gravy wrote:MS had to take a one off charge to cover the maximum cost of replacing the consoles from the business. It was $1bn.
This stuff -has- to be above board as MS is a publicly traded business. Just making up a figure that's one eighth of the actual cost would be mental.
In your reasoning you're assuming that the replacement cost is the same as the retail cost of the console.
My reasoning is the replacement cost is
higher. Estimates at the time were that the parts in the Xbox 360 were worth far more than the retail price, and that's before assembly, distribution, marketing costs. That's normal: consoles are sold at a loss and the money's made back from games sales and other content. But it makes problem with hardware that require units to be replaced very expensive.
I don't doubt that the Xbox 360 would have been profitable, or at least broke even, without the RROD problem. But with that it lost money. But it doesn't need to make money for MS. Their other divisions are still very profitable and have been able to carry the Entertainment and Devices division through its losses.
