One other thing - I didn't sob at this one, and I preferred that. The end of a series doesn't have to be harrowing. Felt like Moff wanted us to have a choice in how we felt, as opposed to the YOU WILL WEEP fist of anguish that usually accompanied RTD endings. This, by the way is comparison, not criticism.
Sometimes it is enough to be fun, heartwarming, exciting, lovely, clever and ace. I wasn't saying goodbye to (in series order to date) Doctor 9, Rose, good scripts, Rose again, or Doctor 10 this time, we just saw Amy and Rory get married and The Doctor's hat explode. Onward to adventure, no bones broken, see you at Xmas for some dumb fun and then next year we'll talk about River and the Silence.
Which is the sort of thing we were all hoping for, innit?
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
One other thing - I didn't sob at this one, and I preferred that. The end of a series doesn't have to be harrowing. Felt like Moff wanted us to have a choice in how we felt, as opposed to the YOU WILL WEEP fist of anguish that usually accompanied RTD endings. This, by the way is comparison, not criticism
Yeah that adds nicely to the points about it being lighthearted and just letting you smile. Everyone has different tastes, me I like an ending like this one and also the fact that he didn't leave us with a massive cliffhanger for 6 months.
One other thing - I didn't sob at this one, and I preferred that. The end of a series doesn't have to be harrowing. Felt like Moff wanted us to have a choice in how we felt, as opposed to the YOU WILL WEEP fist of anguish that usually accompanied RTD endings. This, by the way is comparison, not criticism
Yeah that adds nicely to the points about it being lighthearted and just letting you smile. Everyone has different tastes, me I like an ending like this one and also the fact that he didn't leave us with a massive cliffhanger for 6 months.
Interesting points, as I NEVER sobbed or felt even slightly moved by RTD's over-written schmaltz-fests, yet I was very moved by some of the scenes in The Big Bang.
IronGiant wrote:
Interesting points, as I NEVER sobbed or felt even slightly moved by RTD's over-written schmaltz-fests, yet I was very moved by some of the scenes in The Big Bang.
I'm wantonly open to over-written schmaltz fests, while I might have preferred something else at times, that's what was happening to the characters I love. I'm surprised anyone could fail to be moved by the initial farewell to Rose, or the cafe scene with Cribbens where 10 wells up himself, though. Those were utterly heart-rending to me. Buttons pushed. I just don't always thank RTD for it.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
FX23- master ov questions wrote:yeh, im the daddy.
so all in all a good series apart from the vampire fish one and series final which where shite.
Watch the finale again with your memory refreshed by the recent explanations. And remember, it's a show about remembering - be it stars, Rory or events in prior episodes. I love how Moffat weaves our own remembering in with that of the characters, even within one episode, as per the wristband Doctor antics.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard