The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
The Captain
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1672
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 12:24 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Barbellion
PSN: Barbellion
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by The Captain »

Noticed a problem with the Scottish thing -
Spoiler: show
whilst Amy's line about the Scottish demanding their own ship was funny, what about the UK needing a Space Whale? It isn't towing or pushing another ship, so did the Scots just have better technology? Or perhaps they are being towed by the Skarasen/Loch Ness Monster?
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.

Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
User avatar
Flabio
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8717
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2004 12:37 pm 0
Location: Guildford

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Flabio »

Spoiler: show
She never said that they *got* their own ship, maybe they were left behind?
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

The Scots do have a history of being great engineers.
Dungeon-Dave wrote:… (the oscilloscope in the first ep suggests the Doc is aware of it) …
I do not think that oscilloscope existed in the previous control room.
Cloudane wrote:As for why he constantly manages to find trouble (improbability levels through the roof), I'm sure this must've been explained in an episode some time in the past run of its existence? I'm thinking the TARDIS is probably attracted to it like a magnet somehow.
My theory is that the TARDIS is attuned to the Doctor's desires, finding him adventures when he subconsciously needs them.
juice wrote:I enjoyed that episode, but... it does carry on a slightly worrying trend in Moffat's work: a very heavy focus on having a monster-of-the-week. …
Have there been any DW episodes at all this century without a MotW?
juice wrote:
Spoiler: show
… Equally, what was the point of the polling system - other than to kill off the people with a conscience?
Spoiler: show
The point would seem to be that the project would end once 1% of the adult population had chosen that option. Obviously, those protesters could not be permitted to remind others of what they had chosen to forget.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by KlaxonCow »

The rest of the world fucked off into space, but the English were left behind?

There's only one explanation. The Scots - who invent most things - must have invented the "star drives" that got everyone else off the planet.

But, oh look, we seem to have completely run out of "star drives" by the time the English want one. Oh, well, never mind. Shit happens. We'll be off now. Goodbye!

"Revenge is a dish best served cold"
- Klingon proverb
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Harlequin wrote:
juice wrote:I enjoyed that episode, but... it does carry on a slightly worrying trend in Moffat's work: a very heavy focus on having a monster-of-the-week. …
Have there been any DW episodes at all this century without a MotW?
I probably could have stated that better! Essentially, it feels like there's something of a template - the monsters tend towards being artificial and/or masked: looking at Moffat's episodes, we've had the gas-masks, the clockwork androids, the statues, the spacesuits (and the info nodes) and now the Smilers. The only episode which doesn't really fit this pattern is The Eleventh Hour and Prisoner Zero - and even then, the constructs PZ put together were clearly artificial.

To be fair, focusing on a single, clearly recognisable bad guy makes perfect sense in many ways, both in terms of the self-contained-episodes format and the family-entertainment ambition. I just don't want to see Dr Who going down the same "templatised" route as has happened for a lot of US TV shows.
Harlequin wrote:
juice wrote:
Spoiler: show
… Equally, what was the point of the polling system - other than to kill off the people with a conscience?
Spoiler: show
The point would seem to be that the project would end once 1% of the adult population had chosen that option. Obviously, those protesters could not be permitted to remind others of what they had chosen to forget.
Spoiler: show
I know that's what the film stated, but the scenario still didn't seem that logical:
1) Having already captured the whale, built a spaceship around it, loaded the country's population onto it and then tortured it into moving, the government then gets a guilty conscience?
2) 1% of the population deciding "no" is enough to condemn the remaining 99% to death?
3) Killing dissenters seems pointless: you could still record their vote and wipe their memory
4) Performing "ethical" cleansing means that the "no" population would naturally shrink, as the dead people wouldn't pass their ethics onto their children - and in the mean time, I assume that the general population would be growing
5) Also, did no-one ever notice that people tend to vanish after voting? Surely that'd introduce a bit of bias into the voting!

Overall, the voting was either completely pointless or a tool for the government to help control the population: I can't see any way in which it could be viewed as a legitimate ballot. So, given that this was a lynchpin of the plot, it made everything else weaker as a result.

There was also the whole police-state plot-thread, which was waved away by the end of the episode, despite the fact that the goverment freely admitted to executing both dissidents and underperformers - including children.

Overall, I'm sticking with my assessment that the backplot felt very much contrived!
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
Sir_LANs-a-lot
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12143
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
Location: Here

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Sir_LANs-a-lot »

KlaxonCow wrote: "Revenge is a dish best served cold"
- Klingon proverb

I think they're confusing "revenge" with "ice cream".
[Sir_LANs-a-lot]

Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

I am still waiting for Moffat to properly kill somebody onscreen. We have heard of deaths this season but we still have yet to see any. Compare to RTD, whose stories rarely ran for more than fifteen minutes before the bodies started to pile up.

I think we can forgive SM a little less detail in his mid-season single episodes as he now has to deal with producing the show, re-writingediting the other writers' scripts and dealing with his own Sherlock series.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

juice wrote:
Spoiler: show
1) Having already captured the whale, built a spaceship around it, loaded the country's population onto it and then tortured it into moving, the government then gets a guilty conscience?
2) 1% of the population deciding "no" is enough to condemn the remaining 99% to death?
3) Killing dissenters seems pointless: you could still record their vote and wipe their memory
4) Performing "ethical" cleansing means that the "no" population would naturally shrink, as the dead people wouldn't pass their ethics onto their children - and in the mean time, I assume that the general population would be growing
5) Also, did no-one ever notice that people tend to vanish after voting? Surely that'd introduce a bit of bias into the voting!

Overall, the voting was either completely pointless or a tool for the government to help control the population: I can't see any way in which it could be viewed as a legitimate ballot. So, given that this was a lynchpin of the plot, it made everything else weaker as a result.

There was also the whole police-state plot-thread, which was waved away by the end of the episode, despite the fact that the goverment freely admitted to executing both dissidents and underperformers - including children.

Overall, I'm sticking with my assessment that the backplot felt very much contrived!
Spoiler: show
It may not seem obvious, but if the government formed the ship on what was the suffering of an intelligent creature, then an ethical government will attempt to make it an informed choice. Like the Iraq War was supposed to be, or entering Europe. If the population as a whole agree, then they only have themselves to blame for what the government do in their name. But there is also the issue of that information getting out and promoting armed revolt. So you contain dissent by dealing with it before it becomes dangerous..or..for the well-being of society you remove the information so people can carry on without guilt to what they've done. I mean, how many Iraqis died thanks to my personal part implicitly endorsing of government involvement in the Iraq War? I didn't exactly go off to parliament and deal with the people who voted. And I mean, the people re-elected the same government afterwards, so it clearly wasn't much of an election issue!

What they did in Saturday's episode is not too dissimilar to actual government policy - although simplified for kids clearly ;)

OK, we don't feed dissenters to animals, but if you go over a certain line to defend your beliefs then you pay the price depending on the circumstances. In peacetime, you might wind up getting fined. In war you might wind up being imprisoned or executed. In an environment where resources are limited and the environment is finely balanced..one might be less tolerant of 'parasites' who consume without producing so if everyone did that, society would break down. It might be very important to stop the rot before it happens.

It might seem contrived because we haven't been living in an environment where maintaining balance and the cycle of activity is dependent on continuing humanity and individual assent to the policy used by the government. If the Iraq War was a massive fib and people found out, then the worst that would happen is that the government would be replaced because it doesn't affect the UK as an environment. But in the Star Whale case,knowing that information would destroy society. So you're a bit stuck with workable options there..so a cover up is the only option basically.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

Maybe I miss-read it, but I thought the voteing system was actualy...
Spoiler: show
People knew they would die if they voted no. They got the whole story.
It was simply so that anyone voting against it would be willing to sacrifice themselves. To put the choice in stark clarity to them.
I probably could have stated that better! Essentially, it feels like there's something of a template - the monsters tend towards being artificial and/or masked: looking at Moffat's episodes, we've had the gas-masks, the clockwork androids, the statues, the spacesuits (and the info nodes) and now the Smilers.
True. But also Cyberman, Daleks would fit that description too, and probably a large amount of Who cannon in general.
You could even say the Slavine fall into that category, seeing as your counting the Spacesuits.
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

[quote="Darkflame"]Maybe I miss-read it, but I thought the voteing system was actualy...
Spoiler: show
People knew they would die if they voted no. They got the whole story.
It was simply so that anyone voting against it would be willing to sacrifice themselves. To put the choice in stark clarity to them.
Spoiler: show
They don't know what will happen to them once they've made the choice. But people disappear suddenly and the recordings of their reactions are enough to stop them asking questions about what they've chosen to forget. All they know for certain is that they chose to forget, but not why.. When the protest button was pressed, then the voting booth is sealed before the floor opens so no-one sees that option.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Darkflame wrote:
I probably could have stated that better! Essentially, it feels like there's something of a template - the monsters tend towards being artificial and/or masked: looking at Moffat's episodes, we've had the gas-masks, the clockwork androids, the statues, the spacesuits (and the info nodes) and now the Smilers.
True. But also Cyberman, Daleks would fit that description too, and probably a large amount of Who cannon in general.
You could even say the Slavine fall into that category, seeing as your counting the Spacesuits.
True to a degree - I deliberately left the Daleks and Cybermen out because they weren't Moffat's creations. Also, they don't quite fall into my "MOTW" template because there's more depth to their characters and background story. Then too, they also tend to talk more: Moffat's monsters tend to be more from the "silent and implacable" mold with a minimal (or no) line in conversation.

Anyhoo: time will tell if the MOTW pattern actually exists...
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
Alarm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 9046
Joined: Sat May 21, 2005 10:45 pm 0
Location: Welsh Wales
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Alarm »

Cloudane wrote:That grey haired bloke in the ep was the headmaster wasn't he? Or am I thinking of someone else? He always has that evil look about him.
I can't remember, but I've seen him portray "baddies" before and he's very good at it. :)
User avatar
Alarm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 9046
Joined: Sat May 21, 2005 10:45 pm 0
Location: Welsh Wales
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Alarm »

That wasn't a bad episode, I thought.
Spoiler: show
Looking forward to next week's episode, but how can the Doctor not know that (presumably) the Daleks "helped" us to win he war?
Edited to put a miniscule spoiler (what you see in the "next week" trailer about the next episode) for those who haven't watched the current ep.
Last edited by Alarm on Mon Apr 12, 2010 11:39 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

Cloudane wrote:That grey haired bloke in the ep was the headmaster wasn't he? Or am I thinking of someone else? He always has that evil look about him.
As in demon, yes.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

arron wrote:
Darkflame wrote:Maybe I miss-read it, but I thought the voteing system was actualy...
Spoiler: show
People knew they would die if they voted no. They got the whole story.
It was simply so that anyone voting against it would be willing to sacrifice themselves. To put the choice in stark clarity to them.
Spoiler: show
They don't know what will happen to them once they've made the choice. But people disappear suddenly and the recordings of their reactions are enough to stop them asking questions about what they've chosen to forget. All they know for certain is that they chose to forget, but not why.. When the protest button was pressed, then the voting booth is sealed before the floor opens so no-one sees that option.
Spoiler: show
Are you sure they didn't know? I cant remember anything that makes that for sure.
Post Reply