gilesgoat wrote:
Ok "technically" I think the whole MLP idea was born as a way for Hasbro to sell their toys, in fact I don't know if Hasbro actually makes any profit ( if not 'indirectly' ) from the show itself.
The show will just be a cost to them, like an advert and more than likely come out of the marketing budget.
MLP is co-produced by Hasbro and aired on a channel called The Hub which is co-owned by Hasbro.
There's obviously big and vociferous adult following for the show. It absolutely wouldn't surprise if despite moaning about the poor quality of Pony merch loads of the Bronies still buy it.
What I don't know at all is how many young girls watch the show and if it really is a failure at capturing that market. I just don't know and you're probably being a bit presumptuous saying it's failed on that basis.
In other news the original creator has quit the show. How that affects season 2 will be interesting, if they continue interacting with the adult fans or change its focus to kids.
It's really interesting from the point of view how something can be co-opted by internet fandom and that feeling of ownership be successfully embraced by the creators. But again, really not my cup of tea
gilesgoat wrote:I wonder how much someone could be happy of any ceo/whatever that actually let a big opportunity slipped out of his/her hands when it was there with the "we already made 2 bn" excuse

it's called opportunity cost. You only have finite resources to apply. If you spend time and effort on MLP at the expense of something more lucrative that'd be a mistake. That's often the reason why big companies don't do things.