and the Portuguese are very happy that Cacá is out of the game against Portugal even if the exclusion is one of those misteries only a referee can explain.
Now i'm going to ask Teifi to forgive me for all that noise i made with the blow horn. Poor thing he thinks human went crazy.
PFVA wrote:and the Portuguese are very happy that Cacá is out of the game against Portugal even if the exclusion is one of those misteries only a referee can explain.
PFVA wrote:and the Portuguese are very happy that Cacá is out of the game against Portugal even if the exclusion is one of those misteries only a referee can explain.
I am at a complete loss how you could possibly deduce most of that from what we saw.
This is the only clip I can currently find on youtube, with an odd choice of music. 1.02 shows it in slow motion and from a slightly different angle. He clearly pushes him in the solar plexus with his elbow with a bit of added bite added from his hip movement. It's little more than slight bump, although it is intentional. Keita bumps his face slightly on his shoulder as he runs into Kaka, but that would have happened regardless of the elbow.
Edit: actually there are others that show the incident on youtube but none from that angle.
Gorecki wrote:I am at a complete loss how you could possibly deduce most of that from what we saw.
This is the only clip I can currently find on youtube,
Or you could try watching the much better quality BBC one I link to in my piece. And I "deduced" it by looking.
I can't, iPlayer runs like shit on my computer. But that clip does back up my initial feelings after seeing it live. Did the beeb show it in slow-mo and from that angle?
Pretty sure it's apparent to anyone who saw it that there was an intentional elbow. Head clash though? Don't think so, it was play acting, hence the "witch hunt".
disciple wrote:Pretty sure it's apparent to anyone who saw it that there was an intentional elbow. Head clash though? Don't think so, it was play acting, hence the "witch hunt".
Watch the footage at 38 seconds. If you don't see the sides of their heads banging together there, see an optician.
http://wosland.podgamer.com "You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
I did do. I can see it might look that way from your footage, but that's taken from the worst possible angle for determining if there was a collision.
Gorecki's footage is better since it's more side on, you can see his head bangs into Kaka's shoulder at about the 1:07 mark, it's not even a particularly hard collision since the majority of impact is taken by his chest. Defo looks like play-acting.
disciple wrote:Gorecki's footage is better since it's more side on, you can see his head bangs into Kaka's shoulder at about the 1:07 mark,
At 1.07, Kaka's shoulder is in line with the back of Keita's jaw, not his temple. It's still perfectly possible that their heads have collided. And even if you're saying Keita's head hit Kaka's shoulder... are shoulders made of jelly now? I don't keep up with The Lancet, but I'm pretty sure they're still solid bone.
http://wosland.podgamer.com "You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
disciple wrote:Gorecki's footage is better since it's more side on, you can see his head bangs into Kaka's shoulder at about the 1:07 mark,
At 1.07, Kaka's shoulder is in line with the back of Keita's jaw, not his temple. It's still perfectly possible that their heads have collided. And even if you're saying Keita's head hit Kaka's shoulder... are shoulders made of jelly now? I don't keep up with The Lancet, but I'm pretty sure they're still solid bone.
If there's a collision between Keita's jaw and Kaka's shoulder then how can there be a head to head collision given the human skull doesn't bend and the neck muscles only allow ~30 degrees of lateral movement?
If your saying it's a head shoulder collision, I think from the video Keita takes the brunt of the impact on his chest. It's a bit telling that Keita goes down with his hands on the front of his face when the impact was actually side on.
disciple wrote:Gorecki's footage is better since it's more side on, you can see his head bangs into Kaka's shoulder at about the 1:07 mark,
At 1.07, Kaka's shoulder is in line with the back of Keita's jaw, not his temple. It's still perfectly possible that their heads have collided. And even if you're saying Keita's head hit Kaka's shoulder... are shoulders made of jelly now? I don't keep up with The Lancet, but I'm pretty sure they're still solid bone.
<sings> The rib-bone is connected to the, head-bone</sings>
Maybe you should read The Lancet (although why get even more confused when any children's book on anatomy will set you straight).
However it is obvious that Kaka was trying to get a cheap hit on Keita, so the red card was deserved.