The great thing about international law is you can usually find someone to make a case for whatever it is you did: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/co ... id=topnews (see also Iraq War)Spoongod wrote:Not making out it is black an white, only that the law is. Supposedly it's not legal to board a craft outside the waters you control. That happened. It's illegal.
Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
This is what makes me think you are reading it wrong. The words "trying to breach" are a conditional, therefore the ship has as a goal the act of breaching the blockade, hence proportionate force is sanctioned.Harlequin wrote:The Beeb wrote: A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
- betamax
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10520
- Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
- Location: Coalition Anxiety
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I'm kind of hoping this thread gets boarded and scuttled now. 
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
The act of attempting to do something is very distinct from just intending to do so at a later time. Attempted murder, for example, is quite different to intent to murder. In any case, according to the above, boarding in international waters is still illegal without the suspicion of weapons transportation.Duck Turkin wrote:This is what makes me think you are reading it wrong. The words "trying to breach" are a conditional, therefore the ship has as a goal the act of breaching the blockade, hence proportionate force is sanctioned.Harlequin wrote:The Beeb wrote: A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
BTW, do you not think it odd how those guns could be stolen?
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Hmm, well, pretty much anyone sane was against the Iraq war. I'm noting that most of the condoning is coming from either the US or Israel itself. The US have a special relationship with Israel and let's not forget that a great many American Jews who visit Israel decide (and are legally obliged) to stay. The real story of Palestine's plight is not widely spread amongst the Israeli public, even many of those who sympathise don't have a real idea of what it's like.aureole wrote:The great thing about international law is you can usually find someone to make a case for whatever it is you did: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/co ... id=topnews (see also Iraq War)Spoongod wrote:Not making out it is black an white, only that the law is. Supposedly it's not legal to board a craft outside the waters you control. That happened. It's illegal.
I'm not sure the Turkish Foreign Minister will get much help from NATO. It's a pity, because somebody should be fighting in the Palestinian corner for once. Israel could come up with simple defences to neutralize the kind of outdated tech Palestinians have (RPGs, home made devices) from being fired into their settlements without ever having to continue oppressing a people they've left practically homeless in what was their own country. Both need external support and to actually keep their fingers off the trigger even when a handful of angry, desperate individuals attack in the name of their country. The cycle must end, and Israel are big and powerful enough to realise they have a big enough penis now and can stop slapping everyone around the fucking face with it any time they strive to be treated like humans.
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
If I'm trying to murder you, you'll want to stop me before I succeed. Your second contention is unfounded as boarding in international waters is not necessarily illegal.Harlequin wrote:The act of attempting to do something is very distinct from just intending to do so at a later time. Attempted murder, for example, is quite different to intent to murder. In any case, according to the above, boarding in international waters is still illegal without the suspicion of weapons transportation.
It underlines the incompetence of the operation in my opinion.Harlequin wrote:BTW, do you not think it odd how those guns could be stolen?
-
llamaprotector
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 648
- Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2010 2:00 am 0
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
It was an act of terror on a boat load of civilians. Simple as that. Me being intelligent enough to push away any legality bullshit does not make me a 'Jew Hater' at all. They were in international waters, and as such the country committing the crime needs to be punished accordingly.
There is another boat destined for the blockade in a few days time too, so is it OK if more innocent civilians are killed again? Since when is protesting an unjust and illegal blockade cause for killing other civilians?
End of the day some gung-ho Jewish soldiers killed some unarmed civilians, don't pollute the thread trying to turn this into some discussion of retro steampunk Minority Report bollocks about intent/actual crime. Until any crime was committed they should have stayed the on their Israeli boats rather than trying to provoke international incidents possibly leading to WW3 TYVM.
I for one do not wish to see a bomb going off and killing my children here because the government I voted for was just on BBC News 24 talking about HAMAS rather than giving a stern one-sided ultimatum to the Israeli government, or America appeasing Israel again and again for that matter. A line must be drawn in the sand after the line drawn in international waters was crossed.
And that's why I am angry, I hate any country who's actions bring us closer to the next world war, has nothing to do with the validity of my grandfather giving his life in WW2 in an effort to end the holocaust. The lives of my family are more important than some idiot 1000s of miles away getting some target practice in via civilian body bags, be it past, present or future. Simple as that.
There is another boat destined for the blockade in a few days time too, so is it OK if more innocent civilians are killed again? Since when is protesting an unjust and illegal blockade cause for killing other civilians?
End of the day some gung-ho Jewish soldiers killed some unarmed civilians, don't pollute the thread trying to turn this into some discussion of retro steampunk Minority Report bollocks about intent/actual crime. Until any crime was committed they should have stayed the on their Israeli boats rather than trying to provoke international incidents possibly leading to WW3 TYVM.
I for one do not wish to see a bomb going off and killing my children here because the government I voted for was just on BBC News 24 talking about HAMAS rather than giving a stern one-sided ultimatum to the Israeli government, or America appeasing Israel again and again for that matter. A line must be drawn in the sand after the line drawn in international waters was crossed.
And that's why I am angry, I hate any country who's actions bring us closer to the next world war, has nothing to do with the validity of my grandfather giving his life in WW2 in an effort to end the holocaust. The lives of my family are more important than some idiot 1000s of miles away getting some target practice in via civilian body bags, be it past, present or future. Simple as that.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Intent to murder (as distinct from actually attempting it) is an arrestable crime; intent to breach a blockade (as distinct from actually attempting it) is not grounds for stopping or boarding.Duck Turkin wrote:If I'm trying to murder you, you'll want to stop me before I succeed.Harlequin wrote:The act of attempting to do something is very distinct from just intending to do so at a later time. Attempted murder, for example, is quite different to intent to murder. In any case, according to the above, boarding in international waters is still illegal without the suspicion of weapons transportation.
True, which is why I included the phrase "without the suspicion of weapons transportation." I thought that you had already read the first paragraph of the legal outline we have been discussing.Duck Turkin wrote:Your second contention is unfounded as boarding in international waters is not necessarily illegal.
The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
Some of the most highly trained elite special forces on the planet cannot keep their weapons out of the hands of a bunch of civilians? If I may repeat my paraphrase of Oscar again: for one world-class elite trooper to lose his weapon a few minutes into an active mission may be regarded as a misfortune; for two to do so looks like carelessness. Incompetence of that magnitude would be unforgivable in a soldier from any military force in the world, let alone multiple members of the IDF! I find it enormously difficult to swallow and, as some here know, swallowing is one of the things that I am best at.Duck Turkin wrote:It underlines the incompetence of the operation in my opinion.Harlequin wrote:BTW, do you not think it odd how those guns could be stolen?
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Not exactly. It doesn't have the word "intends" in it, which is the point everyone is trying to make. You only get to board it if it actually breaches the blockade.Duck Turkin wrote:I think you are reading that wrong. The law says that if a ship intends to breach a blockade, which this certainly did since that was their purpose, then the ship can be boarded after being warned (which they repeatedly were).
The words were: "Merchant ships ... may be attacked if they are ... breaching a blockade".
The word "intends" isn't in there. If you want to extend the definition of "breaching" to mean "within 20 miles of having breached", well, go right ahead. But if I turn on TV to watch an astronaut leaving the atmosphere, I damn well don't expect part of the show to include the part of the journey where he drives his car to work. And likewise, I don't expect a ship isn't breaching a blockade while it is in dock, when it sails, or while it's in international waters. I expect it to be breaching a blockade while it's in that act of actual breach.
As gravy has mentioned, experts in maritime law are currently debating this to see if there is any way that the law applies (it's easy to say no they were wrong, but you have to address all the "what if"s, and "according to this"'s to wholly settle the matter). If it is found that Israel had a right, then that changes matters.
But - on a straight reading on what has been posted on here related to maritime law it is absolutely clear - Israel had no right to board the ship, and I'm flabbergasted that anyone can argue otherwise at the moment. Really.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Harlequin wrote:I find it enormously difficult to swallow and, as some here know, swallowing is one of the things that I am best at.
Sorry, I just liked that so much I had to quote it.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
That quote is so abreviated as to potentially be a misquote. From earlier in this thread:ekendrick wrote:Not exactly. It doesn't have the word "intends" in it, which is the point everyone is trying to make. You only get to board it if it actually breaches the blockade.Duck Turkin wrote:I think you are reading that wrong. The law says that if a ship intends to breach a blockade, which this certainly did since that was their purpose, then the ship can be boarded after being warned (which they repeatedly were).
The words were: "Merchant ships ... may be attacked if they are ... breaching a blockade".
The word "intends" isn't in there. If you want to extend the definition of "breaching" to mean "within 20 miles of having breached", well, go right ahead.
Particularly:aureole wrote:Helsinki Principles on the Law of Maritime Neutrality wrote:
5.1.2(3) Merchant ships flying the flag of a neutral State may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade, and after prior warning they intentionally and clearly refuse to stop, or intentionally and clearly resist visit, search, capture or diversion.
The Israeli's beliefs may seem unreasonable to you or me, but I have to say that I believe that they believed that the ships were in the process of attempting to breach the blockade, and probably believed them to be carrying weapons, or components of weapons (since food can be a component of explosives, as can fertilisers).may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade
Besides which, what happened was that the people on the ships specifically:
it was that point in the process, the ships weren't attacked (with e.g. missiles, bombs or shells) and sunk, which is presumably the expected form of attack.resist(ed) visit, search, capture or diversion.
Last edited by zip accident on Wed Jun 02, 2010 6:49 pm 0, edited 2 times in total.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Israelis not covering themselves in glory again. Nit sure they'll ever learn their attitude isn't helping actually solving the issue if the US don't stop protecting them.
They're currently spamming replies on Twitter with links to "approved" reporting on the matter to anyone that appears not to share their view, and don't bother querying their posts as it just results in more spam
They're currently spamming replies on Twitter with links to "approved" reporting on the matter to anyone that appears not to share their view, and don't bother querying their posts as it just results in more spam
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Oh, and just because this has got on my nerves:
The blockade exists to stop ships getting to port. It is in itself a preventative measure. Preventing somebody from breaching your preventative measure is just stupid. That's like security at a shop tackling somebody who's walking near the exit because they were about to steal something. You have to wait til they clearly attempt to leave, not just rush in the moment it looks like they're going to leave, even if they say to their friend they're going to nick something and you overhear.
If you don't cross the line, you haven't done anything wrong. Dancing really near the line, threatening to cross it or talking about crossing it aren't the same.
To use the murder analogy, somebody might have a gun and they might say 'shut up or I'll shoot you'. That's unpleasant and might be construed as a threat, but it's not til they cock that gun and ready to aim that they're definitely going to have a shot. Indeed, it's usually when somebody attempts to aim their gun at the somebody that the police shoot them because it constitutes a clear and obvious threat. Crossing a blockade also constitutes a 'threat', not crossing it does not. Intent it not important and to be fair even if it was it would be important maybe a mile or so from the blockade, not 20 miles from it.
Oh, and just because a country believes something doesn't make it true. It's a paranoid nation who keep their people on board with their horrible treatment of others by simply misinforming them and not paying any attention to anybody else's views or opinions. Like another country I know, and by 'another country' I mean Eagleland.
The blockade exists to stop ships getting to port. It is in itself a preventative measure. Preventing somebody from breaching your preventative measure is just stupid. That's like security at a shop tackling somebody who's walking near the exit because they were about to steal something. You have to wait til they clearly attempt to leave, not just rush in the moment it looks like they're going to leave, even if they say to their friend they're going to nick something and you overhear.
If you don't cross the line, you haven't done anything wrong. Dancing really near the line, threatening to cross it or talking about crossing it aren't the same.
To use the murder analogy, somebody might have a gun and they might say 'shut up or I'll shoot you'. That's unpleasant and might be construed as a threat, but it's not til they cock that gun and ready to aim that they're definitely going to have a shot. Indeed, it's usually when somebody attempts to aim their gun at the somebody that the police shoot them because it constitutes a clear and obvious threat. Crossing a blockade also constitutes a 'threat', not crossing it does not. Intent it not important and to be fair even if it was it would be important maybe a mile or so from the blockade, not 20 miles from it.
Oh, and just because a country believes something doesn't make it true. It's a paranoid nation who keep their people on board with their horrible treatment of others by simply misinforming them and not paying any attention to anybody else's views or opinions. Like another country I know, and by 'another country' I mean Eagleland.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Apologies - though you know it isn't a misquote (the relevant meaning is intact). I had earlier used the full quote and then broke it down, but it obviously was too much to read so I cut it down to the bare words that apply.zip accident wrote: That quote is so abreviated as to potentially be a misquote. From earlier in this thread:
Look, without commas the sentence can be read several ways. Now excluding the carrying contraband words, you can read it any one of three ways:zip accident wrote: Particularly:
The Israeli's beliefs may seem unreasonable to you or me, but I have to say that I believe that they believed that the ships were in the process of attempting to breach the blockade, and probably believed them to be carrying weapons, or components of weapons (since food can be a component of explosives, as can fertilisers).may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade
1. may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be breaching a blockade
2. may be attacked if they are believed to be breaching a blockade
3. may be attacked if they are breaching a blockade
If you read all three, they share in common the one clause - the ship has to be breaching a blockade to apply. The other two interpretations give wriggle room in case you attack because you thought they had breached but were mistaken. But being 20 miles away from the blockade is a bit far to accept a mistake, and Israel isn't saying oops, we thought they had breached.
If you need to put the contraband words back in, if that is the only cause for the attack, then we don't need to discuss the blockade. We need to discuss contraband, what counts as contraband, and if Israel could have had any reasonable believe the ship was carrying contraband, apart from the fact that it's declared intent was to breach the blockade. Which is as much as substantial as suggesting the ship looked shifty so they sank it.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Yeah, selective quoting.zip accident wrote:That quote is so abreviated as to potentially be a misquote. From earlier in this thread:ekendrick wrote:Not exactly. It doesn't have the word "intends" in it, which is the point everyone is trying to make. You only get to board it if it actually breaches the blockade.Duck Turkin wrote:I think you are reading that wrong. The law says that if a ship intends to breach a blockade, which this certainly did since that was their purpose, then the ship can be boarded after being warned (which they repeatedly were).
The words were: "Merchant ships ... may be attacked if they are ... breaching a blockade".
The word "intends" isn't in there. If you want to extend the definition of "breaching" to mean "within 20 miles of having breached", well, go right ahead.
aureole wrote:Helsinki Principles on the Law of Maritime Neutrality wrote:
5.1.2(3) Merchant ships flying the flag of a neutral State may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade, and after prior warning they intentionally and clearly refuse to stop, or intentionally and clearly resist visit, search, capture or diversion.
They were [in the process] of breaching a blockade.
If we wanted to get ultra-specific about language we could say that once they've passed over the hair-thin blockade line they cannot be attacked since having breached they're no longer breaching.
Bit shit if your protesters are in a speedboat isn't it. "Right we've got a 0.3 second window in which to board that speedboat, overpower the crew and take control, get ready lads"
Last edited by disciple on Wed Jun 02, 2010 7:05 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
