Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by zip accident »

Spoongod wrote:The blockade exists to stop ships getting to port. It is in itself a preventative measure. Preventing somebody from breaching your preventative measure is just stupid.
Also called enforcing the measure.
If you don't cross the line, you haven't done anything wrong. Dancing really near the line, threatening to cross it or talking about crossing it aren't the same.
When they read the riot act, not going home is an offence, whether you do anything else or not.
To use the murder analogy, somebody might have a gun and they might say 'shut up or I'll shoot you'. That's unpleasant and might be construed as a threat, but it's not til they cock that gun and ready to aim that they're definitely going to have a shot. Indeed, it's usually when somebody attempts to aim their gun at the somebody that the police shoot them because it constitutes a clear and obvious threat.
Threatening to kill someone is itself an offence. Conditional threats maybe less so, but still probably an offence I suspect.
Oh, and just because a country believes something doesn't make it true.
Of course not. However, that law says they have to believe it, not that it has to be true. They get to act on their beliefs, not on the truth. It does say:
believed on reasonable grounds
But that just means one paranoid individual is not allowed to go it alone just because s/he is the senior officer present, if the whole unit believes it, it's probably fine, and if the country does it's almost certainly fine, even if the rest of the world disagrees.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
ekendrick
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3033
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 12:14 pm 0
Location: Stratford-upon-Avon

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by ekendrick »

disciple - Oh... COME ON?

I write it out in full and you just ignore it, so I quote it again just using the relevant words and you nitpick it to hell.

I then clarify and you IGNORE it. Now, every time I've posted the forum has warned me that there has been a subsequent post and gave me an opportunity to read it before posting, so. Well. you can't say it isn't intentional. So COME ON what. are. you. on?

*flounces off the forum again*

*sniff*

You just don't deserve me.

;)
User avatar
Duck Turkin
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1682
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
Location: Down South

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by Duck Turkin »

Harlequin wrote:True, which is why I included the phrase "without the suspicion of weapons transportation." I thought that you had already read the first paragraph of the legal outline we have been discussing.
The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
Why keep bringing this up? The second part clearly states:
"A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate"." We both agree that the proportionate part was breached, but the legality of boarding the ship is not black and white. It was not an obviously illegal action, although lawyers may in the future determine that it was.
Harlequin wrote:
Duck Turkin wrote:
Harlequin wrote:BTW, do you not think it odd how those guns could be stolen?
It underlines the incompetence of the operation in my opinion.
Some of the most highly trained elite special forces on the planet cannot keep their weapons out of the hands of a bunch of civilians? If I may repeat my paraphrase of Oscar again: for one world-class elite trooper to lose his weapon a few minutes into an active mission may be regarded as a misfortune; for two to do so looks like carelessness. Incompetence of that magnitude would be unforgivable in a soldier from any military force in the world, let alone multiple members of the IDF! I find it enormously difficult to swallow and, as some here know, swallowing is one of the things that I am best at.
This is what makes this operation a total balls up. The soldiers should never have had their guns taken away. With more professionalism and planning things wouldn't never have become this bad.
User avatar
axel000
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
PSN: huckwee
Location: Philadelphia, USA

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by axel000 »

Hmmm you are all missing the point; the blockaid of Gaza is not internationally recognized...indeed if it was not for the sizeable Jewish population in the US distorting the truthfulness of US policy in this area, the UN would have long ago brought down sanctions against Israel for its modern day apartheid state and effective imprisonment of millions of Palestinians in the Gaza strip.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by Harlequin »

zip accident wrote:That quote is so abreviated as to potentially be a misquote. From earlier in this thread:
aureole wrote:
Helsinki Principles on the Law of Maritime Neutrality wrote:5.1.2(3) Merchant ships flying the flag of a neutral State may be attacked if they are believed on reasonable grounds to be carrying contraband or breaching a blockade, and after prior warning they intentionally and clearly refuse to stop, or intentionally and clearly resist visit, search, capture or diversion.
We were discussing The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea as summarised by the BBC:
The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
The charter allows for naval blockades, but the effect of the blockade on civilians must be proportionate to the effect on the military element for the blockade to be legally enforceable.
A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
If we are reading the Helsinki Principles, however:
Helsinki Principles on the Law of Maritime Neutrality wrote:5.1.2 Protection against attacks
…
(5) Merchant ships flying the flag of a neutral State and carrying only civilian passengers, e.g., liners, may not be attacked but must be diverted to an appropriate port to complete capture, unless they are incorporated into or assist the enemy’s intelligence system.
…
5.1.3 Precautions in attacks
In conducting attacks by whatever means, the armed forces of a party to the conflict must take all feasible precautions in order to avoid that
- the attack is directed against a neutral vessel or aircraft.
…
5.3 Relief
A blockade may not be used to prevent the passage of relief consignments which has to be free according to the applicable rules of international humanitarian law, in particular those contained in Articles 23, 59 and 61 of the Fourth Geneva Convention or Articles 69 and 70 of Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Conventions.
disciple wrote:They were [in the process] of breaching a blockade.
…
Bit shit if your protesters are in a speedboat isn't it. "Right we've got a 0.3 second window in which to board that speedboat, overpower the crew and take control, get ready lads"
Where can I find one of these speedboats that can do 4,000 Mph?

Can we ask RiK if he has the legal right to use force if someone comes within twenty miles of a door that he is guarding?
Duck Turkin wrote:
Harlequin wrote:
The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
Why keep bringing this up? The second part clearly states:
"A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate"." We both agree that the proportionate part was breached, but the legality of boarding the ship is not black and white. It was not an obviously illegal action, although lawyers may in the future determine that it was.
I bring it up because the other parts do not contradict it. They apply outside of international waters.
Duck Turkin wrote:
Harlequin wrote:
Duck Turkin wrote:Some of the most highly trained elite special forces on the planet cannot keep their weapons out of the hands of a bunch of civilians? If I may repeat my paraphrase of Oscar again: for one world-class elite trooper to lose his weapon a few minutes into an active mission may be regarded as a misfortune; for two to do so looks like carelessness. Incompetence of that magnitude would be unforgivable in a soldier from any military force in the world, let alone multiple members of the IDF! I find it enormously difficult to swallow and, as some here know, swallowing is one of the things that I am best at.
This is what makes this operation a total balls up. The soldiers should never have had their guns taken away. With more professionalism and planning things wouldn't never have become this bad.
More professionalism? This comes down to the training of the individual soldiers and these troops were some of the most highly trained professionals in the world.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by pogo »

Harlequin wrote:More professionalism? This comes down to the training of the individual soldiers and these troops were some of the most highly trained professionals in the world.
Wot ? The IDF is a conscript army with a long history of fucking up is similar situations, i.e. faced with civilians. Professionalism is when you chose those suited for the job, invest in their training and pay them so it's a career. Not take people barely out of school, no matter their suitability, give them minimal training (as you won't have them for long enough to develop real skills) and put them in combat situations. I suspect they are doing it for entirely the wrong reasons too, as if they relied on professionals, few would want to do what seems very unpleasant work, which means there's probably a lot of people doing it who would much rather be elsewhere and fall well short of the professional commitment of armies like the US or UK.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by zip accident »

I was thinking about the British approach to this situation (back when we were a significant power).

I think we'd have asked them politely, several times, whether we could come aboard, then warned them of the blockade, several times, fired warning shots across the bows, waited until they were in the blockade zone, then sunk the ships.

I suspect the Israelis let them off lightly, in real terms.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
mattley
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6253
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2002 3:50 pm 0
Location: Watford
Contact:

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by mattley »

axel000 wrote:Hmmm you are all missing the point; the blockaid of Gaza is not internationally recognized...
It is recognised in fact it's been quite well publicised, OK it isn't widely supported or UN ratified but it's THERE and it isn't going away and it's run by Israel, to try this blockade run was never going to end well and Turkey has made a huge mistake allowing its name to be associated with this folly.

axel000 wrote:indeed if it was not for the sizeable Jewish population in the US distorting the truthfulness of US policy in this area, the UN would have long ago brought down sanctions against Israel for its modern day apartheid state and effective imprisonment of millions of Palestinians in the Gaza strip.

Don't forget that the Palestinians voted for a party whos stated aim was the destruction of Israel hence the blockade. Yes it's collective punishment but that's the price you pay for democracy in a country with a 51% dumb fuck electorate.

Best thing Palestine can do right now is have another election and put Hamas pretty much where we put the BNP last time we got a go.
vi vi vi the text editor of the beast.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by pogo »

zip accident wrote:I was thinking about the British approach to this situation (back when we were a significant power).

I think we'd have asked them politely, several times, whether we could come aboard, then warned them of the blockade, several times, fired warning shots across the bows, waited until they were in the blockade zone, then sunk the ships.
Really ? The closest point of comparison in the UK is illegal immigration, where in marked contrast to other countries (OK, Australia) not much is done at sea to stop people coming here, or at least once they get close enough to be considered our problem they are brought onshore. Further back in history our borders were much more open and there was a lot more freedom of movement from e.g. Europe. I can't think of any instance in history where civilian ships have been sunk, or a time when it would have been done.
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by Harlequin »

pogo wrote:
Harlequin wrote:More professionalism? This comes down to the training of the individual soldiers and these troops were some of the most highly trained professionals in the world.
Wot ? The IDF is a conscript army with a long history of fucking up is similar situations, i.e. faced with civilians. Professionalism is when you chose those suited for the job, invest in their training and pay them so it's a career. Not take people barely out of school, no matter their suitability, give them minimal training (as you won't have them for long enough to develop real skills) and put them in combat situations. I suspect they are doing it for entirely the wrong reasons too, as if they relied on professionals, few would want to do what seems very unpleasant work, which means there's probably a lot of people doing it who would much rather be elsewhere and fall well short of the professional commitment of armies like the US or UK.
That may be true of the regular service but this was Shayetet 13, Israel's elite naval commando Special Forces Unit, apparently specialising in sea-to-land incursions, assassinations, counter-terrorism, sabotage, maritime intelligence gathering and maritime hostage rescue. Not your everyday conscripted grunts.
mattley wrote:
axel000 wrote:Hmmm you are all missing the point; the blockaid of Gaza is not internationally recognized...
It is recognised in fact it's been quite well publicised, OK it isn't widely supported or UN ratified but it's THERE and it isn't going away and it's run by Israel, to try this blockade run was never going to end well and Turkey has made a huge mistake allowing its name to be associated with this folly.
Perhaps that should be rephrased: the legality of the blockade of Gaza is not internationally recognized.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:Really ?
I dunno, I was thinking of long ago and far away. Probably pre WW1. There were places where we ran blockades in those times I'm pretty sure, though I couldn't name one.

Wikipedia says that the British blockade of Germany in WW1 caused a lot of privation. I don't get details of shipping sunk in the process, maybe no-one was silly enough to try running it.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by pogo »

Harlequin wrote:That may be true of the regular service but this was Shayetet 13, Israel's elite naval commando Special Forces Unit, apparently specialising in sea-to-land incursions, assassinations, counter-terrorism, sabotage, maritime intelligence gathering and maritime hostage rescue. Not your everyday conscripted grunts.
I didn't know that, but still, based on what happened they seemed singularly ill prepared for what they encountered, in an operation they had a long time to get ready for.
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by Gorecki »

zip accident wrote:I was thinking about the British approach to this situation (back when we were a significant power).
An interesting historical reference for anyone with forty minutes to spare.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/adamcurtis/2 ... _pale.html
Here is a strange echo from history.

It is a documentary made by the BBC in 1973 about the story of the ship, the Exodus.

It was the ship full of Jewish refugees - many of them survivors of the Holocaust - that tried to break the British blockade of Palestine in 1947. The participants from both sides appear and describe in detail how British soldiers boarded the ship 21 miles off the coast of Palestine killing 3 of the refugees and wounding others.

It caused an international scandal and was a PR disaster for the British government. It is seen in Israel today as one of the most significant events that led to the founding of the modern Israeli state.
zip accident wrote:I suspect the Israelis let them off lightly, in real terms.
I'm sure that's a great comfort to the relatives of the deceased.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
disciple
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13941
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
PSN: Prime_Heretic
Location: Greenfield
Contact:

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by disciple »

ekendrick wrote:You just don't deserve me.

;)
No we don't!

Well, it's just I don't see it working like the state border in Smokey and the Bandit.

I'm sure there will be a number of instances where a blockade has opened fire on one or more ships trying to break a blockade before the line has been physically crossed.

Analogies have been made to shoplifting with the shoplifter dancing around just inside the shop and there being nothing that can be done since technically said shoplifter hasn't actually crossed the line! Despite the shambles seen in the video the Isreali's take this sort of thing seriously, as should any military force defending a country's interests. It's expected you get the job done and within the scope of the quoted 'law', and the norms of sea-warfare I'd deem the action taken as acceptable.

Given sea warfare is usually undertaken at range, and given the protester's intention was clear, I'm pretty sure it won't be hard at all to find precedent for this.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza

Post by Harlequin »

disciple wrote:I'm sure there will be a number of instances where a blockade has opened fire on one or more ships trying to break a blockade before the line has been physically crossed.
Twenty miles away? In international waters?
disciple wrote:Analogies have been made to shoplifting with the shoplifter dancing around just inside the shop and there being nothing that can be done since technically said shoplifter hasn't actually crossed the line! Despite the shambles seen in the video the Isreali's take this sort of thing seriously, as should any military force defending a country's interests. It's expected you get the job done and within the scope of the quoted 'law', and the norms of sea-warfare I'd deem the action taken as acceptable.
Again, twenty miles away in international waters hardly counts as "just inside the shop" and certainly not within the legal scope by my reading although, as we know, this is still being debated by those who actually know the laws and their application.
disciple wrote:Given sea warfare is usually undertaken at range, and given the protester's intention was clear, I'm pretty sure it won't be hard at all to find precedent for this.
The only one I have found so far is that of the British forces against the SS Exodus 1947, as linked to by Gorecki above, although we only killed three passengers and crew. I can only hope that the recent events hasten the formation of a sovereign Palestinian state as quickly as that did Israel.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Post Reply