tufty wrote:gilesgoat wrote:I never understood totally how all this "ISPs thing" work.
Don't know details here in UK but I do know that in Italy "nobody but Telecom ( the Italian BT ) actually ever laid down
cables and have the money/possibility to do so".
That's basically correct, apart from the cable TV guys and the few dedicated line people. That's why you're presumably still paying BT line rental, even if your telephony service is provided by someone else.
The ISPs are selling you a bunch of bandwidth delivered over BT's fibre and copper network. I'm not sure how the charging and stuff works out, but presumably they "buy" a bunch of bandwidth from BT and then "sell" it back to you. It's the same over here in France. Having dealt with non-France Telecom ISPs over here, it seems that the way they cut the price to you, the consumer, is by responding to every technical complaint from "my line won't sync" to "my modem arrived in a million pieces" with "It's France Telecom's fault, call them".
But the question is and remains .. WHO can REALLY provide you "good service" ? And this "good" how much is going to
cost you ? And CAN you REALLY buy it "anytime, anywhere" ?
BT are slowly dipping their toes into the "fibre to the premises" market, but I suspect it's gonna be a while before they get to your place.
There are still quite some mysteries I never understood, for example "how they can sell you all that bandwidth".
I had a bit of a check .. if you ask for a dedicated line "it still seems to be working the same", you can buy it in
( symmetric ) increments of 64K, in fact I believe it still works that let's say you want a 256K line this is actually a
"bundle" of 4 x 64K channels , I am not sure if we are talking about something "close to" the old ISDN system but I think it's "kinda".
I think last time I had to do with stuff like this they were telling us that "in the location we were" MAX they could have
sold us was an E3 line which has "enormous costs".
Now 8 mbits/sec is around an E2 carrier .. that again costs quite a bit .. a quick check in Italy Telecom seems "the best"
offer they can make around that is SHDLS "Liberty 8M" ( which they state "physical limit 6.5Mbits" ) can't find the price
listed ( i.e. "contact for" ) but judging by the price of other things must be well over 300 Eur/month.
So how they can sell 8 Mbits at 20 pounds a month it escapes me.
Fibers .. they were talking around here as well but I think "maybe in 5 years time if lucky", given the users pool around
here and such I can't see any improvement of any kind anytime soon.
I remember ( not sure about the prices now ) "FastWeb" in Italy was bringing fibers up to your place giving you a
GUARANTEED symmetric 10 Mbits/sec in all their circuit ( i.e. two users on FastWeb would talk each other at 10 Mbits/sec.)
in those times ( about 6 years ago ) was about 150 eur/month, out of their circuit I dunno the details but they did have
part of their circuit directly connected to some ATM backbones.
But you had to be in one of those towns touched by FastWeb service, which were/are only a few around Italy.
Ah a quick check seems for "micro business" they can now offer you 100 Mbits/sec download + 10 Mbits/sec upload
but this again is fiber, not copper.
I heard that if you are in a place like Milan you can get that service "no problem anywhere you are".
I always wondered anyway back to "standard common people DSL" how the heck they do, must be some form of
"time sharing/multiplexing" to give some bandwidth in some way.
About "resales" .. once a Telecom man was talking me something about some "anti trust EU laws" that basically forced
Telecom Italy to have some contract to re-sell/lease part of their lines to some "other companies" that then were re-selling
them to other people.
Fundamentally if Telecom could say again "fuck that" there would be no other company in Italy capable to sell any
landline connectivity other than Telecom, as it was for many years before, as I said "nobody but them owns lines" nobody
but them ( with the exceptions ) ever invested money to put down more wires or improve/expand the existing ones.
It yet has to happen and probably will never happen as it seems "all the investments" are gone into mobile/wifi stuff,
cheaper and easier to invest/set up/see returns/shut down/re-sell.
Anyway all this business to me seems quite "smoky" lot of promises and things but .. who knows what really is under the hood.