Unusual units of speed?

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by Absolute_Zero »

Misconceptions seemingly abound.

Photons can ONLY exist/travel at 'c'. Appearances to the contrary are due to absorption and re-emission by the atoms of the medium.

Is an emitted photon in this situation the same entity that was absorbed? Hardly.

A link from gOOgle...
http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/0 ... sal-speed/
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by zip accident »

Absolute_Zero wrote:Misconceptions seemingly abound.

Photons can ONLY exist/travel at 'c'. Appearances to the contrary are due to absorption and re-emission by the atoms of the medium.

Is an emitted photon in this situation the same entity that was absorbed? Hardly.

A link from gOOgle...
http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/0 ... sal-speed/
The text at that link really, really sounds like bullshit, as in making plausible stuff up to make others look silly when they believe you. I don't know enough about light to say it isn't true, but it isn't how I think of other waves behaving.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by Absolute_Zero »

zip accident wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:Misconceptions seemingly abound.

Photons can ONLY exist/travel at 'c'. Appearances to the contrary are due to absorption and re-emission by the atoms of the medium.

Is an emitted photon in this situation the same entity that was absorbed? Hardly.

A link from gOOgle...
http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/0 ... sal-speed/
The text at that link really, really sounds like bullshit, as in making plausible stuff up to make others look silly when they believe you. I don't know enough about light to say it isn't true, but it isn't how I think of other waves behaving.
Try another link then...
http://www.physlink.com/education/askexperts/ae23.cfm
In a medium other than a vacuum, light propagates by a cascade of interactions with the molecules or atoms that make up the medium. Photons, the 'particles' of light, are absorbed and re-radiated (by atoms or molecules), absorbed again and re-radiated again, and over-and-over as they pass through the medium.

Since each absorption and re-radiation interaction takes time, though it be very little, the cascade cannot travel as fast through a material medium as light can in a vacuum. Light travelling in a vacuum does not have to 'waste time' being repeatedly absorbed and re-radiated. For this reason, the speed of light in a material medium is generally less than c, and will exhibit a specific value that depends upon the characteristics of the medium.

Since a vacuum exists between the atoms or molecules of a material medium, the speed of light between absorption and re-radiation sites is still c. It is the interactions that cause the overall speed through a material medium to differ from the standard value c in vacuum.

Clearly, the speed of light in a vacuum is, in a sense, more 'fundamental' than the speed of light through any particular material medium. For this reason, the speed of light is usually quoted in vacuum. It is also much more convenient for reference purposes to quote the speed of light in a vacuum where the details of the medium, which may not be reproducible to sufficient accuracy from laboratory-to-laboratory, do not have to be considered or dealt with.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by zip accident »

Absolute_Zero wrote:Try another link then...
http://www.physlink.com/education/askexperts/ae23.cfm
Since a vacuum exists between the atoms or molecules of a material medium,
In this text, this is the bit that gives me trouble.

It is not true.

If it was true, pressure would cause the surrounding medium to rush to fill the gap. There are fields between the atoms of a medium, it is the fields on which the light is transmitted, the idea that it ever travels at c within a medium is probably bogus.

There is not a complete vacuum in interstellar space, and in most of intergalactic space the vacuum is not complete either, the density goes down to one particle of hydrogen per cm^3, but there is still matter there. What if in one of the great intergalactic voids there was an area with no matter at all, could light cross that?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by pogo »

It's not just that the speed of light in a vacuum is more 'fundamental'. It's mostly that c is pretty accurate for most uses. E.g. see here

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_refractive_indices

The refractive index, so the amount of slowdown, of air is 1.000277. That is it's so close to no difference that even a well equipped school or college would find it difficult to detect. For all practical purposes the speed of light in vacuum and air are the same. It travels more slowly in solids and liquids like glass and water, but they are over such short distances that the travel is instantaneous, and the speed difference is only of interest because of the refractive effects that are due to it. Whenever you want to use the speed to e.g. deduce a distance based on time of flight then c will do.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by Absolute_Zero »

zip accident wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:Try another link then...
http://www.physlink.com/education/askexperts/ae23.cfm
Since a vacuum exists between the atoms or molecules of a material medium,
In this text, this is the bit that gives me trouble.

It is not true.

If it was true, pressure would cause the surrounding medium to rush to fill the gap. There are fields between the atoms of a medium, it is the fields on which the light is transmitted, the idea that it ever travels at c within a medium is probably bogus.

There is not a complete vacuum in interstellar space, and in most of intergalactic space the vacuum is not complete either, the density goes down to one particle of hydrogen per cm^3, but there is still matter there. What if in one of the great intergalactic voids there was an area with no matter at all, could light cross that?
I'll happily admit that the explanations proffered thus far are 'lite' and incomplete... 'wrong' even, but your concerns became unfashionable in the century before the previous. I don't know where to start beyond: 8O

If you want a 'better explanation' (albeit itself naive), try the Physics Forums FAQ re light speed in a solid... it's still about the appearance of a slowdown due to absorption and re-emission, though.
http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=511177
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by zip accident »

Absolute_Zero wrote:your concerns became unfashionable in the century before the previous. I don't know where to start beyond: 8O
Now you're being silly. They didn't believe in fields between atoms, when they believed in atoms, in the 1800s.

The point is that in solids, there are no volumes that are free of the fields between the atoms (unless there are bubbles, and even then, they will have gas in them, not vacuum), so if it's a matter of transmission and retransmission between fields, then there will be no time when the photon is not in a state of transit across a field.
If you want a 'better explanation' (albeit itself naive), try the Physics Forums FAQ re light speed in a solid... it's still about the appearance of a slowdown due to absorption and re-emission, though.
http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=511177
That is a bit better but it still ends up going for that emission re-emission route in the end.

There are loads of jokers on the internet, and I don't know enough about the sites you linked to say they aren't all jokers (or dupes).
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by Absolute_Zero »

zip accident wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:your concerns became unfashionable in the century before the previous. I don't know where to start beyond: 8O
Now you're being silly.
You seemed to be advocating for aether. Did you consider solids when you wrote:
zip wrote:If it was true [vacuum in the spaces between atoms], pressure would cause the surrounding medium to rush to fill the gap.
Since the definition of vacuum is simply space sans matter... the (relatively huge) spaces between atoms in a solid can be safely regarded as vacuum.
They didn't believe in fields between atoms, when they believed in atoms, in the 1800s.

The point is that in solids, there are no volumes that are free of the fields between the atoms (unless there are bubbles, and even then, they will have gas in them, not vacuum), so if it's a matter of transmission and retransmission between fields, then there will be no time when the photon is not in a state of transit across a field.
If you want a 'better explanation' (albeit itself naive), try the Physics Forums FAQ re light speed in a solid... it's still about the appearance of a slowdown due to absorption and re-emission, though.
http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=511177
That is a bit better but it still ends up going for that emission re-emission route in the end.
Shucks, maybe it's 'true'.
There are loads of jokers on the internet, and I don't know enough about the sites you linked to say they aren't all jokers (or dupes).
:lol: it's a conspiracy.

wikipedia has hundreds of reference and external links to physicsforums.com
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Unusual units of speed?

Post by zip accident »

Absolute_Zero wrote:You seemed to be advocating for aether.
No.
Did you consider solids when you wrote:
zip wrote:If it was true [vacuum in the spaces between atoms], pressure would cause the surrounding medium to rush to fill the gap.
Yes.

The space between atoms being "empty" is only a valid way of looking at things if you imagine atoms to be ping-pong balls, which isn't a good analogy.
Since the definition of vacuum is simply space sans matter... the (relatively huge) spaces between atoms in a solid can be safely regarded as vacuum.
No, that's not the case, vacuum is space sans matter or pressure. Have you seen a can filled with water vapour? The can is a solid containing a gas, but air pressure reduces it to a very much smaller space when the water condenses.
They didn't believe in fields between atoms, when they believed in atoms, in the 1800s.

The point is that in solids, there are no volumes that are free of the fields between the atoms (unless there are bubbles, and even then, they will have gas in them, not vacuum), so if it's a matter of transmission and retransmission between fields, then there will be no time when the photon is not in a state of transit across a field.
If you want a 'better explanation' (albeit itself naive), try the Physics Forums FAQ re light speed in a solid... it's still about the appearance of a slowdown due to absorption and re-emission, though.
http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=511177
That is a bit better but it still ends up going for that emission re-emission route in the end.
Shucks, maybe it's 'true'.
On this forum at this time, there's you for it, and me against. That's not a huge majority. I'm not saying that there isn't a bit of that going on, but the bit about light going through a medium by stopping for a bit, going at c for a bit, then stopping again for a very short time, sounds to me like the worst sort of rubbish.
There are loads of jokers on the internet, and I don't know enough about the sites you linked to say they aren't all jokers (or dupes).
:lol: it's a conspiracy.
You haven't proved it isn't. Which would actually be an impossibility, so don't worry about it.
wikipedia has hundreds of reference and external links to physicsforums.com
You didn't link to Wikipedia, and that itself is by no means respected, some here regard it as completely unreliable because it places so much reliance on external references that may in fact turn out to be circular references to it's own bogus statements.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Post Reply