It's all horses for courses: a doctor will point and laugh at House; a police officer will bang his head while watching CSI; soldiers will cry when watching the FUBAR tactics in films like Starship Troopers. Tekkies pick apart the details of science fictionDungeon-Dave wrote: I've seen many let rip into films/series in Architecture for a good idea ruined by poor presentation or shaky fact.I'm probably using science to mean "fact" rather than physics/chemistry/etc - I ranted against apparent lack of safety standards in "Flashforward" on the grounds that fact hasn't just been tweaked but actively violated to suit the story.Harlequin wrote:Personally, I am quite content to accept that DW has never been any more about the science than Star Wars, Mary Poppins or Dangermouse.
I'm sure I'm not the only one that thought "is the Doctor in danger of being bitten or hissed to death by these girls? What are they waiting for?"
Personally, I've deliberately tried to tone down my analysis of DW over the last few - mostly because there's far better things to do with life than spend it analysing prime-time TV fiction
(and also, to be fair to Moffat: the general quality/internal consistency of the new series is better than in the RTD era)
For instance, I'm (mostly) willing to accept the fact that the sonic screwdriver is now an all-encompassing magic wand, given that DW has now generally switched to single-episode stories and the writers need to keep the plot moving along. I'm willing to accept Spitfires flying in space, given that it was so gloriously silly and there was enough setup in the script to make it a part of the plot rather than a deus ex machina. And so on.
However, this episode failed on two counts:








