The Captain wrote:Gorecki wrote: Matt Smith doesn't seem to do 'angry' quite as well as as two previous Doctors.
I have to disagree. I thought the Space Giraffe was very convincing here, trying to keep his cool when he was being railroaded by his own morality until, hectored, he snapped. He certainly seemed far, far more alien than his predecessor, and whilst different to Eccles I think Smith's more shambolic-until-provoked approach is a winner. I haven't seen a moment of Matt Smith thus far where he seems to be anything other than utterly convincing. So much so that I stop thinking 'Matt Smith's great' and just think 'that's the Doctor'. It isn't really an issue for me.
The problem for me was that it seemed like very much like a line that could have been written for one of the past two Doctors and would have suited them better. Eccleston in particular would have had that line
dripping with disgust. It's only a minor observation though. It's to be expected that the script writers are going to be writing (and the audience watching) with the previous Doctor still fresh in their memory and with no clear idea as to what the new Doctor is going to be like.
The second series will be the one where everyone knows who he is and can write/direct to his mannerisms (of which there are many already, my favourite being the way he has a tendency to get far too close to Amy whilst speaking to her, eyes flicking back and forth as if he's trying to read a piece of information at the back of her brain).
Also, I notice how Moffat has introduced a blatant Scottish agenda. Now I have no problem with Scottish people, some of best friends are Scottish, and if anyone wants to be Scottish behind closed doors in the privacy of their own home then that's fine by me. But please, stop trying to shove it down our throats every five minutes. This a family show after all.