Indeed. Well within acceptable parameters. As with all women ever, not being orange skinned does her the power of good. It would be churlish of me to criticise Karen Gillen in the show as she's utterly gorgeous and I have enjoyed every moment, but a more likeable character played by a more capable actress could be a revelation.RiK wrote:Works for me!
As companions have gone so far, Rose and Donna were characters one is entirely likely to come across in everyday life, which is sort of the point of companions - stand them next to the most human and British of extraterrestrials and make him look alien where necessary. Martha was a reasonable idea, a doctor with the Doctor, but we never adored her and her family were shockingly bad, while Amy Pond is a retcon device for River Song and an accident of the events occurring around the Doctor, affected as she is at such a young age. Hers is tragic story and a dysfunctional character, for all the strength she shows. Rory got the humanity in that deal, it's him we relate to and through whose eyes we can look at the Doctor. Still, it has worked more than well enough for me.... and Moffat's threat to end the Pond's arc with more tragedy might not out-RTD RTD after all.
I think this new miss will be more Donna or Rose than not. She certainly ought to be. As the companion will seemingly always be 'totty' and as a normal, filthy 35-year old, I would simplify the difference thus: a good companion like Rose or Donna you just have a feeling you'd like to know them, a badly-drawn one like Amy Pond one simply sits there trying to decide which specific acts of depravity to perpetrate upon their fantasy willing self. It's a fairly crass way of looking at it, but then it's crass to always cast utter saucepots in the role.









