NASA wrote:"Astronomers have pushed the Hubble Space Telescope to its limits and have seen further back in time than ever before," NASA said in an announcement posted on its website today (Jan. 21).
Here's a petition by astrologers to try to get the BBC to publicly apologise for astrology being utter nonsense. Sorry, I meant that it's to get the BBC to apologise for misrepresenting it as utter nonsense, of course:
Mark wrote:Here's a petition by astrologers to try to get the BBC to publicly apologise for astrology being utter nonsense. Sorry, I meant that it's to get the BBC to apologise for misrepresenting it as utter nonsense, of course:
Mark wrote:Here's a petition by astrologers to try to get the BBC to publicly apologise for astrology being utter nonsense. Sorry, I meant that it's to get the BBC to apologise for misrepresenting it as utter nonsense, of course:
Is there a "The BBC shouldn't apologise to astrologers for calling astrology rubbish" petition?
Given that Professor Cox had already made his views on astrology clear in "Wonders of the Solar System" and the trade description of these people - they didn't see it coming?!
He implied that astrologers believe that all the planets orbit the Sun in one year. That would mean that there's only 365 possible horoscopes - one for every day of the year - and then they repeat absolutely identically every year. This isn't true.
Carl Sagan captured it well there (as always, of course).
Astrology has developed into a truly bizarre mix, in that the astronomical side of astrology - the plotting of the positions of the planets - is actually mathematically exacting and precise. They use the same astronomical charts and data that astronomers use to know where to point their telescopes, in fact. The calculation of a horoscope is a purely mathematical exercise - and quite a complicated and precise one at that.
As Sagan notes, astrology was taken deadly seriously by kings of the past. They firmly believed in its predictive powers enough to make it an offence punishable by death to calculate a horoscope - the kings would crave this "great power" unto themselves and only themselves (well, you can imagine that if you genuinely 100% believed that this shit was really accurately telling you the future, then such a power would be absolutely fucking immense. It would be no less than god-like).
Thus, in astrology, there has been every drive forward to make the calculation of the positions of the planets ever more precise - because, after all, with more precision, surely the predictions will be more accurate, yes?
So, yes, there is this rather perverse mix in that calculating the horoscope is a precise and exacting mathematical discipline. There is a strange interaction in that whenever astronomy discovers a new object - such as Neptune, Uranus and Pluto - then astrology absorbs it without question and if astronomers create ever more precise astronomical data, then that is exactly the data astrologers use to make their calculations.
They really do earn the title "pseudo-science" in that, right up until you reach the "interpretation" phase of calculating a horoscope, it's every bit as scientific and mathematical as astronomy itself (indeed, if you were to do just that phase only and not "interpret" it at all - just calculate where the planets are and then stop - then it is astronomy).
But then, at that point, they return their core superstitious beliefs and throw all rationality out of the window, to start "interpreting" that Mars in Capricorn means this, that or the other.
Because the problem is that though astrology has had the drive to become ever more precise - the more exacting the calculations, the more accurate the prediction - they've always done so starting from that crazy core belief. They want more accuracy so that their "interpretations" are more correct.
You can imagine a chemist with a periodic table in front of him, carefully doing his experiments in the proper scientific way, with all modern knowledge and equipment - in order to discover what "the philosopher's stone" might be made of and what "mystical incantation" they need to say (whilst, no doubt, sacrificing a chicken or whatever), in order to work out how to turn lead into gold.
Someone who behaves in every way like a modern chemist, but is still, in their heart, an alchemist - firmly believing that it's only a matter of time before their chemistry work will discover the fabled magic of elemental transmutation (by non-subatomic means).
Yes, it's utterly crazy. But that's basically what astrology is.
Thus, I would hazard a guess that the astrologers making these complaints will moan along these lines - "Dara implied that astrology believes the planets all go around the Sun in a year, which is a complete misrepresentation of our beliefs. We pay our licence fee and you're obliged to be impartial and..." blah-blah-blah.
(And, strictly, in those narrow regards - that Dara did imply they believed something that they never have and that this is a misrepresentation of astrology on a public broadcaster that is legally obliged to be impartial - they'll have a case to piss and moan at the BBC with.)
Also, I'm pretty sure that Brian Cox noticed Dara's mistake and that's why he started with "in the interests of balance, I should point out..." and then thought "fuck it" - it's a live show, they've got lots to get through and they can't waste precious astronomy time trying to explain all this nonsense (particularly when, ultimately, Dara's conclusion - that it's all complete bullshit - is entirely on the money, even if he got his astrology facts wrong) - so he made an on-the-spot presenter's decision to just say "...that astrology is, indeed, bullshit".
And, yes, astrology is bullshit. No question.
But Dara was strictly wrong to imply that it's bullshit because astrologers don't know how the planets orbit properly. It's bullshit because their core belief - that you can predict the future from mapping where the planets are - is superstitious nonsense.
From the way he did it, I suspect that Brian was actually going to issue that correction - but then thought better of it, because he couldn't be fucking arsed to "provide balance" for a bullshit belief. Which is a decision I entirely understand and completely support.
It was an astronomy show, not a show to be apologetic for beliefs you know are bullshit - and doing so would have got in the fucking way of the astronomy. Right decision, in my view. But, yes, in respect of the rules that the BBC must be impartial and "provide balance" and all that bollocks, Dara unintentionally dumped Brian in the shit there.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
I don't get all the snoot by the so-called rationalists. It's not as if the population at large regards their daily sun sign forecast as science. Are the beeb going to broadcast that Judeo-Christianity/Islam is bullshit? Not a chance, much as you might wish it. So, essentially, it comes down to the size and threat of the insulted as to whether respect is granted.
Mr Sagan got a mention. He also refused to sign on with a condemnation of astrology issued by American humanists... thought it was too authoritarian.
Absolute_Zero wrote:I don't get all the snoot by the so-called rationalists. It's not as if the population at large regards their daily sun sign forecast as science. Are the beeb going to broadcast that Judeo-Christianity/Islam is bullshit? Not a chance, much as you might wish it. So, essentially, it comes down to the size and threat of the insulted as to whether respect is granted.
Mr Sagan got a mention. He also refused to sign on with a condemnation of astrology issued by American humanists... thought it was too authoritarian.
Precisely. Astrology provides no more or less an explanaton of reality than Christianity, Islam, Judaism or any other religion for that matter - yet you won't hear the BBC saying that will you ? Spot on.
Astrology, somewhat to its credit, is a lot easier disproven then anything based on "things that happened long ago by a big man in the sky" - because it is attempting to make predictions rather then explain our existence. Most religions don't do that. At least, not so explicitly.
In fact, I don't think astrology is even trying to explain our existence is it? Doesn't seem desperate to fill in all the gaps, more just add some magic sprinkles to our mundane life.
That said, I don't see anything wrong with chipping away at a any nonsense belief if its especially vulnerable. Some people DO believe this stuff, and Id hope that is a shrinking number.
Condemn this nonsense as much as possible - why should it mater that its "more vulnerable". Nonsense beliefs shouldn't be treated like some endangered species to be protected. If its more easier to attack, then attack it. Kill it as much as possible so the next generation can be free.
Its worth pointing out that many astrology columns in national newspapers run premium rate phonelines; in fact many of them now encourage people to call to get their horoscope completed. Now, it can be argued that its up to the individual what they decide to spend their money on (Ben Goldacre regards this sort of thing as "a voluntary tax on stupidity") but consider what charities might do with equivalent donations. Professor Cox (him again!) has also pointed out that more is spent on ringtones than on the whole of nuclear fusion research...