Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Couple of good podcast interviews with Gary Taubes which give a nice bite-size overview on the low carb logic.
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/undergroun ... ary-taubes
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/gabwiththe ... we-get-fat
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/undergroun ... ary-taubes
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/gabwiththe ... we-get-fat
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
I apologise for posting reliable information!gravy wrote:To be honest if it's a choice between personal experience and anecdotal evidence from people on here vs reading up a load of stuff on the internet then it's not a hard choice where to place trust.
People who are not sick don't need to eat "low carb".. they can eat "normal carb" (<-- = "what should be normal") .. ie. 30-40% something like that. Low carb and starvation diets are especially beneficial for people with specific issues. You know that! Where's the beef?gravy wrote:I'll pick up on this as you've alluded to "It's great if you're sick!" a few times now.(o)(o) wrote:Low carb is indicated for persons who are down the metabolic syndrome road as it can reverse some of its effects.
Yeah thanks for that really helpful!gravy wrote:gravy wrote:Out of interest how are you doing on this? Everyone else is posting their weight loss achievements...You just have to get on with things.(o)(o) wrote:Two close friends died in the last month. Lost focus.
I think I did pretty well to maintain the same weight.
Nope.gravy wrote:This may be uncharitable but it's coming across as if you almost want there to be flaws in any system because it's the fault of the approach rather than the individuals own efforts.
"I'm sure you won't allow that to happen" is what I said.gravy wrote:Being told I'm just going to get fat again eventually? It's not such a great read.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Tell us when you start eh?(o)(o) wrote:I apologise for posting reliable information!gravy wrote:To be honest if it's a choice between personal experience and anecdotal evidence from people on here vs reading up a load of stuff on the internet then it's not a hard choice where to place trust.
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
You're the one advocating anecdotal evidence over research ! ?gravy wrote:Tell us when you start eh?(o)(o) wrote:I apologise for posting reliable information!gravy wrote:To be honest if it's a choice between personal experience and anecdotal evidence from people on here vs reading up a load of stuff on the internet then it's not a hard choice where to place trust.
I first posted the worlds largest and longest comparison of four popular diets using real-world conditions by Stanford, presented by Professor Christopher Gardner PhD.. here about half way down. If you skip forward to about 46 minutes you can see the weightloss results for yourself.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Here you go.. individual weightloss after 12 month, by person, by diet (Ornish, Zone, Tradtional, Atkins).. circled are people who lost at least 15 Kgs..


Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
I don't think they're relevant to me or my experience. I'm not saying they didn't find what they claimed but you're posting adherence rates for people on diets that don't necessarily want to be on diets but do happen to be on the study.
I am in no way surprised that the drop out rates and relapses are similar on both approaches. Personal will and motivation are big factor success for -any- change in your dietary habits. The only point being made by a lot of people is that this requires less will power than standard restricted calorie approach. Despite what others have experienced on here you don't want to accept that. Fine
I'm more confident in my personal experience that your internet trawling.
The other claim is that less carbs will probably benefit key health indicators whether you have a chronic disease or not. You don't seem to like that either despite the studies many studies confirming that.
The implication of what you're saying is that the positive experiences of people on here are either transitory or delusory.
What I don't get is the cost to admission to some actual experience in this is incredibly low. Sorry for your loss in the last month or so but you've been at this for 2 months now. Man, even the first week is a revelation for a lot of people. Have you nothing to say about time you've been trying this?
I am in no way surprised that the drop out rates and relapses are similar on both approaches. Personal will and motivation are big factor success for -any- change in your dietary habits. The only point being made by a lot of people is that this requires less will power than standard restricted calorie approach. Despite what others have experienced on here you don't want to accept that. Fine
The other claim is that less carbs will probably benefit key health indicators whether you have a chronic disease or not. You don't seem to like that either despite the studies many studies confirming that.
The implication of what you're saying is that the positive experiences of people on here are either transitory or delusory.
What I don't get is the cost to admission to some actual experience in this is incredibly low. Sorry for your loss in the last month or so but you've been at this for 2 months now. Man, even the first week is a revelation for a lot of people. Have you nothing to say about time you've been trying this?
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Is that the menopausal women study you laughed at earlier in the thread? It's the only Gardner study I can find. It's only 311 people. Funnily enough it finds the lowest carb option had the best results(o)(o) wrote:Here you go.. individual weightloss after 12 month, by person, by diet (Ornish, Zone, Tradtional, Atkins).. circled are people who lost at least 15 Kgs..
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
It's the youtube video he posted..gravy wrote:Is that the menopausal women study you laughed at earlier in the thread? It's the only Gardner study I can find. It's only 311 people. Funnily enough it finds the lowest carb option had the best results
The case for low-carbohydrate diets is gaining weight. Christopher Gardner, PhD, assistant professor of medicine at the Stanford Prevention Research Center, has completed the largest and longest-ever comparison of four popular diets using real-world conditions, which he discusses - the lowest-carbohydrate Atkins diet came out on top.
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Yeah
Which I am pretty sure is this one:
http://livinlavidalowcarb.com/blog/stan ... ealth/1620
We're through the looking glass now, earlier (o)(o) mocks a study that used post menopausal women as subjects because it doesn't agree with his point of view.
Now he's citing a study of menopausal women to back him even though on closer examination doesn't seem to do that at all.
What (o)(o) has proved unequivocally is that nit picking on the internet has zero effect on your health. If you don't try anything then you're completely safe from any improvements

http://livinlavidalowcarb.com/blog/stan ... ealth/1620
We're through the looking glass now, earlier (o)(o) mocks a study that used post menopausal women as subjects because it doesn't agree with his point of view.
Now he's citing a study of menopausal women to back him even though on closer examination doesn't seem to do that at all.
What (o)(o) has proved unequivocally is that nit picking on the internet has zero effect on your health. If you don't try anything then you're completely safe from any improvements

- SpookyElectric1
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 704
- Joined: Fri Nov 15, 2002 2:27 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: SpookyElectric1
- PSN: SpookyElectric1
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Since January I've been trying to lose weight. Kicked off the year with a low fat diet and some exercise and the first week or two had some good results (however a lot of that was just the Christmas bulge which I'd only really put on over a week). Kept this up as best I could but, in all honesty, it was tough going with plenty of falling off the wagon.
So, around the middle of March I decided to switch to a lower carb diet. Not totally low carb but keeping a watch and avoiding too much rice, pasta, bread and potatoes. Still have them every now and then, but in much reduced doses. Here's a chart of how the year's gone so far.

Can you spot when the lower carbing started?
The great thing is it's so much easier to stick to. I'm hardly ever hungry or craving between meals, exercise is easier and the results just spur me on to lose more!
So, around the middle of March I decided to switch to a lower carb diet. Not totally low carb but keeping a watch and avoiding too much rice, pasta, bread and potatoes. Still have them every now and then, but in much reduced doses. Here's a chart of how the year's gone so far.

Can you spot when the lower carbing started?
The great thing is it's so much easier to stick to. I'm hardly ever hungry or craving between meals, exercise is easier and the results just spur me on to lose more!
Spotify link https://open.spotify.com/artist/5uOFLgF ... z2ZCYde28Q.
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
Don't be silly! That can't possibly be right, even though it ties in with the experience of just about everyone else on here, and elsewhere that's actually tried a low-carb approach.SpookyElectric1 wrote:Can you spot when the lower carbing started?
The great thing is it's so much easier to stick to. I'm hardly ever hungry or craving between meals, exercise is easier and the results just spur me on to lose more!
I'm sure tits will be along shortly to prove to you categorically (by citing something he may or may not have heard on a knitting forum) that you're imagining all that.
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
I did not laugh at that study.gravy wrote:Is that the menopausal women study you laughed at earlier in the thread?
I quetioned the relevance of the article because as it says :
"Objective: The objective was to investigate associations between dietary macronutrients and progression of coronary atherosclerosis among postmenopausal women.
Design: Quantitative coronary angiography was performed at baseline and after a mean follow-up of 3.1 y in 2243 coronary segments in 235 postmenopausal women with established coronary heart disease. Usual dietary intake was assessed at baseline.
"Conclusions: In postmenopausal women with relatively low total fat intake, a greater saturated fat intake is associated with less progression of coronary atherosclerosis, whereas carbohydrate intake is associated with a greater progression. "
Gardner has participated in at least 46 studies :gravy wrote:It's the only Gardner study I can find.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term ... d=17341711#
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
He's probably got 3 hats as well, which is about as relevant.
I mean that's the only study I can see that's he's been involved in that compares the diets you mention.
It is restricted to pre-menopausal, fat women
It does have only 311 participants for a period of 12 months (biggest longer study ever!)
And it does show that the lowest carbohydrate option is the most effective.
Or am I missing something here?
As for the other stuff. You question the relevance of one study because of the people taking part but this one you don't even though it has a similarly restricted participant group. I mean I made the point that given they're humans and everything there'd be some relevance to all of us. You didn't agree. Have you've changed your mind? Or you haven't? It'd be a twattish of me to reply "Are you a fat woman? lol!" though wouldn't it?
It backs up my point about your inconsistency and in turn the irrelevance of some of the stuff you're posting.
Anyway, that's it for me with you. Sort out your own path and this is a good place to share you experiences. It's a pretty wide church in here so If you want to resolutely stick to doing fuck all then just start a "Fatter, Slower, Weaker!" discussion.
I mean that's the only study I can see that's he's been involved in that compares the diets you mention.
It is restricted to pre-menopausal, fat women
It does have only 311 participants for a period of 12 months (biggest longer study ever!)
And it does show that the lowest carbohydrate option is the most effective.
Or am I missing something here?
As for the other stuff. You question the relevance of one study because of the people taking part but this one you don't even though it has a similarly restricted participant group. I mean I made the point that given they're humans and everything there'd be some relevance to all of us. You didn't agree. Have you've changed your mind? Or you haven't? It'd be a twattish of me to reply "Are you a fat woman? lol!" though wouldn't it?
It backs up my point about your inconsistency and in turn the irrelevance of some of the stuff you're posting.
Anyway, that's it for me with you. Sort out your own path and this is a good place to share you experiences. It's a pretty wide church in here so If you want to resolutely stick to doing fuck all then just start a "Fatter, Slower, Weaker!" discussion.
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
I'd say so.. plus you didn't read that graph right.. ("adherence rates".. huh??).. but you have decided you don't want a civil discussion, and to be honest that is evident in your responses lately which misrepresent my position, or a piece of information, then attack that misrepresentation, and repeat.. no wonder you see inconsistency..gravy wrote:Or am I missing something here?
How is low carb affecting your mood atm, btw??
I think the record shows I've only been respectful and civil and applauded the achievements of others including yourself.
Rik : Skimmed thrugh the thread for an overview the other day... 8 people have posted impressive weight loss results via other methods than "low carb".. 13 posted positive low-carb results.. 4 of those stalled, a couple regained more weight and a few reservations have been expressed. Good luck whatever method you choose.
P S If only pro low-carb discussion is to be entertained in this thead the title ought to be changed.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!
OK. I get the message. The guy on the left isn't trying hard enough.gravy wrote:
Has anybody reading this tried the RAW or RAW vegan diet?
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
