merman wrote:cf Harlan Ellison and the Star Trek episode City on the Edge of Forever...
According to Wikipedia, "The production staff considered Ellison's script to be excellent." From what I've heard, then, not quite the same situation as with Gaiman's original Doctor Who script...
Yes, but it was IMPRACTICAL and would have cost hundreds of thousands of dollars more, at a time when the money per episode the production studio was budgeting was being cut... He had a dinosaur lunging through the time travel portal, for example, and described a scene with pterodactyls flying overhead.
The point I'm making is that Ellison then went on to win an award for his original script and made an angry speech about the TV company rewriting it... but in my opinion the rewrites worked to make it a better story (and kept it under budget).
Almost all works of fiction get written and re-written time and time again. Reading the notes in Neil Gaiman's short stories I get the impression that he's somebody who re-writes his stuff a little more than most anyway.
The next series of Doctor Who will air in two parts, it has been announced.
Speaking at the Edinburgh TV Festival this morning, showrunner Steven Moffat confirmed that the sixth run will start in Spring 2011 and return in the Autumn.
A statement from the BBC explained: "The split transmission is the result of a request from Steven Moffat to write a new Doctor Who story arc which involves a big plot twist in the middle of the series. By splitting the series Moffat plans to give viewers one of the most exciting Doctor Who cliffhangers and plot twists ever, leaving them waiting, on the edge of their seats, until the autumn to find out what happens."
A not uninteresting development for the next series:
"The BBC and Steven Moffat have announced today that the transmission of the next series of Doctor Who, in 2011, will be split into two blocks, transmitting in spring and autumn.
The split transmission is the result of a request from Steven Moffat to write a new Doctor Who story arc which involves a big plot twist in the middle of the series. By splitting the series Moffat plans to give viewers one of the most exciting Doctor Who cliffhangers and plot twists ever, leaving them waiting, on the edge of their seats, until the autumn to find out what happens.
Steven Moffat said: "The split series is hugely exciting because viewers will be treated to two premieres, two finales and more event episodes. For the kids it will never be more than a few months to the next Doctor Who! Easter, Autumn, Christmas!!" "
Cloudane wrote:At quick glance you could almost mistake that for a Red Dwarf photo with Moffat as Dave Lister. Now there's an idea
I had an idea for a Dr Who / Red Dwarf / ST:TNG crossover. However he only idea I had was having Lister arming the Enterprise with an enormous catapult made from all the knicker elastic on the 'Dwarf
Cloudane wrote:At quick glance you could almost mistake that for a Red Dwarf photo with Moffat as Dave Lister. Now there's an idea
I had an idea for a Dr Who / Red Dwarf / ST:TNG crossover. However he only idea I had was having Lister arming the Enterprise with an enormous catapult made from all the knicker elastic on the 'Dwarf
I would have loved to see Dr Who on a borg-based ST:TNG, so he could put in a dig about how similar they are to the cybermen
So I take it nobody's much bothered about the adventure games any more, given that I've seen no reviews and only one blog post about it since TARDIS was released.
Haven't got around to it yet although I finally got around to finishing the Cybermen one yesterday, having previously lost enthusiasm for it when it got to the tedious (although thankfully less so than the Dalek one) stealth section in Act 3.
After playing as far as the first avoid the Daleks bit of the first one and giving up I skipped over the second as from what I read it was more of the same, but downloaded and played through the third one which is different, though not necessarily better. Mild spoilers follow if you plan to play it.
The good:
* It's in the Tardis, so looks a lot better than e.g. generic bombed London
* You get a good look at the Tardis console, or a CGI version of it
* You get to see another room in the Tardis
* No stealth
* The plot is not bad, though with themes lifted from recent TV episodes
The bad:
* Same very poor animation, a very crude models of e.g. the Tardis, simple CGI effects
* Same poor (slow, tricky) navigation, except here instead of making stealth annoying it makes navigating the Tardis control room very annoying
* The other room in the Tardis is pretty dull (and you only get a brief glimpse of anything else)
* The gameplay sucks really badly:
The worst thing is the gameplay which consists of some very simple puzzles which if they were Flash games would be dismissed as childish, a quiz of random Dr Who knowledge with answers scattered around the other room (though with the slow navigation I found it quicker to guess) and a really annoying bit at the end where you've got to visit different panels of the central console in a minute, fighting against the appalling navigation. Took me four or five times to do what is a very simple task. Interspersed with some 'find and press a named button' and 'find objects to use' tasks that would be trivial if it weren't for the navigation.
After you've most of it you can examine and play with everything on the console, which is nice, except you get to look at the dodgy models they've used: they could have at least used some sort of level of detail system so it zooms in to high quality models. Ends at the start of the fourth which looks interesting - set after the great London flood of 2350 or some such.
TARDIS was very annoying to play - lots of recycled objects and puzzles from the last two games, and they actually made the TARDIS no fun to pilot. The Doctor's study was one of the most crushingly disappointing things they could have done. It even and especially bored my kids.
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.
Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
pogo wrote:After playing as far as the first avoid the Daleks bit of the first one and giving up I skipped over the second as from what I read it was more of the same
If it was mainly the stealth business that put you off the first one, I'd give the second one a go - you don't get to the stealth bits until act 3, they're a lot less tedious and frustrating than the Dalek ones, and there's more of a problem-solving aspect to the game. Still probably won't be up to much for people who'd consider themselves gamers, but I found it an occasional entertaining diversion (not enough to play it all the way through in one sitting, though). Whereas after way too much Dalek-dodging I simply couldn't hack the first one any more and ended up watching a YouTube walkthrough instead of finishing it.
pogo wrote:After playing as far as the first avoid the Daleks bit of the first one and giving up I skipped over the second as from what I read it was more of the same
If it was mainly the stealth business that put you off the first one, I'd give the second one a go - you don't get to the stealth bits until act 3, they're a lot less tedious and frustrating than the Dalek ones, and there's more of a problem-solving aspect to the game. Still probably won't be up to much for people who'd consider themselves gamers, but I found it an occasional entertaining diversion (not enough to play it all the way through in one sitting, though). Whereas after way too much Dalek-dodging I simply couldn't hack the first one any more and ended up watching a YouTube walkthrough instead of finishing it.
Thanks, downloaded and did the second one in two goes and it's not at all bad. The stealth bits are annoying, with the navigation not helping, but not as bad as I remember the Daleks and the rest is better. Environments are much better and the puzzles more interesting. Scarily the plot like the third remind me a lot of various Who shows, which doesn't so much mean the games were well written, more the shows are so predictable and formulaic. Animation is as bad as ever and Matt Smith especially seems to have no enthusiasm it. May even re-download and try the first again if I get bored some time.
Totally unrelated Warren Ellis has been having an art contest, design the 13th doctor. Just two copied below but there are many good ones.