World Cup 2010, there we went!
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Well Motty's reason for not having technology in football is bollocks.
When asked why not use the same technology available in tennis and cricket:
"Football is a continuous game". How long were the arguments after the Tevez 'goal'? Longer than it would have taken to check a video clip, that's for sure.
When asked why not use the same technology available in tennis and cricket:
"Football is a continuous game". How long were the arguments after the Tevez 'goal'? Longer than it would have taken to check a video clip, that's for sure.
Is this going to take long, only my foot's gone to sleep and I'd like to catch it up.
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
360 Gamertag: xGEENIUSx
http://www.fitnessin3steps.co.uk
- hairy_pete
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7217
- Joined: Mon May 27, 2002 8:10 pm 0
- Location: A Tiny Village in Bavaria
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Heh, yes, this sport needs video proof - both for foul play and for occasions like this one. In this championship alone, there was enough nonsense escaping the referees to prove that point.Guru-Meditation wrote:http://i.imgur.com/Yd4xq.png
![]()
Nope, there simply is no offside when the ball comes straight from a goalie kick.The strangest part about all this is on the first goal the german players were about 5 yards offside at the time the ball was kicked. But because our defense was so bad at dealing with it and the aftermath in the game it's been completely forgotten
- Gorecki
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5962
- Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
- Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
I think he has a fair point. Few people would argue that it wouldn't be trivially easy to implement goal-line technology to tell when the ball crosses the line. But the question is where do you stop? There are seemingly trivial, border-line decisions made all over the pitch almost every minute in a game of football and the game is only allowed to flow because one man has absolute control to make instant decision. It's not hard to imagine a situation where an over zealous urge to make the game perfectly fair reduces the game to a series of stop-start bursts and end up making the game even less fair.Geenius wrote:Well Motty's reason for not having technology in football is bollocks.
It could be possible to introduce various technologies to football refereeing but does anyone trust FIFA to do it without wrecking the game completely?
Tang Sou!
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
You can't legislate for incompetent officials, in the same way you can't compensate for shite players. We had both today; it would have been a bit of a travesty had we got a result based on the final score, but the Germans were rattled in that 54 seconds where we didn't play like a pub team with a hangover. Who knows how it goes under different circumstances.
Fortunately, this must see the end of some careers, and some serious re-evaluation of some others. One being that Rooney cannot perform when there are consequences for getting sent off - when he's off the leash, he's quite a player, but when he knows that getting sent off will lead to more than a 3 week holiday and a mild SAF earbashing, he's a waste of space.
Upson, last England game, surely, potentially Fat Frank, Gareth Barry, Heskey. others? JT? James? Rio?
Simon
Fortunately, this must see the end of some careers, and some serious re-evaluation of some others. One being that Rooney cannot perform when there are consequences for getting sent off - when he's off the leash, he's quite a player, but when he knows that getting sent off will lead to more than a 3 week holiday and a mild SAF earbashing, he's a waste of space.
Upson, last England game, surely, potentially Fat Frank, Gareth Barry, Heskey. others? JT? James? Rio?
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Couldn't agree more. He made mistakes, but after the players failed yet again to do even the basics right it's time they took the blame this time.Gorecki wrote:I really hope that Capello isn't lumbered with all the blame for the poor performance. We really need a strong manager with some real authority and clout. Sacking every manager who doesn't make it to the quarter finals won't give us that.turk182 wrote:Fabio will need to get some grit back into the squad.
Our problem is that everything is about the next game and nothing else matters. If we draw a meaningless friendly then the fans, fuelled to ridiculous levels by the media, want the manger and all the players out.
What we need to do , as several other countries have done, is start building for the next World Cup now. Get rid of the players who will be too old and have proved time and again that they aren't good enough anyway (James, Terry, Ferdinand, Lampard, Gerrard etc.), bring in Hart, Wilshire, Rodwell etc and accept we will have some bad results and it might take a few years before we get the best out of them.
And finally Rooney was shocking, but clearly nowhere near fit enough to be playing. What are the odds it's announced next week he needs an operation of some kind and should never have been there much like Beckham in previous tournaments?
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Hard to think we wouldn't have been better if, decrepit as he is, Beckham had been on the pitch. He at least would have set the bar higher in terms of professionalism and set an example to the others that noone else in the squad seemed able to provide.fog wrote:…Beckham in previous tournaments?
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Technology has to come into the game, this current World Cup I think has aptly demonstrated why at least a limited introduction is now a necessity. At this level you have to provide support to the officials, it's beyond a joke, FIFA just fudge the issue.
As for England, possibly the worst defensive performance I have ever seen, but let's not kid ourselves, Germany were devastating. They've heavily invested in player development, we haven't. We've carried injuries, over-prepared, look just plain fed up, and at the end of the game the players seemed palpably relieved for it to be over. They are probably sick of each other anyway.
As for Capello, I see no reason why his job shouldn't be at risk. He's handsomely paid to turn his immense club credentials into international success and quite frankly this tournament has his reputation almost shattered. The past couple of weeks have exposed a fair few bizarre decisions and a troubling player rift that can't be healthy. Maybe he is the man to reboot the whole thing, I guess I just don't know.
At least we can enjoy the remaining games, come on Chile!!
As for England, possibly the worst defensive performance I have ever seen, but let's not kid ourselves, Germany were devastating. They've heavily invested in player development, we haven't. We've carried injuries, over-prepared, look just plain fed up, and at the end of the game the players seemed palpably relieved for it to be over. They are probably sick of each other anyway.
As for Capello, I see no reason why his job shouldn't be at risk. He's handsomely paid to turn his immense club credentials into international success and quite frankly this tournament has his reputation almost shattered. The past couple of weeks have exposed a fair few bizarre decisions and a troubling player rift that can't be healthy. Maybe he is the man to reboot the whole thing, I guess I just don't know.
At least we can enjoy the remaining games, come on Chile!!
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
- Portland
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 8828
- Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 8:16 am 0
- Location: Swinton, South Yorkshire
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Non-goal aside, Terry was well out of position for 3 of the German goals and has been shit stirring to boot, but the finger of blame seems to have not been pointed at St John somehow.
Portland 3.0.1.0 public release rolled out
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Rgby implemented limited use of video technology mainly on whether to award scores. Can't see why this couldn't be implemented in football without ruining the flow of the game.Gorecki wrote:I think he has a fair point. Few people would argue that it wouldn't be trivially easy to implement goal-line technology to tell when the ball crosses the line. But the question is where do you stop? There are seemingly trivial, border-line decisions made all over the pitch almost every minute in a game of football and the game is only allowed to flow because one man has absolute control to make instant decision. It's not hard to imagine a situation where an over zealous urge to make the game perfectly fair reduces the game to a series of stop-start bursts and end up making the game even less fair.Geenius wrote:Well Motty's reason for not having technology in football is bollocks.
It could be possible to introduce various technologies to football refereeing but does anyone trust FIFA to do it without wrecking the game completely?
It's not as if there are many bodies hiding the ball at goal time
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
I suppose the concern is that players and fans will be challenging every decision made and that would seriously upset the flow of a game. But surely some technology must exist which would set off an alarm as soon as the ball was a fraction of an inch over the line?
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Yes, this is the problem - the amount of incidents where the ball crosses/doesn't cross the the line is negligible compared to the amount of offside decisions. And what about throw-ins etc? That is what the naysayers mean when they say that it woudl slow the game down. It is manageable, however. If it is limited to, say, offside decisions that directly lead to a goal for instance. Gary Linekar was saying yesterday that there could be a system like tennis where you were only allowed three appeals per match/half, and maybe it could be limited to just the captain making the complaint.Tmuk wrote:I suppose the concern is that players and fans will be challenging every decision made and that would seriously upset the flow of a game. But surely some technology must exist which would set off an alarm as soon as the ball was a fraction of an inch over the line?
On a different note, I also thought that Terry was wooden throughout, and Johnson, whilst a good attacking full back, was woefully out of position throughout the tournament.
- RedOktober
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4788
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2005 11:15 pm 0
- Location: Stalin's Organ
- Contact:
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
At it's simplest, technology could provide a third official and a video feed. If there's something the ref needs to know about, the third man can shout at him down the earpiece.
Sponsoring terrorism at £1 per mile.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10456
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
Yeah, particularly in this kind of situation. If it were a goal play would have stopped anyway and it takes seconds to see...RedOktober wrote:At it's simplest, technology could provide a third official and a video feed. If there's something the ref needs to know about, the third man can shout at him down the earpiece.
Not sure challenges are a good idea. They just need to clearly define the situations it would be used in. Many situations are subjective and to an extent it is very much part of the game if a foul or offside is missed and shouldn't necessarily be subject to being pulled back.
A ball crossing the line is not subjective.
We also need to up the use of video evidence regardless of what the referees sees or has acted upon. We'll stamp out loads of crap as soon as players know that can get into trouble later.
Last edited by Misfit on Mon Jun 28, 2010 11:45 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
The biggest issue with this is that as soon as you do it, the offside law has to cease to exist for the officials on the field. You can't ever stop play for it because you don't know if you're right or not.RedOktober wrote:At it's simplest, technology could provide a third official and a video feed. If there's something the ref needs to know about, the third man can shout at him down the earpiece.
Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!
I just don't see what the issue is with bringing in technology. The World Cup is basically a joke without it, especially seeing as it's supposed to be the most important and popular sporting tournament in the world.
I also don't agree with people saying it would ruin the game and there's an issue of when you use it, what for and how far back you go. There isn't at all, a chip in the ball with a beep in the ref's ear when it crosses the line is an absolute necessity now. As for video replays, just draw up a list of situations when it can be used, everybody will then know the rules, what's the issue, it's simple. If a goal is clearly offside and everyone except the ref has seen it look at the video, it takes 5 seconds. Only use it for dubious goals like offside or handball, the mind boggles why they refuse to allow this.
I also don't agree with people saying it would ruin the game and there's an issue of when you use it, what for and how far back you go. There isn't at all, a chip in the ball with a beep in the ref's ear when it crosses the line is an absolute necessity now. As for video replays, just draw up a list of situations when it can be used, everybody will then know the rules, what's the issue, it's simple. If a goal is clearly offside and everyone except the ref has seen it look at the video, it takes 5 seconds. Only use it for dubious goals like offside or handball, the mind boggles why they refuse to allow this.


