I just think given the 50 years they've had they'd have tried it again if it worked. NASA is always pleading poverty but their number one cost is getting things into orbit. All the things they've tried since you'd think they'd retry using a cannon if had any hope of saving money.Darkflame wrote:Maybe it is possible, and they know, so people are now trying to do it?
Saying "it hasnt been done so it cant be" is very close to saying "everything that can be invented has been"
I suspect the problem is it's fine lobbing shells and shell-like things into the upper atmosphere. We could cram hardened electronics into a shell and probably launch that. But to reach orbit you need to fire not just a shell but a rocket, which is suddenly much more massive, requiring explosions that would make even the building damaging quakes of HARP seem small. The size of the explosion might be such that it requires more fuel than that saved by giving the rocket a kick-start. And the rocket is no smaller than before as it needs less fuel but needs reinforcing like a tank or bomb-shelter to survive the explosive launch.
A last objection is you could maybe send up well protected solid state circuitry but solar panels? radio antennae or dishes? optics? science experiments? The only thing I can think you could send this way would be raw materials and supplies, e.g. for the ISS or some future project. Any thing else with parts like the above for comms or to do its job would be wrecked.







