gravy wrote:And a link to a forum post from 4 years ago?
Yes did you read the post I linked? That forum post quotes the exact article I was referring to, which is lifted from the NHS Direct website. Despite your talking about a 'forum post' you CAN see that I'm not talking about a forum post right?
gravy wrote:the NHS seemed to have removed it from their site.
Yeah I think we can agree on that one, I mentioned that on page 2 of this thread 3 odd months ago, you know the post you keep referring to. Also a few posts back.. twice!
gravy wrote:I've talked to my doctor about the long term effects of low carb diets and ketosis. He doesn't like the idea in general but also admits there's no significant medium term risk with it either. He's -very- pleased about my general health improvement though. This pretty much backs up most of the stuff I've read about it too.
That's great, in fairness you can read any old shit on the internet. Also I think that's the first time anyone's mentioned advice from a Doctor so far.
gravy wrote:As for the low carb / ketosis thing. You can go into ketosis on a low carb diet, it doesn't have to be zero carb.
Well as I keep saying this is back from 2007 with the focus on a 3 week diet, not an ongoing permanent diet change which in 2007 there was less data(?) on. Take my comments from page two in that light since that's where I was coming from, as I keep saying.
In response: no it doesn't have to be zero carb, but from my experience over that period it does have to be very very low carb. At the levels you've quoted me as saying above as I say : I've been there and done it (more than once), encouraged work colleagues to do the same, watch some succeed some fail. Talked to those that failed, given them pointers, seen them succeed. And so on.
I am measuring ketosis by a positive indicator on a set of ketostix which is an indicator (of something or other, some ketone?) in your urine. Which I think is generally accepted to be the state which is referred to as ketosis.
gravy wrote:I just don't think your enthusiasm to nit pick matches the effort you've put in to actually research this stuff.
Slow down cowboy, who's nitpicking?
You keep quoting stuff from 24 pages back and pulling me up on it, while I've sat here repeatedly telling you for umpteen posts that you're misconstruing what I've said and taking it out of context.
Bear in mind this whole rig-ma-role's only started up because you felt like pointing a finger after 24 pages while at the same time being a bit confused as to what I actually wrote. I think that's a fair assessment isn't it?