Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Nostalgia ain't what it used to be...
Post Reply
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by RiK »

phattslagg wrote:It seems pretty clear that any feedback that isn't all-out praise gets taken as some sort of personal attack. I'm not one for walking on eggshells, and I have enough experience in the field of software testing to know that developers don't benefit much from arse-licking - they need to hear it straight.
There is however a huge difference between hearing and listening..
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by gilesgoat »

RiK wrote:
Yak wrote:And guess what? I bet people will moan about THAT too...
Jeff, you really need to try and refrain from referring to all user feedback as 'moaning'. It comes across as pretty disrespectful to the opinion of the users, who are after all also the paying customers. These guys on here are your core fans and as such they are already biased in your favour so surely it makes sense to listen to what they have to say with an open mind? Chances are there are many more people out there sharing a similar opinion but who aren't members on here and hence not providing any feedback rather than how they may or may not make a decision to purchase your next release.
There's a standard way to deal with this.

The standard way is :

"We thank you for the time you took us for sending your opinions, your feedback is very important to us, we'll take it into consideration and we'll use it for our next release."

Which, is true even in our case, except that here tends to get 'a bit too personal' about things and can slip off easily.

This is why there's "company formal communication" but we are the most informal thing in the world, this is also why, normally, "the end user" will never ever get in touch with "the lab" if not through some very well prepared "forms" and things and such.

The thing anyway is "a two way thing", fans/etc. that "want to be DIRECTLY" in touch with "the developer" and knows "everything that goes on" HAS TO BE READY to take 'the good and the bad', you are talking to a PERSON, NOT "a company image" not "one of those thingies I could be a master - having some years of experience as well more than what you could believe - in writing you back what it would be more convenient for anyone to read".

But you are talking to Jeff, with "goods and bads" and ( strong ) personal opinions/feelings about its creations, you want to talk to a person, you get the person, including what could be a good day, a bad day, a good feedback, a bad feedback and such.

If you want to be "pampered all time" that's very easy to be done, actually is easier than giving you "what a person really thinks about".

You are already well screened anyway, there's so much going into my personal life other than begin here reading this forum and writing things about you have no idea and nobody needs to know, I could tell you there has been days I was struggling to just be on this chair writing code let alone hear negative feedback on something that tooks me weeks to make - even if this feedback could have some reason to be - and doing my fucking best not to project my problems on anyone else.

There's lot more than meets the eye but I am not going to put in on the internet or out of this place for any matter, when you deal with persons, life is not so rose tinted every day as it could seem it is or it would be and really is for no one else to know.

Anyway, this feedback, even if the replies to it could be well off what you'd expect them to be is here, we look at it, some of it we take it, some of it we decide "yes but we still want to do different", if you expect that "all the time" "I give you feedback and things are going to change according to it", well this will never happen 100%, it could happen to some extents but it will never happen completely we can agree with some of it, we can disagree as well.

But on the other side you give "a better look" about "what we really are", it should also give you an even better feeling that "we do what we want to do because we love it to do not because we want to make out the highest possible profit for it".

If all this would be profit only based, I can tell you STRAIGHT ON, I would be out of all this doing another job, there are jobs I can make more money out of them even if of course the context would be all different, we are not here for the money only nor to make 'the most succesfull selling game or beloved game in the history'.

If it happens to be, it's luck, it's a bonus, it's a nice thing to happen .. but we are not pushing everything spending time studying "the impossible of everything and all what people likes or not like" for it to be.

Did Leonardo think "I am going to make the best painting in the world ?" when he's done the Monna Lisa ? No, he just wanted to make a painting he liked to make it that way according to what for himself was his best.

You make a game because you have "a vision" of what you wish it to be, an idea that turns into something that exists, it's a real shame that this idea has to make some profit, it would be lot better if it would not have to make any profit at all.

But anyway, that's what you get for dealing with persons, "real feelings", "real emotions", not "company talk".

Anyway I personally agree that "feedback should be a drop box with no reply to it" .. I mean "you put it there, you KNOW we WILL look at it, but NOBODY comments on it".

Anyway remember, you are talking directly to Jeff that between a post and a comment and another is typing bytes at the KB ( and so me ) .. you really can't get better than that, there's no better than that, there's better crafted communication maybe but certainly "never so straight out from the ox's mouth" :mrgreen:

Company talk :

"I don't like your UI" -> "Thanks for your letter, your feedback is very important to us".

Direct developer talk :

"I don't like your UI" -> "WHAT ? FUCK ! WHO SAYS THAT ?" :lol: :lol: :lol:

( 20 mins later )

"But now .. but see .. but they say .. but listen .. but maybe .. "

"Fucking weeks for that shit and that crap of thing and the bloody problem and I knew they were saying and FFS and argh bloody hell can't they understand what a button is for and ... we never get it right arrgh .. I WANT MY PLUSHIES ! ( goes to cry in a corner ) .. "

( 1 hour later )

"Maybe we could change something in the next release .. "

Making SW is war .. :mrgreen:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Yak »

phattslagg wrote: It seems pretty clear that any feedback that isn't all-out praise gets taken as some sort of personal attack
Nonsense. We listen to what people say about the game and where things are genuinely annoying people we will address those issues in some future update, just as we did with Minotaur Rescue.

However with limited resources and time it behooves us to focus on stuff that is genuinely relevant. You said that something would cause people to vote 1 and leave bad feedback and I just pointed out that that hasn't in fact happened. And as for ensuring people get to see the instructions I mentioned that in the next game they will be compelled to look at the instructions first, thereby avoiding that issue.

And yes, some people WILL moan about being compelled to do a tutorial mode, simply because with the best will in the world you can't satisfy everybody and what is one person's helpful intro is another person's annoying intrusion. There IS no way to satisfy everypony.

Listening to the broad consensus is common sense. Debating minutiae with individuals is perhaps not so sensible, especially when actually debating the issues is perceived as being some kind of attack.

We do appreciate feedback, we do take notice, and we do update stuff accordingly when we can, and take note of it when planning new releases. But at this point I think it's better for me to be talking to my compiler than discussing details in here.
Justified and Ancient.
matt
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14826
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 4:07 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: gingerbeardman
PSN: wirehang
Location: here && there
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by matt »

Yak wrote:Erm well in that case how come the Mino Rescue entry in the app shore shows 44 5-ratings, 3 4-ratings and one 1-rating?
My response to this would be to ask if you're happy with less than 50 ratings in total? Personally I wouldn't rest until my game had hundreds of reviews. More so with a game as good as Minotron!

Everybody here would like to see these games enjoyed by a wider demographic, which is why we're suggesting ways in which you might be able to secure a wider user base. These suggestions are to improve the first time play of the Minotaur Project games: making them more approachable. Info about game control & objectives should be front and centre. It needs to be more obvious to users that are perhaps not as accustomed to rooting around old-school interfaces to find that information.

So, a summary of changes I would suggest:
- on first play force user to read an abridged one screen summary of game controls & objective
- add that same controls & objective text to the App Store entry
- add a border to all buttons to make them look like buttons
- add a button to display the expanded (attract mode) game controls & objective to the info page

I'm thinking those changes would take less than an hour.

What do you think?

matt
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Yak »

Well it's only been out a week; it's not like it's going to have that number of reviews forever. Not everyone who buys puts a review; ~50 in a week isn't too bad, especially when most of them are excellent.

We will look at what people are saying about the games and any significant issues will be addressed in the next round of updates. I don't believe in machinegunning updates out for tiny little changes; for us it seems a lot more natural to do updates between game releases so that each is significant and worth the download, and that timescale gives us a better idea of what the most important issues are for most people.
Justified and Ancient.
matt
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14826
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 4:07 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: gingerbeardman
PSN: wirehang
Location: here && there
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by matt »

Any idea how many out of the 50 are from people other than "us"/yakyak?
BillyT
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 77
Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2009 1:17 pm 0

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by BillyT »

The feedback system is very important on the App Store to the developer and fans...

My experience of this is that if most users complain or suggest things on universal ideas - lots of people want the same things... With the game I was involved with we listened to the consensus and implemented these requests in the updates we released through out last year. Some we did not do but had plans to do them on the sequel.

The fans really liked this and said nice things to their friends about the game and their friends bought the game - if the fans of the game see a game updated frequently they feel the developer cares. And will likely invest their money in the next product.

There are tonnes of developers who just release and never update and never listen to their fans, usually these games sink like a lead ballon and the developer gets a bad rap by the public. It actually pays to listen and update because the buyers of the game feel like they are getting a service.

EA have a bad rep on the App Store - they very rarely update their games. They are a big company and have the money clout to ignore the user input because users will buy the games anyway. But for the independents to ignore user feedback can backfire and do more damage than good.

One thing I wish the App Store would allow is to let developers to reply to the reviews.
Kriv
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:40 pm 0

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Kriv »

Is there a quicker way to resume last best?

Really trying to crack level 93. After being incapacitated get the dying wail then frantically tapping the screen in the bottom right for 5 seconds to resume. When in the heat of the moment just want to get that one more go. Perhaps tapping the left or right corner 3 times in quick succession will skip though the game over / wail and quickly get back in game.
"It's like a stereogram. For ages all you see are shitty dots then suddenly BAM you get it."

"I mean...wtf is with that generic man/baby's face on the background?" "It's my face dammit. My beautiful face." - J Allard
User avatar
axel000
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
PSN: huckwee
Location: Philadelphia, USA

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by axel000 »

Maybe have a shake motion to restart ? heh give it an etch-a-sketch effect :D
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by RiK »

Kriv wrote:Is there a quicker way to resume last best?

Really trying to crack level 93. After being incapacitated get the dying wail then frantically tapping the screen in the bottom right for 5 seconds to resume. When in the heat of the moment just want to get that one more go. Perhaps tapping the left or right corner 3 times in quick succession will skip though the game over / wail and quickly get back in game.
Nice to know I'm not the only one then...

Beginning to think that I was single-handedly taking over the reigns of the axis of evil..
User avatar
Jedburgh
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5904
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:50 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: dariusjedburgh23
Location: Uncanny Valley

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Jedburgh »

Easy. You get enough time after losing your final life and before game over to pause, quit and then tappity-tap your way to a restart within a second or two. Becomes second nature very quickly.
Jedburgh

It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
Kriv
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:40 pm 0

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Kriv »

RiK wrote:
Beginning to think that I was single-handedly taking over the reigns of the axis of evil..
No, no... you still are ;)

@Jedburgh
Yeah, that's not so bad on an iPhone, but on a pad (and this will sound absurd) you have to move your hands due to the screen real estate. It would be nice to have something in the thumb arc area. I'm guessing having palm of the hands nestled in the corners of the pad is quite common. Not a game breaker, just a nice to have.
"It's like a stereogram. For ages all you see are shitty dots then suddenly BAM you get it."

"I mean...wtf is with that generic man/baby's face on the background?" "It's my face dammit. My beautiful face." - J Allard
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Jamesac »

This may be an unworkable idea, but-

How To Play button that starts the attract mode going? Exit button unobtrusively off to the side while it runs. Hitting Exit goes back to the main menu, of course, while hitting anywhere else makes the attract mode go quadruple-time for those wanting to get to a specific part for clarification.

Good idea/dumb idea?

James
Longshot
Posts: 2
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 10:04 am 0

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Longshot »

Hi everyone,

Found a bug with level 32 of minotron. You can get yourself into a situation where you get killed by an ever fattening tea-cup, with no hope of of survival -
http://gallery.me.com/gilmanbrian#100016

Basically happens when you are fully powered up. The work around is to kill the teacup before it gets so large that it never comes out of its pain state.

Other feedback -

So far I'm really enjoying the game, but I'm having a hard time getting used to the controls. With Minotaur Rescue, the controls felt weird at first, but eventually, after an hour or two of play, they felt absolutely perfect( well, as good as you can get on a touch screen anyway ).

With Minotron, the controls felt weird at first, but many hours of play later, they still feel weird. I think I might prefer having the option to use boring, not great but useable, virtual thumbsticks.

Have a good one,
Brian
Kriv
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:40 pm 0

Re: Minotaur Project #2 - Minotron

Post by Kriv »

Aye longshot. Mentioned that on the other forum.
"It's like a stereogram. For ages all you see are shitty dots then suddenly BAM you get it."

"I mean...wtf is with that generic man/baby's face on the background?" "It's my face dammit. My beautiful face." - J Allard
Post Reply