay overnight), you pay around 100 euros, but a hospital stay is free if you stay for some time :roll:

All visitation costs are capped at a total of 50 euros per year per all children of a family, and per 100 euros per year per grown up. This used to be a huge fun of keeping pink receipts about the house and go to a bureaucratic office to pick up a card, only to forget the card when you went to the doctors, and having to go to the office again to get a refund... This has now been completely computerized and automated.

Dentistry is not covered so well by the state. The state will pay what amounts to around 25% of dentistry for grown up and around 80% for kids.

Medicine follows some haphazard rules. The state will pay from 0 - 100% of medicine. If the medicine is usually used for chronic diseases, the state will usually pay a lot. If there is a cheaper alternative to a medicine, the state will usually cover most of the cost of the cheap one, but none of the costlier one. You can even get different prices on medicine depending on the use. Zyban, an antidepressant that is also used to help people quit smoking, used to priced to the max if you got it to quit smoking. But if you were using as an antidepressant, the state would pay quite a lot of it. This was ripe for abuse obviously :) There are probably more stories like this, but this is the only one I have seen the different receipts for. :lol:

There is not a cap for medicine costs, but if you pay too much due to chronic illness or whatever, you may get a grant to help offset it. More haphazardness and bureaucracy.

Also, now that Iceland is on the dole, I foresee that this little article will be obsolete within a few years :?
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by zip accident »

In the UK, unless you are very poor, there is a standard charge for prescriptions for drugs etc, it doesn't vary with the cost to the NHS of the drugs.

In NHS run services in general, if you miss an appointment you can usually be seen if you're just late on the same day (but that is as a favour and you may have to wait until the end of the queue), but if you miss the day entirely you'll usually need to make another appointment. Apparently people making and then missing appointments is a significant problem throughout the NHS.

General Practitioner's surgeries usually house several doctors per practice, and sometimes as in the one I use there will be two practices in one building. In the case of the one I use there is a semi-autonomous "treatment room" where you can go for blood tests from either practice. Your GP is the central information point for all your medical information, if you have hospital treatment, your GP should be notified about it, and if you need to go to hospital after a visit to your GP your GP will arrange that, and can issue repeat prescriptions for anything that may have been prescribed by (or in the name of) a hospital consultant. Visiting your GP on the NHS costs nothing, but you only get about ten minutes (which is probably quite adequate).

If you need a blood test, you have to make an appointment, and there's no point turning up early. In my experience it's unusual for them to be running more 10 minutes late, they are frequently on time.

The medical system is somewhat separated from dentists and opticians, dentists practices will usually house several dentists, Opticians are often quite plush and it's often not clear how many opticians work in a practice. There will be charges if you have NHS work done at dentists or opticians unless you are very poor.

As others have said, you can attend Doctors, dentists and opticians as a private patient, which will cost you more than NHS charges, I think most people see their Doctors on the NHS, but there was a situation where NHS dentistry was in short supply, there wasn't a problem with opticians.

Dentists you should see for an inspection every six months, after fifteen months of non-attendance a dental practice is entitled to drop a patient from it's NHS clientelle list, that doesn't happen with doctors, and I believe you don't have to register with an optician, so that doesn't apply. You can have one (free?) NHS eye test every two years, there are adverts of cheap (private?) eye tests in some opticians windows.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
evilpaul
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 811
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 2:01 pm 0
Location: #ukscene, helsinki branch
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by evilpaul »

zip accident wrote:In the UK...
Scotland is different - cheaper perscriptions and free eye tests. Isn't Wales different again? And probably Northern Ireland too?

It's also worth pointing out that levels of care and service are *vastly* different across the UK. I've recently moved down from Dundee to Essex and I know where I'd rather be treated ;(
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by zip accident »

evilpaul wrote:
zip accident wrote:In the UK...
Scotland is different - cheaper perscriptions and free eye tests. Isn't Wales different again? And probably Northern Ireland too?

It's also worth pointing out that levels of care and service are *vastly* different across the UK. I've recently moved down from Dundee to Essex and I know where I'd rather be treated ;(
That may all be true.

I suspect there are local variations within the countries, as well as between them.

I tend to find the sort of people who claim to be English as opposed to British to be twits of the highest order, which is why I don't tend to do that even when it is correct.

Essex is probably almost London prices though, the rest of the country may be better.

I think dentistry has improved, there was apparently a time they weren't taking on any new NHS patients, since I went regularly I didn't have a problem.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by gilesgoat »

I forgot to say that dentists in Italy are almost ONLY private studious, there are NHS ones as well and I heard they are
even good but you have to wait a really long time for those.

On the other side you want a dentist you just have so many you can pick up there are dentists everywhere you don't need
to be registered/etc. anything you just go to one and you get an appointment within the next few days, they don't cost
you "super millions" and they are all very well in business.

Opticians .. plenty around .. the NHS ones are really good as well, I can't speak "for all of Italy" because I really don't know
the situation as a whole but speaking about where I live I have to say they seems to do quite well, waiting lists are not
very bad and quality of service from what I can see ( ah ha, irony ) seems quite good to me.

How it normally works in Italy the procedure is : you have something you go to your own doctor first, if the doctor thinks
"you need more tests" it will give you a paper to go and book some tests in the hospital, you go in the hospital reception with
those papers you book for the appointment, unless you are "super poor" there always is some extra fee to pay on depending
on what kind of stuff you need ( normally in the range 20 .. 50 eur ).

You pay that, the day of your appointment you go there, they do the thing, end.

If you really want you can get tests for "anything", you pay and you do the tests, there's a price list for every test.

Emergency situations : .. you run to the ER .. you wait a fuck load of time while they are super busy with lots of other
people there and finally - hopefully before you'll die :roll: :twisted: - you'll be rushed in and someone will take care of you
mind you it's NOT uncommon you could spend even 10 hours waiting ... in pain .. if you are around July - June - August there
prepare to PRAY A LOT becuase "all the universe will be there" ..

They only thing they ask you is if you have a document and you NHS card ( thing that if you are going to go in a hospital
and/or whatever you MUST carry with you ), HOWEVER, if you enter the ER NO ONE can deny you emergency and/or
refuse you treatment no matter what card or not or citizenship you have, you can be EU or extra EU if you are in an
emergency they get you in.

*BUT* .. the doctors have the right to state/judge "if this is really an emergency or not" .. cause far too much "bad
customers" today I think you can even be FINED if you actually go to an ER for NOT an emergency situation.

You would not believe how many people were going to ER "anytime" maybe just to get some cough drops because they
were not arsed to find a pharmacy that was open ( and making doctors waste lot of time ) ... :?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Health Care System Questions

Post by gravy »

evilpaul wrote:
zip accident wrote:In the UK...
Scotland is different - cheaper perscriptions and free eye tests. Isn't Wales different again? And probably Northern Ireland too?

It's also worth pointing out that levels of care and service are *vastly* different across the UK. I've recently moved down from Dundee to Essex and I know where I'd rather be treated ;(
Dundee's Ninewells is excellent but then again that's probably because it's a big teaching hospital. St Marys in Southampton is another teaching hospital and to be honest my experience of them was equally fantastic.

There are some right shitholes too :D
Post Reply