bisto chip shop curry
Re: bisto chip shop curry
There was a series of programmes on BBC2 a while ago all about food additives and one episode covered MSG. It suggested that the negative effects some people get with MSG are also found with foods that naturally contain glutamates (IIRC brocolli, parmesan and mushrooms were given as examples). So the MSG isn't the issue, just the G, and that's naturally-occurring. It sounded like it's more an allergy than anything else - some people are affected, most aren't.
Here's a link to the programme, although there's not much you can do with it. If it's repeated it's well worth a watch though. The episode on colourings was especially memorable - showing how kid's sweets were once coloured with stupidly-toxic red lead.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00tl4qk
Here's a link to the programme, although there's not much you can do with it. If it's repeated it's well worth a watch though. The episode on colourings was especially memorable - showing how kid's sweets were once coloured with stupidly-toxic red lead.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00tl4qk
- Dungeon-Dave
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3925
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: bisto chip shop curry
FTFY. In one of those articles linked by Lisor, a controlled experiment actually disproved a diner's allergy to MSG, implying that the symptoms he experienced were either psychosomatic or caused by a different ingredient.gumboot wrote:It looks to me like there's plenty of news report and theories/accusations, but no evidence proving them.
(footnote: I recall watching some programme in the states where a merkin refused to have stir-fried veg from a Chinese takeaway, citing "too much MSG" as a concern, favouring instead a burger. When pointed out to him "too much salt/sugar/fat" in the burger, he dismissed those with "nope - this is wholesome American food, not like that foreign muck". Although the character was supposed to be comically bigoted, my colleagues sadly pointed out just how prevalent this attitude is in the USA)
mmm.. I *do* fancy an indian tonight. Beef, pork or chicken... with onions, peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms... all sinking in a quagmire of Rogan Josh tomatoey bog topped with chopped coriander and spiked with red chillies... served with a side of rice flavoured lightly with lemon and cardamom.
Damn, my food porn's given me an erection now. Gnnnnnnnnnnn...
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Good lord. Just what do you think I'm trying to prove, here?Dungeon-Dave wrote:FTFY. In one of those articles linked by Lisor, a controlled experiment actually disproved a diner's allergy to MSG, implying that the symptoms he experienced were either psychosomatic or caused by a different ingredient.gumboot wrote:It looks to me like there's plenty of news report and theories/accusations, but no evidence proving them.
- Dungeon-Dave
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3925
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: bisto chip shop curry
I didn't think you were; I took your statements as an observation upon what you'd read on those links. Similarly I took your use of the word "evidence" to mean "reports", but those reports seemed based upon feeling and theories, rather than upon provable fact.gumboot wrote:Good lord. Just what do you think I'm trying to prove, here?
As ever, I could have misread you completely and can be located at a different tree, making dog-like noises. I'm still foggy from last night's tipples.
Re: bisto chip shop curry
If the evidence in this case were made out of provable fact it would, itself, simply be proof. In that case why would there be separate words for evidence and proof?Dungeon-Dave wrote:Similarly I took your use of the word "evidence" to mean "reports", but those reports seemed based upon feeling and theories, rather than upon provable fact.
Re: bisto chip shop curry
<obpedant>gumboot wrote:If the evidence in this case were made out of provable fact it would, itself, simply be proof. In that case why would there be separate words for evidence and proof?
Taking the second statement first. In English, there's 2 probable reasons why there are 2 separate words.
The first is that, due to the bastard etymology of English, there are, in fact, 2 separate words for the same thing, with differing origins (usually coming from Norman French and the pre-Norman Saxon languages, and corresponding to the "posh" and "common" definitions of things). This is far more common than it sounds (portal/gate, road/street, etc), although not the case here.
The second, of course, is that the two words do actually mean different things.
Looking at my dictionary, we have :
Evidence - "the available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid" (from Latin evidentia via Old French)
Proof - "evidence or argument establishing or helping to establish a fact or the truth of a statement" (from Latin probare via Old French)
Put succinctly, evidence may be (and hopefully is) made up of provable fact, but doesn't necessarily form a proof in itself. It may well, after all, be a provable fact that I vomited after leaving the pub (the puke on my shoes is evidence), but that doesn't prove my hypothesis that the last pint was "off".
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Would I have saved you the bother had I started that bit with <obobtuse>?tufty wrote:<obpedant>
Taking the second statement first. In English, there's 2 probable reasons why there are 2 separate words. [...]
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Given that obtuse can be taken to mean either "difficult to understand" or "slow witted", it might, but not for the reasons you'd have thought.gumboot wrote:Would I have saved you the bother had I started that bit with <obobtuse>?
[insert smiley here]
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Granted I hadn't considered the former a viable interpretation. Peculiarly, it seems to have taken that meaning upon itself rather than the facetious comment to which I had meant its second sense to be applied.tufty wrote:Given that obtuse can be taken to mean either "difficult to understand" or "slow witted", it might, but not for the reasons you'd have thought.gumboot wrote:Would I have saved you the bother had I started that bit with <obobtuse>?
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Fair enough, then.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- Dungeon-Dave
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3925
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: bisto chip shop curry
I don't know if evidence can be made out of provable fact - to my mind, interpretation of evidence is used to prove (or disprove) a theory/hypothesis/proposal. Without evidence there is no proof and the theorem still remains debatable.gumboot wrote:If the evidence in this case were made out of provable fact it would, itself, simply be proof. In that case why would there be separate words for evidence and proof?
Some examples spring to mind:
- there is evidence that a proof exists for Fermat's Last Theorem, but the evidence wasn't a proof in itself.
- evidence in the form of a controlled experiment was used to disprove someone's apparent sensitivity and allergy to MSG.
- evidence in the forms of (historical) facts and statistics is used to prove the accuracy of Met Office predictions.
In my past as a schoolteacher, I've encountered many schoolkids holding up (some) evidence, loudly proclaiming that it "proves it". Evidence can place someone at the scene of a crime and thus not rule them out, but it doesn't prove they committed the crime.
Look, perhaps I'm just being overly pedantic about the choice of terms. You probably understand this isn't just cockmanship on my part; I appreciate the way in which you persist with your view and welcome redressing any imbalance I may be causing.
Re: bisto chip shop curry
We all appear to be fully agreed on the definitions of the terms, but that only makes it more peculiar that I earned a FTFY.Dungeon-Dave wrote:Look, perhaps I'm just being overly pedantic about the choice of terms. You probably understand this isn't just cockmanship on my part; I appreciate the way in which you persist with your view and welcome redressing any imbalance I may be causing.
- Dungeon-Dave
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3925
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: bisto chip shop curry
Perhaps you may interpret the acronym as "Fucked That For You!", then! 
Re: bisto chip shop curry
So after all this pedantry - what about this curry sauce then?gumboot wrote:We all appear to be fully agreed on the definitions of the terms, but that only makes it more peculiar that I earned a FTFY.Dungeon-Dave wrote:Look, perhaps I'm just being overly pedantic about the choice of terms. You probably understand this isn't just cockmanship on my part; I appreciate the way in which you persist with your view and welcome redressing any imbalance I may be causing.



