That's how I'm seeing it really. It's exactly how Smith is coming across to me as well. I don't think he's bad at all, just not amazingly good. I'm sure his acting skill is probably great (can't tell really, not an expert!) and he really shines when he gets serious. But the bumbling and hyperactivity are overdone IMO.. now I know he's the Doctor and needs that element to him but I think Smith overdoes all the speed-talking and bouncing around. As you say he doesn't seem to have the same "charm" to go with it. YMMV - I really liked David Tennant once he'd settled into the role (he was also a bit too speed-talky and bounce-aroundy at first, maybe it's a regeneration side effect?) and liking Tennant seems to be a bit of a minority view on here.Dio wrote:Dunno chaps. I'm finding this series really rather average so far. The pacing of all the episodes has been well off; every 1-parter has been rushed, the 2-parter had too much blah.
The biggest problem for me is that Smith's 'very alien' portrayal is a great acting performance, but I'm not finding it likeable or charming enough; I think that's supposed to be done with the bumbling, but it makes me want to cringe rather than smile.
It's pretty much all at least OK, and there hasn't been much bad, but not much great yet either.
And I hate to say it but I still can't quite see past the massive wall of "student / graduate". He doesn't "feel" 900 years old to me, which as we know is nothing to do with appearance or energy so it's tough to say what exactly it is. Best one that way was Eccleston.
Maybe it's the fidgety thing he does with his hands and the proper pronunciation of 't's etc (very Oxfordy?). They have a strong 'student vibe' to me. Dunno, but it's still early days yet. He's not bad, put it that way.
(Inevitably someone will come down on me like a ton of bricks with "students are nothing like that" but I can't help getting that vibe from it and it's not because people were previously saying he was too young).
Moffat has built up huge expectations from what he did previously and I think disappointment was inevitable as nobody (or at least very very few) can keep up that level of awesomeness when it's done on a constant production basis rather than the one-offs he wrote before. He also recycles a bit more than I'd like. However I think we might see him shine with continuity and interwoven story threads like River or the cracks, which are a pretty clever and memorable idea and it'll be interesting to see where it all leads. I also get the feeling we'll see reference to things said and done in early episodes later on and if so that's where some writing genius might start to show. And of course he definitely shines in terrorising kids, who will now be terrified of wall cracks and stone statues
But don't get me wrong, I find his writing FAR better than RTD's.
Amy is really nice to look at
Overall it's very early days still but I'd agree that the best word for it so far is "average".
And it needs less of this straight scottish agenda











