The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Phineasfool
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2698
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:57 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Phineasfool
PSN: Phineasfool
Location: Colorado, USA

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Phineasfool »

I think you guys think too much.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Gorecki wrote:I think the problem is, Dio that you're approaching this with the logic of a physicist rather than the logic of a storyteller. I think your argument that buggering about with time removes any drama has been blown out of the water by A Christmas Carol, where it was used to great dramatic effect.

The only reasons you've come up with so far are physical, causality reasons that simply don't apply to a decent storyteller.
Exactly the opposite. I'm quite happy for them to handwave away anything. Anything. When it comes to the next regeneration but one, I personally really rather want them to have it just happen, and everyone be a bit confused. I have no problem with saying "You break the laws of time, except that occasionally you can if we can handwave a reason". I ask for nothing but good stories and consistency - I think I've made that perfectly clear.

But the consistency can't be confined to a single episode, which means that there must be underlying rules and the ones shown in this episode are way too loose to be workable on a day-to-day basis.

You can't say "the Doctor can do this" and then next week conveniently forget it when Amy is in a dire situation where he can go and rescue her before the situation ever happened. That's not an objection based on physics, it's an objection based on storytelling.

(To be fair, you can do that, but it changes the tension mechanic around the stories totally, making them much harder to parse for the audience, and it doesn't seem to me that this is the intention, even without it making a mess of the entire history of the thing).
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

Dio wrote:… I ask for nothing but good stories and consistency - I think I've made that perfectly clear.
But the consistency can't be confined to a single episode, which means that there must be underlying rules and the ones shown in this episode are way too loose to be workable on a day-to-day basis.
The series managed perfectly well without consistency for its first few decades. Why is it necessary now?

1) DW 'canon' has more contradictions than the Christian bible.

2) The Doctor's meddling was character- rather than logic-based and was shown to be counter-productive (as KC pointed out earlier).

3) Christmas Special leniency rarely extends to normal episodes (aside, perhaps, in some of RTD's season finales).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Harlequin wrote:The series managed perfectly well without consistency for its first few decades. Why is it necessary now?

1) DW 'canon' has more contradictions than the Christian bible.
Small things. Mostly it holds up pretty well as far as I'm aware. Hardly made a detailed study of it in recent years, but it all kind of works - at least as well as Star Trek, Star Wars etc.
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

Dio wrote:
Harlequin wrote:1) DW 'canon' has more contradictions than the Christian bible.
Small things. Mostly it holds up pretty well as far as I'm aware. Hardly made a detailed study of it in recent years, but it all kind of works - at least as well as Star Trek, Star Wars etc.
Nah, ST was the first SF series to actually have a 'bible' to maintain consistency between stories while the second and third SW films were written to fit everything established in the first. Even in the early years of DW the writers could not agree on such basic principles as whether Daleks could negotiate stairs.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

juice wrote:There *has* to be rules and limits, as otherwise writers have nothing to work with.
Andy Diggle discussed this in a 2000AD article about scriptwriting for comics: without establishing rules and limits beforehand, the reader is free to question "but why doesn't he just $ACTION". Highlighting those limitations shows that characters are constrained to a subset of actions, decreasing their options - and increasing their peril, as it were.

I also read an interview with a games designer (I've a feeling it could have been :worship: Eugene Jarvis) who also said that gamers prefer limitations - they need to fight their way through masses of cannon-fodder with a stick. Equip them with the BFG early on in the game, and the rest of it becomes no challenge. This is partly why some Williams' games ramp up the difficulty levels exponentially, and why Blizzard added another 9 levels onto WoW, giving those level-90 bored players something else to do.

(I recently wrote an article comparing some programming languages, arguing that flexibility with syntax and relaxed standards gives the developer complete freedom to churn out code of poor quality, but rigidity in frameworks constrains the developer to only producing a limited set of solutions, increasing maintainability and code quality)
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Harlequin wrote:Even in the early years of DW the writers could not agree on such basic principles as whether Daleks could negotiate stairs.
I recall a cartoon (from many years back, could have been in Playboy) in which two Daleks examine a set of stairs and one remarks "well, that's fucked our plans for world domination!" - I was surprised to see a Dalek hover then ascend stairs in the Eccleston Who series and a viewing colleague mentioned that - from a specific season - the Daleks have been able to fly (my Who watching tailed off during the Peter Davidson era), which was news to me.

(I was always curious in "Destiny of the Daleks" how they managed to navigate rocky environments)

Deviation: I've just searched Usenet and noticed that "Kenickie" has popped up many Who eps, stretching back as far as "An Unearthly Child". I feel my pipe may start burning...
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Ollie »

In the RTD era this was all dealt with by the device that there were "fixed points in time" that couldn't be altered - the implication being that anything else could be. But then in The Waters of Mars it turned out that those fixed points could be altered as well, and there was a firm suggestion, I felt, that the last two specials were going to deal with the implications of the Doctor having done that. Which, in the event, they didn't at all - in fact in direct opposition to his apparent realisation at the end of TWoM that he's gone too far, he's been off on a jolly old romp around time, evidently unconcerned with any effects it might have on the timeline.

I found that far more of a let-down than anything Moffat has done since. There's more of a feeling of continuity now than I ever got in the RTD era, a feeling that plot threads left hanging will be picked up down the line, so for now I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt and see where he's going with things.

Having said that, he has said essentially that a Christmas Special is a thing in itself which stands somewhat apart from the rest of the series, so I wouldn't be expecting this episode to have any major implications for continuity.
Why are you breaking my kayak?
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Harlequin wrote:
Dio wrote:
Harlequin wrote:1) DW 'canon' has more contradictions than the Christian bible.
Small things. Mostly it holds up pretty well as far as I'm aware. Hardly made a detailed study of it in recent years, but it all kind of works - at least as well as Star Trek, Star Wars etc.
Nah, ST was the first SF series to actually have a 'bible' to maintain consistency between stories
Having a series bible doesn't make for consistent storytelling. It just means that when a writer writes (insert tech here) you get roughly the same kind of tech from week to week.

In about a third of ST:NG episodes you can usually ask "Why don't they fix it with the (transporter / warp drive / computer / Data) using the technique they demonstrated in episode X?" Doctor Who has generally done rather better in those respects than that - precisely because the technology is kept at a very handwavy, in-the-background level.

My suspicion is that - perhaps perversely, in some ways - a focus on storytelling with a loosely defined technology base tends to lead to a more consistent universe, particularly where the series is written by disparate writers. (I mean, JMS managed to keep things very consistent in Babylon 5, but by writing most of it himself and script editing the rest).
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:
Harlequin wrote:Even in the early years of DW the writers could not agree on such basic principles as whether Daleks could negotiate stairs.
I recall a cartoon (from many years back, could have been in Playboy) in which two Daleks examine a set of stairs and one remarks "well, that's fucked our plans for world domination!" - I was surprised to see a Dalek hover then ascend stairs in the Eccleston Who series and a viewing colleague mentioned that - from a specific season - the Daleks have been able to fly (my Who watching tailed off during the Peter Davidson era), which was news to me.
You just missed it - they started flying in the Colin Baker era:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revelation_of_the_Daleks
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by gravy »

Moffat doesn't care if it all gets mucked up by time travel
Davies' replacement, Steven Moffat declared at a convention in 2008 that, "It is impossible for a show about a dimension-hopping time traveller to have a canon."[29] Paul Cornell, who was written Doctor Who novels as well as episodes of the TV series, said "I can’t think of any other fandom that assumes they have a canon when nobody has ever told them that they do. Especially since our show itself declares that it doesn’t now have, and probably never did have, a canon.
User avatar
Governmentyard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11757
Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Governmentyard »

Harlequin wrote:
Dio wrote:
Harlequin wrote:the second and third SW films were written to fit everything established in the first
But we now know the bastard was just biding his time, don't we?
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
User avatar
betamax
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10520
Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
Location: Coalition Anxiety
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by betamax »

Dio wrote: Nah, ST was the first SF series to actually have a 'bible' to maintain consistency between stories

Having a series bible doesn't make for consistent storytelling. It just means that when a writer writes (insert tech here) you get roughly the same kind of tech from week to week.

In about a third of ST:NG episodes you can usually ask "Why don't they fix it with the (transporter / warp drive / computer / Data) using the technique they demonstrated in episode X?" Doctor Who has generally done rather better in those respects than that - precisely because the technology is kept at a very handwavy, in-the-background level.

My suspicion is that - perhaps perversely, in some ways - a focus on storytelling with a loosely defined technology base tends to lead to a more consistent universe, particularly where the series is written by disparate writers. (I mean, JMS managed to keep things very consistent in Babylon 5, but by writing most of it himself and script editing the rest).
I always interpreted the fixed points in time paradigm as being one of choice- you can, but you really, really shouldn't, because that way chaos and madness lies, like trying to create the perfect day against all the variables. You'd eventually have to eliminate all other life in the universe in order to ensure their random doings didn't potentially upset your perfect day.

I may be wrong, but didnt the Master have a penchant for trying to swipe the Tardis to accomplish just that kind of thing?
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Dio wrote:My suspicion is that - perhaps perversely, in some ways - a focus on storytelling with a loosely defined technology base tends to lead to a more consistent universe, particularly where the series is written by disparate writers. (I mean, JMS managed to keep things very consistent in Babylon 5, but by writing most of it himself and script editing the rest).
In fact - yeah, quoting myself, the first sign of madness - thinking about it, it comes down to how you resolve problems.

Star Trek regularly digs holes for itself with its technology because it uses its technology to solve big problems. Doctor Who doesn't, because technology very rarely solves big problems, only the little ones that get in the way of the plot moving quickly.

My fear, as bolded above, will be that Doctor Who will make the mistake of digging the holes for itself with time travel.
User avatar
Kelloggs
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1859
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Kelloggs »

I think I can see what you may be getting at, Dio - the "big picture" premise of Doctor Who really couldn't come about without a time travel, but the weekly episodes almost never made any use of it. The Doctor is, fundamentally, a Problem-Solver - those problems don't normally need anyone to step round-the-back of spacetime to tweak a solution into existence.

I wonder, though, if in the intervening years between "old" Doctor Who and the modern stuff, we've got more used to having our brains blended by "time-travel" plots in SF (ST:TNG's "Yesterday's Enterprise, fr.ex), and the writers now think they're comfortable enough with it that it's just another tool for them to use, much as animated/CGI mattes are employed now where only static ones could have been used before.
Post Reply