Harlequin wrote:Darkflame wrote:He prefers Red Dwarf.
I remember once reading/hearing him mention about it having better sci-fi ideas then Who.
Other than the ones that it 'borrowed' from Star Trek.
I dont think Red Dwarf borrowed much, if anything at all, from star trek.
No warp, no transports or replicators anyway.
Anything Red Dwarf and Trek have in common are probably far older sci-fi ideas and troupes.
Mind you, I have never described DW as SF either. It has for the most part always been Sci-Fi: fantasy with SF trappings.
Well, sci-fi-ness is a scale rather then a yes/no state anyway.
The more scientific explanation something has (in universe) the more Sci-Fi it is. The more it just shows stuff and expects us to accept it without explanation, the more its fantasy.