When it does breach it.disciple wrote:...at what point do you stop a vehicle unlikely to stop that's heading towards a blockade with clear intention to breach?
Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
There are reasons why separate laws are drafted for doing things, intending to do things and conspiring to do things.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
You're lucky I'm in a good mood. I'm saying that most of the 'discussion' here is un-informed anti-Israeli biased bollocks, the un-informed part stops me from accusing anyone of anti-semitism.betamax wrote:Are you really accusing people of anti-semitism behind your hand there? At least have the bollocks to come out and say it plainly.Duck Turkin wrote: The reflexive anti-Israeli postings in this forum aren't fair, and smacks of something far worse.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
The legality of the boarding is arguable.
In that a shed load of maritime law experts are arguing about it right now.
Legality aside though it's hard to see this operation or the assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh as anything but ill conceived and incompetent.
Which isn't an anti-semetic or anti-Israeli point of view in the same thinking the French were fuckwits for blowing up The Rainbow Warrior isn't anti-gaul
In that a shed load of maritime law experts are arguing about it right now.
Legality aside though it's hard to see this operation or the assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh as anything but ill conceived and incompetent.
Which isn't an anti-semetic or anti-Israeli point of view in the same thinking the French were fuckwits for blowing up The Rainbow Warrior isn't anti-gaul
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
ITYM "boatload"gravy wrote: In that a shed load of maritime law experts are arguing about it right now.l
Strongly agree. I think the images they're currently creating are a much larger national security threat than the ones they've been ostensibly been addressing.gravy wrote: Legality aside though it's hard to see this operation or the assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh as anything but ill conceived and incompetent.
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I think you are reading that wrong. The law says that if a ship intends to breach a blockade, which this certainly did since that was their purpose, then the ship can be boarded after being warned (which they repeatedly were). What happened after was a total fuck up, no question about it. The soldiers fired upon people who attacked them, which does admittedly contravene the proportionate part, but since a couple of guns were stolen from the IDF soldiers then it renders that point murky too.Harlequin wrote:I note that intent (known or suspected) to breach a blockade is not sufficient grounds for stopping, for boarding or, indeed, for massacring.The Beeb wrote:The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
The charter allows for naval blockades, but the effect of the blockade on civilians must be proportionate to the effect on the military element for the blockade to be legally enforceable.
A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I think we can agree on that.gravy wrote:Legality aside though it's hard to see this operation or the assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh as anything but ill conceived and incompetent.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Well if you want people to get informed a good step would be to suggest this book by Joe Sacco.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestine_(comics)
Available quite widely if people would only look (it's also on pirate bay, but I do suggest buying a dead-tree copy once you've read it). Oddly, I was rereading this the other week (I'd been reading the section about Palestine in Micheal Hodges enjoyably interesting AK47: The story of the People's gun just before that).
Palestine have acted fucking retarded for a long time and Israel are surrounded by potential enemies so it's little surprise that they are so militant. The thing is, though, Palestinian life is so fucking harsh that it's no surprise they have such anger inside them. They are forced to live in bombed out places they can't rebuild. They have seen their homes destroyed, their livelihood uprooted a left to rot. They have been imprisoned without rhyme or reason. They are endlessly hounded. They are kicked out of everywhere they go to escape their fate. They will fight until they start winning or every one of them dies.
Israel meanwhile is a fairly modern country, with creature comforts like walls and beds along with basics like TVs, internet, specialised military equipment and (for Jews) freedom of speech.
It'd be kinda hard to see Israel as anything other than aggressive, regardless of the atrocities done by Palestine.
BTW, list of what is stated as legal to bring across the border.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/p ... mports.pdf
Here's a pic of what Israel claim to have confiscated from the craft. Note the scarf and flag, as if to prove that these were terrorist sympathisers hell bent on giving Hamas the means to DESTROY Israel. Why would the aid ships be carrying a politically sensitive flag somewhere it could be seen (and taken) even if they were carrying weapons? Who's that stupid? Note that most items are tools of some kind or another, even the knives (as opposed to combat weapons).

That said, the defenders were pretty brutal. That could be pack mentality, fearing death and not wanting to go down without a fight, or just anger at the sheer audacity of the boarding action (which is a hostile action or 'attack', BTW).
Not convinced they were using paintball guns. It's hard to kill somebody with a paintball gun (but not impossible) and there's no clear shot to identify weapons by. Get me a nice profile shot of an IDF weapon and I might be able to confirm or refute.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestine_(comics)
Available quite widely if people would only look (it's also on pirate bay, but I do suggest buying a dead-tree copy once you've read it). Oddly, I was rereading this the other week (I'd been reading the section about Palestine in Micheal Hodges enjoyably interesting AK47: The story of the People's gun just before that).
Palestine have acted fucking retarded for a long time and Israel are surrounded by potential enemies so it's little surprise that they are so militant. The thing is, though, Palestinian life is so fucking harsh that it's no surprise they have such anger inside them. They are forced to live in bombed out places they can't rebuild. They have seen their homes destroyed, their livelihood uprooted a left to rot. They have been imprisoned without rhyme or reason. They are endlessly hounded. They are kicked out of everywhere they go to escape their fate. They will fight until they start winning or every one of them dies.
Israel meanwhile is a fairly modern country, with creature comforts like walls and beds along with basics like TVs, internet, specialised military equipment and (for Jews) freedom of speech.
It'd be kinda hard to see Israel as anything other than aggressive, regardless of the atrocities done by Palestine.
BTW, list of what is stated as legal to bring across the border.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/p ... mports.pdf
Here's a pic of what Israel claim to have confiscated from the craft. Note the scarf and flag, as if to prove that these were terrorist sympathisers hell bent on giving Hamas the means to DESTROY Israel. Why would the aid ships be carrying a politically sensitive flag somewhere it could be seen (and taken) even if they were carrying weapons? Who's that stupid? Note that most items are tools of some kind or another, even the knives (as opposed to combat weapons).

That said, the defenders were pretty brutal. That could be pack mentality, fearing death and not wanting to go down without a fight, or just anger at the sheer audacity of the boarding action (which is a hostile action or 'attack', BTW).
Not convinced they were using paintball guns. It's hard to kill somebody with a paintball gun (but not impossible) and there's no clear shot to identify weapons by. Get me a nice profile shot of an IDF weapon and I might be able to confirm or refute.
- betamax
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10520
- Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
- Location: Coalition Anxiety
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Were the CD's full of pirated games and movies?
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
And this one's somewhat vague in that respect. Choosing between boarding at 4:30am and doing it at 9am when resistance is going to be that much higher is a no-brainer as far as getting the job done as efficiently as possible is concerned.Harlequin wrote:There are reasons why separate laws are drafted for doing things, intending to do things and conspiring to do things.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Yes, and killing babies is an easier way to solve over-population than educating people about contraception and responsible procreation. What's you point?disciple wrote:And this one's somewhat vague in that respect. Choosing between boarding at 4:30am and doing it at 9am when resistance is going to be that much higher is a no-brainer as far as getting the job done as efficiently as possible is concerned.Harlequin wrote:There are reasons why separate laws are drafted for doing things, intending to do things and conspiring to do things.
When they broke the blockade, it would've been legal to board. They didn't so it wasn't.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Can't remember where, but I read that it's claimed they were carrying paintball guns plus a handgun which was only to be used in an emergency. You can see what looks like, to my untrained eye, a paintball gun at 0:52 in that black and white video on the previous page. Fuck knows why a paintball gun, is that normal? Plausible deniability maybe? Regardless, if I were taking a beating like that I think I'd be pulling out gun if I had one.Spoongod wrote:Not convinced they were using paintball guns. It's hard to kill somebody with a paintball gun (but not impossible) and there's no clear shot to identify weapons by. Get me a nice profile shot of an IDF weapon and I might be able to confirm or refute.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I have condemned the British Government for many actions, most recently for activities in Afghanistan and Iraq. I do not think that makes me anti-UK nor indicates any dislike of the vast majority of British people.
(Which reminds me that I should book a seat to see a local performance of The Importance of Being Earnest by the company that we're touring with in August).
I think that you are reading it wrong as I see no reference to intent to breach as opposed to the act of breaching. In international waters I read that a vessel may be boarded only if it is suspected to be transporting weapons. As gravy wrote above, however, these questions are currently being debated by people who know far more about these laws than you or I.Duck Turkin wrote:I think you are reading that wrong. The law says that if a ship intends to breach a blockade, which this certainly did since that was their purpose, then the ship can be boarded after being warned (which they repeatedly were).…Harlequin wrote:I note that intent (known or suspected) to breach a blockade is not sufficient grounds for stopping, for boarding or, indeed, for massacring.The Beeb wrote:The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
The charter allows for naval blockades, but the effect of the blockade on civilians must be proportionate to the effect on the military element for the blockade to be legally enforceable.
A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
For one world-class elite trooper to lose his weapon a few minutes into an active mission may be regarded as a misfortune; for two to do so looks like carelessness.Duck Turkin wrote:… but since a couple of guns were stolen from the IDF soldiers then it renders that point murky too.
(Which reminds me that I should book a seat to see a local performance of The Importance of Being Earnest by the company that we're touring with in August).
To act legally or to act illegally. Is that a question?disciple wrote:And this one's somewhat vague in that respect. Choosing between boarding at 4:30am and doing it at 9am when resistance is going to be that much higher is a no-brainer as far as getting the job done as efficiently as possible is concerned.Harlequin wrote:There are reasons why separate laws are drafted for doing things, intending to do things and conspiring to do things.
I never knew that paintballs could cause so many fatalities.disciple wrote:Can't remember where, but I read that it's claimed they were carrying paintball guns plus a handgun which was only to be used in an emergency.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Killing babies vs contraception? They were going to board the ship either way, everything would have been hunky dory had they waited a few hours right? Well no, shit hitting the fan aside, it would have been a lot worse due to having to deal with a ship full of prepared protesters.Spoongod wrote:Yes, and killing babies is an easier way to solve over-population than educating people about contraception and responsible procreation. What's you point?disciple wrote:And this one's somewhat vague in that respect. Choosing between boarding at 4:30am and doing it at 9am when resistance is going to be that much higher is a no-brainer as far as getting the job done as efficiently as possible is concerned.Harlequin wrote:There are reasons why separate laws are drafted for doing things, intending to do things and conspiring to do things.
When they broke the blockade, it would've been legal to board. They didn't so it wasn't.
My point? As I keep saying, is that there's room for interpretation. It isn't as black and white as you're making out.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Not making out it is black an white, only that the law is. Supposedly it's not legal to board a craft outside the waters you control. That happened. It's illegal.
Everything else is irrelevant. The fighting, the angles both sides are putting on it all, all bullshit. A nation broke the law and will probably get more-or-less away with it. If the craft had broken the blockade, then they would've be acting illegally too (aren't they docked and unloading now anyway?
Now, if you want to get on to the related-but-separate topic of how I feel about Israel that's fine. Do you?
Everything else is irrelevant. The fighting, the angles both sides are putting on it all, all bullshit. A nation broke the law and will probably get more-or-less away with it. If the craft had broken the blockade, then they would've be acting illegally too (aren't they docked and unloading now anyway?
Now, if you want to get on to the related-but-separate topic of how I feel about Israel that's fine. Do you?