The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
Your first paragraph... indeed... I failed to add that to my brief musing on things. It said she did it, but it may not actually be...
As for Mels, I suspect that she was incarnation two, and River Song was three. Although you're right, it could have been anywhere along the line. She mentioned it was happening again like when she was a little girl in New York. The time we saw previous. Which either means it's mentioned because it's the only regeneration we've seen her have, or it's the only one she's actually had to date.
As for Mels, I suspect that she was incarnation two, and River Song was three. Although you're right, it could have been anywhere along the line. She mentioned it was happening again like when she was a little girl in New York. The time we saw previous. Which either means it's mentioned because it's the only regeneration we've seen her have, or it's the only one she's actually had to date.
Lie with passion and be forever damned...
Xbox: Mayhem64
Xbox: Mayhem64
Re: The Dr Who thread
The regeneration limit was ret-conned in the SJ adventures. The Doctors says he has 500 odd regenerationsMayhem wrote:That was a bit... well... interesting. Although I guessed both twists thatbut does that mean if River has done what she did, the Doctor now has another 10 regens to work with?Spoiler: show
Here comes the Crimson Chin!
Re: The Dr Who thread
Possible but doubtful, given the nature of her conditioning, and the fact that this was clearly the first time she'd met the Doctor.xav wrote: As soon as she regenerated from Mels in to River it was clear that either this was her last regeneration, or that she would have to lose any remaining regenerations at some point prior to her death in the library. All we know is that she used up "her remaining regenerations" but it wasn't made explicit how many she had left at that point. That leaves a whole lot of scope for bumping into earlier versions of her in later episodes.
Finally watched the show today and came away with very mixed feelings. The Hitler scenes were entertaining and the final scenes worked surprisingly well, but the start of the show would easily win a "The Most Contrived Introduction of a New Character" award. In fact, most of the plotline felt contrived, to the point that the entire thing felt like a throwback to the RTD era - and it wasn't helped that much of the show's budget looks to have gone on the CGI for the robot and the regenerations, as the physical special effects (e.g. the antibodies and the wristbands) had a very distinct produced-on-a-shoestring-budget feel.
C'est la vie...
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
Re: The Dr Who thread
Actually I that's a deliberate hallmark of the Moffett series, particularly this one. It's a nod to Old Who. He tries to get a good endlessly-reshot corridor into a lot of the episodes as well.juice wrote:the physical special effects (e.g. the antibodies and the wristbands) had a very distinct produced-on-a-shoestring-budget feel.
- Jedburgh
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5904
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:50 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: dariusjedburgh23
- Location: Uncanny Valley
Re: The Dr Who thread
Why couldn't he regenerate? Why?
Jedburgh
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
It's all about trying to work out what the fuck is going on.
Re: The Dr Who thread
On reflection, there only two things I didnt like about the episode were;
and
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
This is pretty huge, since the 12- regen limit is a fundamental Time Lord principal. Link to a plot synopsis in SJA for those of us who tried to like it, but gave up after a few episodes because it was just too child-targeted, even though SJ was and always will be our ultimate companion-pin-up?mightyzim wrote:The regeneration limit was ret-conned in the SJ adventures. The Doctors says he has 500 odd regenerationsMayhem wrote:That was a bit... well... interesting. Although I guessed both twists thatbut does that mean if River has done what she did, the Doctor now has another 10 regens to work with?Spoiler: show
Re: The Dr Who thread
Thing is, in two actors time, its unlikely this will be in recent memory enough for an explanation of that.
I hope its covered, but not sure they will use this innocident.
Besides, if regenerations can be exchanged, whats to stop the Doctor giving some back to her?
I hope its covered, but not sure they will use this innocident.
Besides, if regenerations can be exchanged, whats to stop the Doctor giving some back to her?
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
What happened in SJA was a throwaway line from RTD. He even admitted it in an interview that he wasn't serious about it given the limit of 12 was well established. The media storm that followed was basically a lot of fuss about something made up on a whim changing something else that was made up that was older.Istar wrote:This is pretty huge, since the 12- regen limit is a fundamental Time Lord principal. Link to a plot synopsis in SJA for those of us who tried to like it, but gave up after a few episodes because it was just too child-targeted, even though SJ was and always will be our ultimate companion-pin-up?mightyzim wrote:The regeneration limit was ret-conned in the SJ adventures. The Doctors says he has 500 odd regenerationsMayhem wrote:That was a bit... well... interesting. Although I guessed both twists thatbut does that mean if River has done what she did, the Doctor now has another 10 regens to work with?Spoiler: show
Plus the Master used all 12 of his up. He was forced to seek alternative means to continue his existence, and seemed to get an additional cycle of 12 in exchange for his help in the Time War. So there's various non "arbitrarily increasing the number" means to continuing the Doctor's lineage. Perhaps he might have a son?
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
Re: The Dr Who thread
I thought the Doctor's regeneration comment in SJA was pretty much accepted as a joke, or a convenient lie; i.e., he was asked how many he had, he didn't want to get into how close he is to the last one, so he just pulled a random large number out of the air.
Why are you breaking my kayak?
Re: The Dr Who thread
Rule One.mightyzim wrote:The regeneration limit was ret-conned in the SJ adventures. The Doctors says he has 500 odd regenerationsMayhem wrote:That was a bit... well... interesting. Although I guessed both twists thatbut does that mean if River has done what she did, the Doctor now has another 10 regens to work with?Spoiler: show
I assume the not-being-able-regenerate was an effect of the poison...
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: The Dr Who thread
But, see my answer above.Istar wrote:This is pretty huge, since the 12- regen limit is a fundamental Time Lord principal.
Wouldn't the easiest and coolest thing to do - far more sensible than actually trying to plot it, in 5-10 years time or whenever - just be to have the Doctor as confused about it as everyone else? It can be handwaved away in the short term with "After everything you've been through, are you really surprised your body's lost count?" They can explore it further in the future if necessary.
It would also add a bit more edge to proceedings, if the Doctor has no idea whether he's run out of regenerations or not. Self-sacrifice becomes a riskier option.
Re: The Dr Who thread
That doesnt make sense - surely knowing your reaching your limit is worse then "maybe I have more due to unexplained timey-wimmy stuff".
Not knowing is only riskier if the alternative is your at the start, not the end.
nah, when the time comes it should be a big thing of some sort - any fix too easy makes his previous sacrifices a bit meaningless.
Not knowing is only riskier if the alternative is your at the start, not the end.
nah, when the time comes it should be a big thing of some sort - any fix too easy makes his previous sacrifices a bit meaningless.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
While any fix not handwaved away will be irrelevant to all but thirty-five Doctor Who spods.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Hmm - I had that pegged as being intentional. What we were watching there was "Mels" effectively retconning herself into Amy and Rory's lives, Dawn Summers style only with more timey-wimey and less sorcery.juice wrote:but the start of the show would easily win a "The Most Contrived Introduction of a New Character" award.
"even had I suspected then the truly horrifying suffering and amazing loss of life that would be caused by our well-meaning enterprise... I'd have done it anyway. Only more so."
Lagertron for Android It's Robotron at the pub!
My stuff
Lagertron for Android It's Robotron at the pub!
My stuff






