Full agreement- you've almost saved me from saying it myself. A nice change of pace, a little less self-bashing from the Doctor and some properly meaty subject matter. Also Bill Nighy.The Captain wrote:Yeah, OK, you like the song. It's not that I don't get it or why it's there. I find that kind of thing overbearing in drama programmes anyway - the dialogue, acting and atmosphere - and dare I say, the incidental music - should be enough. It was so loud, and the lyrics so twee, it was like having someone sat next to me, digging me in the ribs, saying 'DO YOU SEE? IT'S MOVING'. It detracted from the episode for me. I don't give one thrust of a fuck whether Athlete have been around as long as Coldplay, or whoever came first - they sound alike, or at least that song does. That can be proved with pie charts and diagrams. I have heard Coldplay before, I hadn't heard of Athlete. And now I know who they are, I shall endeavour to avoid them. I'm not blaming Athlete for the song's inclusion, or claiming they ripped off Coldplay, I just think it was a mistake to put it in, and an error of judgement from Richard Curtis, the sort of thing best left to Youtube 'Tribute' videos.
Just for the record, I disagree about the depth in the song - it's one of those with lyrics that are so elusively vague yet with the appearance of profundity that you can apply it to almost anything; no doubt it will be or has been used to accompany pictures of starving Ethiopian kids in a Comic Relief 'serious bit', or slow motion footage of Jade Goody waving goodbye to the Big Brother house. You are welcome to love the song and find whatever depth you like in it, of course, but for this viewer it had all the emotional resonance of a can of warm Lilt.... Whereas the episode itself was hugely profound and beautiful.
The little musical interlude was jarring and uneccesary only because the episode had already done it's work for it. I'm going to set it aside as a sort of emotional induction loop device for the hard of feeling.





