Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:
p134 wrote:Dave Theurer and video tournament champion Eric Ginner agree that a player can always get more points by conquering his initial Platform than by gradually progressing to it by shooting and Superzapping his way through the Platforms that precede it.
Looks like utter nonsense to me. The key word in that phrase is "can" rather than "will". Which makes the answer a lot less certain than one might think if such was intended by the game to encourage people not to play earlier levels. I think it's a rather vague statement that is given more legitimacy by dropping some famous names in at the start.
That quote is not about game design, but whether a player can score more points irrespective of ability. If I asked someone who knew a game and said "If a guy came up to your game with some ability, would they in your opinion score more with a starting bonus on a higher level as opposed to playing through from the start?" then most people would answer yes to that
irrespective of game design or that one could earn more points playing well through early levels - because it's easier for some random player to win through one level and get a large bonus, rather than playing through several levels and not getting to the highest level you could start at. You could also play like a complete pudding - like for example missing all the bonus pods and not bulling in Space Giraffe which nets you many more points than just shooting stuff. So without knowing more about the player, I'd expect most people to answer yes to that one.
If someone asked me "Could you get a higher score playing to the best of your ability from the start compared to starting on Level X with bonus Y" and I can say definitely that for Tempest the answer is yes. Done it myself. Which demonstrates that the game design is obviously getting the player to accept a lower overall score through avoiding playing through lower levels. A clear risk/reward system.
Quite frankly, I'd take actual evidence playing the game myself over some single quote from an obscure reference. You could rig any question you like to get a desired simple "yes" or "no" answer depending on the factors behind the question and then write a fanciful reply around it. If both guys give the same answer, then they 'agree'. Seen it done before, many times. Tabloid journalists have managed to write entire pieces around pretty much no information at all whilst their interviewee is basically running away from them..
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."