Darkflame wrote:I know - as I said, all for aesthetics,
Aesthetics is about beauty, this would be about money, and the price people will pay for rare stuff.
and all would be a stupid waste of resources to get vs stuff that can actually help us make stuff on earth that, well, does stuff and helps us both progress and survive.
I agree, but that's what economics is about, money.
Besides, I think the market for resources need to make, say, mobile phones and computers, is probably far far greater then the market for "large big pretty rocks" even if as a individual item they are more expensive.
If there was, say, 10 asteroids with insanely large diamonds, vs 10 with more practical materials, I think the economics would point to mining the second as you wouldn't be able to maintain the price on diamonds for very long. Remember we could be talking about really large quantities here.
Only because of the diminished rarity value.
zip accident wrote:
Even so, I don't think we will go to space for minerals, we will go to space because in space there can be quadrillions of humans and quasi-humans, while on Earth we are running out of resources with just billions.
What are minerals if not a resource we are running out of

Yeah, but there are other resources we are running out of faster, cool temperatures, food, drinking water, clean air etc..
It certainly is a survival question in the long term. Both in terms of off-site-backup, as well as the materials we need to survive.
I think the off-site backup far outranks the materials that might be out there.
We probably need to invent some plants that can live in space. That's not impossible, there's light, and gases are containable if you don't put the pressure too high (one Earth surface atmosphere pressure is probably too high).
assuming there isn't anything there already
But yes, that does seem a good idea.
We know there isn't anything there already, we'd see them. I'm talking about plants, maybe trees, living wild in freefall in space. They would need to be able to get minerals from asteroids, and water from comets. They would need to be able to use light sails to stay away from gravity wells, but trees have leaves so that's not impossible. They wouldn't be exactly like any plants we currently know.
Fil wrote:The Space Whale oil trade will be a much needed boost to Earth's economy.
I see Earth as much like the sea the fishes left, nice to go back to occasionally, but hopefully not altogether necessary. The fish/amphibians had to go back to water to breed, so I'd like to limit that analogy.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.